Hage’s high-level panel disappoints

High-Level Panel on the Namibian Economy has turned a blind eye to the real threats to investments and many of their recommendations on fixing the economy are weak and vague.

28 July 2020 | Economics

It is rather like a doctor not mentioning smoking to a patient with lung cancer. - IPPR

Jo-Maré Duddy – The fact that president Hage Geingob’s economic think tank ignored proposed empowerment legislation as a key impediment to investment in Namibia is a “clear dereliction of duty for anyone whose duty it is to present an honest view of the challenges facing policymakers”, the Institute of Public Policy Reseach (IPPR) says.

“It is rather like a doctor not mentioning smoking to a patient with lung cancer,” the IPPR says in its latest quarterly economic review, which includes an in-depth look at the recommendations of High-Level Panel on the Namibian Economy (HLPNE).

The panel, inaugurated in March 2019, had to advise Geingob for the remainder of his first term in office. It consisted of 22 people from inside and outside government, as well as three international experts and was chaired by Johannes !Gawaxab, who has since been appointed as the governor of the Bank of Namibia (BoN).

The HLPNE submitted its final report on the state of the economy and evidence-based recommendations that would result in its revival in February, just weeks before a state of emergency was declared and Namibia went into lockdown.

According to the IPPR, the report “implicitly recognises the need to attract FDI [foreign direct investment] and identifies policy uncertainty as a major barrier”. Despite this, the report “shrinks” from making the link with the National Equitable Economic Empowerment Bill (NEEEB) and the Namibia Investment Promotion Act (NIPA) – “the greatest barriers of all”, the IPPR says.

“Surprisingly, despite their centrality to the investment environment in Namibia, they are not mentioned once,” the IPPR says.

“The report ducks this politically-sensitive issue completely and glaringly ignores the fact that there will be significant costs in reforming the economy to create a private sector export-led economy that creates jobs for the masses,” it elaborates.

According to the IPPR, the HLPNE report also does not go far enough to emphasise policymakers’ “appalling track record on creating an investment environment that fosters job creation”.

‘Strategic bets’

The HLPNE report however, is “spot on” when it says “growth must come from exports and investment activities that promotes exports”, that “export structure hasn’t changed much”, that “Namibia needs to increase the complexity of its product space” and that formal sector employment growth can only be achieved by targeting industries that lead to export diversification.

The IPPR also agrees with the panel that the current Namibia Investment Centre is “re-invigorated, refreshed and re-energised into an Export Promotion Centre with a mandate focused on export promotion and the promotion of investments focused on the export markets as well as the local market”.

However, the HLPNE is on “more questionable ground” when it says this diversification will come about by government making “strategic bets and choosing sectors”.

The HLPNE report also states that “a key factor to be considered within the attractiveness of potential industrial opportunities shall be their potential to insert themselves within global value chains where Namibia has and or will have a comparative advantage. Such value chains can ultimately brand Namibia as the hub for certain products.”

According to the IPPR, the HLPNE “sensibly” goes on to recommend that “ultimately, policymakers should use an iterative and dynamic process to target investment promotion and export diversification efforts, and should interact with many stakeholders – especially with the private sector – to incorporate a variety of perspectives and to implement shared strategies”.

‘Passing the buck’

The HLPNE report fails to recognise that a “bloated and overpaid public sector draws resources and talent away from the rest of the economy”. It also does not compare the “resources devoted to keeping ailing established SOEs alive (such as the billions squandered on keeping Air Namibia flying) to those targeted at new industries”, the IPPR says.

“It then somewhat passes the buck, rather surprisingly to the National Planning Commission which since Independence has hardly demonstrated an ability to conduct sophisticated policy of making ‘strategic bets and choosing sectors’,” the IPPR says.

The report has little to offer other than more committees, the IPPR comments on the following stance of the HLPNE: “Following that guidance, we recommend the creation of public-private taskforces – productivity taskforces – an institutional device for exploring interventions that increase the productivity of sectors with export potential of already existing sectors.”

According to the IPPR: “While it cannot be wrong to say ‘it is essential that the government establishes and maintains a broader permanent public-private dialogue forum, incorporating senior government officials and representatives of the private sector’, it fails to make the point that in so many cases, government action has been premature and misconceived and does an enormous about of damage.”

Jobs

The HLPNE’s recommendations on employment creation are “weak’, the IPPR says.

The panel correctly asserts that “creating economic policy certainty and removing bottlenecks will result in an improved economic and investment climate, which is paramount for job creation”. However, it fails to pinpoint policy uncertainties or bottlenecks or indeed any real analysis of the incentives or disincentives to employ labour (especially unskilled labour), the IPPR continues.

The panel’s recommendations focus on tertiary and higher education (Industry 4.0 Workers) and industry-university collaboration and internships, national programmes for innovation ecosystems, and a country strategy for the fourth industrial revolution IR 4.0.

