Teek fails in compensation bid

03 May 2021 | Justice

Marc Springer



WINDHOEK

Nearly 11 years after he was acquitted on charges of abducting and raping two minor girls, former Supreme Court judge Pio Teek has finally failed in his bid to obtain compensation for alleged malicious prosecution and defamation.

The decisive defeat results from a judgment delivered in the Supreme Court on Friday in which judges Jeremiah Shongwe, Ernest Sakala and Moses Chinhengo dismissed an appeal Teek had filed against a previous ruling made by judge Herman Oosthuizen in March 2018.

In that judgment, Ooshuizen concluded that Teek had no basis for a lawsuit in which he was claiming N$6.87 million in damages from the justice minister and the Ombudsman for their alleged failure to assist him in trying to sue three foreign judges who set aside his acquittal on child molestation charges.

The protracted litigation has a long history dating back to January 2005 when Teek was first charged with kidnapping and sexually assaulting two underage girls.

These charges, on which Teek was eventually acquitted in December 2010, stemmed from allegations that on the evening of 28 January 2005, he abducted the minors - then nine and 10 years old respectively - from Katutura and brought them to his house in Brakwater outside Windhoek, where he allegedly compelled them to consume alcohol and sexually molested them.

His initial compensation claim emanated from two judgments delivered in the Supreme Court on 21 July 2008 and 28 April 2009.

Not guilty - again

In the first of those, judges Piet Streicher, Kenneth Muthiyane und Fritz Brand granted an appeal by the State against a previous acquittal of Teek. In the second ruling, the same judges set the acquittal aside completely and referred the matter back to the High Court, where Teek was eventually found not guilty again on 16 December 2010.

Teek took exception to those judgments, arguing they neglected to consider facts in his favour and created the impression that he was guilty.

As a result, he sued for damages and requested the registrar of the High Court to have his summons served on the three judges in South Africa. When that didn´t happen and judge Nicholas Ndau dismissed his claim for damages, Teek sued the justice minister and Ombudsman, arguing they hadn‘t done enough to assist him to have the summons served on the three judges, and were therefore liable for the damages he had originally claimed from the previous defendants.

That claim was dismissed by judge Oosthuizen, who concluded that the local High Court did not have jurisdiction over the three foreign judges, as they were not present in Namibia when Teek sued them and he didn‘t show that they were domiciled in Namibia, possessed Namibian citizenship or had property in the country.

In their ruling on Friday, the judges agreed echoed Oosthuizen’s sentiments.

As a result, there was no need to deal with the merits of the case which stood to be dismissed on the point of jurisdiction alone. The verdict being handed down ends Teek‘s quest for compensation and brings to a close one of the longest litigations in Namibian legal history.

Similar News

 

Govt ‘forced’ NTB into Kora deal

4 hours ago | Justice

ELLANIE SMIT WINDHOEK The legal team of Kora All Africa Music Awards founder Ernst Adjovi says the Namibian Tourism Board (NTB)...

Kora trial: We