“These are initiatives which, even if things go well, will take years or possibly decades to bear fruit,” the IPPR says.

“The more pressing need for the economy to absorb large numbers of unskilled workers currently unemployed or underemployed in the informal sector is left to an export-promotion strategy for grapes, meat processing and charcoal manufacturing.

“Certainly, grapes and charcoal manufacturing are industries which have already enjoyed a certain amount of growth and may have further potential but the report does not make clear what policy can do to accelerate this and it is all rather vague,” the IPPR says.

Similar News

 

Mutorwa inaugurates new Transportation Commission

13 hours ago | Economics

Minister of works and transport John Mutorwa inaugurated the newly-appointed members of the Transportation Commission of Namibia.President Hage Geingob appointed the members in accordance with...

DBN supports Omboga powdered spinach soup

13 hours ago | Economics

Development Bank of Namibia (DBN) has celebrated the culmination of its support to 2018 Innovation Award winner VNA Foods at the launch of the fledgling...

Libya seeks to revive oil industry

13 hours ago | Economics

Libya's National Oil Company said it expected oil production to rise to 260 000 barrels per day (bpd) next week, as the OPEC member looks...

Uganda's public debt surges in coronavirus crisis

13 hours ago | Economics

Uganda's public debt surged 20.5% in the 12 months to June as the east African country soaked up new credit to help deal with the...

Payroll deductions strengthens the collateral base

1 day - 28 September 2020 | Economics

Payroll deductions strengthen the collateral base of borrowers, which has a major impact on credit deepening, a report on Namibia’s experience with microlending and payroll...

Shivute vows to hunt tax dodgers

1 day - 28 September 2020 | Economics

OGONE TLHAGEThe newly appointed commissioner of the Namibia Revenue Agency (Namra), Sam Shivute, has vowed to chase after tax defaulters in his new position. ...

Kamanjab residents owe N$ 10 mln for water

1 day - 28 September 2020 | Economics

The outstanding water bill of Kamanjab residents has accumulated to N$ 10 million after local authorities were given a directive to reconnect water for residents...

Agriculture, ICT, health drives growth

1 day - 28 September 2020 | Economics

The Namibian Statistics Agency (NSA) recorded improved performances in the agriculture and forestry, Information and communication technology (ICT) and health sectors, according to the Producer...

Nigeria's central bank cuts lending rate

1 day - 28 September 2020 | Economics

By Alexis AkwagyiramNigeria's central bank cut its benchmark lending rate by 100 basis points to 11.5% in a surprise move aimed at stimulating growth in...

Government wage index increases in Q2

4 days ago - 25 September 2020 | Economics

PHILLEPUS UUSIKU The government wage index stood at 133.0 basis points during the second quarter of 2020, an increase of 0.9 percent, compared to an...

Latest News

DBN supports Omboga powdered spinach...

13 hours ago | Economics

Development Bank of Namibia (DBN) has celebrated the culmination of its support to 2018 Innovation Award winner VNA Foods at the launch of the fledgling...

PG Imalwa faces exit

13 hours ago | Government

WINDHOEKELLANIE SMITWith the term of Prosecutor-General Martha Imalwa ending this year, the Judicial Service Commission (JSC) has advertised the position of the principal state legal...

Namibian link in SA sex...

13 hours ago | Crime

OGONE TLHAGE AND TUYEIMO HAIDULAWINDHOEK/OSHAKATISouth Africa's elite Directorate for Priority Crime Investigation, known as the Hawks, has unravelled a transborder trafficking syndicate, with some of...

Knowledge is not in my...

13 hours ago | Politics

OGONE TLHAGEWINDHOEKIndependent Patriots for Change (IPC) leader Panduleni Itula says he is not open to debating Walvis Bay Urban constituency councillor Knowledge Ipinge, who he...

Remaining powerful through education

13 hours ago | People

Ester Kamati With a key interest in space science and the history of science, watching videos on these topics is Hosea Hashili’s favourite pastime. Hasili...

Libya seeks to revive oil...

13 hours ago | Economics

Libya's National Oil Company said it expected oil production to rise to 260 000 barrels per day (bpd) next week, as the OPEC member looks...

Few options for the voter

13 hours ago | Opinion

With only two months left before the November regional and local authority elections, there seems to be limited political choices for the voter.There remains a...

Join the Jerusalema challenge!

13 hours ago | Events

STAFF REPORTERWINDHOEKIf there's one glimmer of positivity at the moment, it's the team spirit and feeling of unity created by the Jerusalema challenge, which is...

Day of the Namibian Child

13 hours ago | Opinion

Lee-Ann Forbes Being able to go to school and to get free education. And having rights that protect me as a Namibian child. Also being...

Load More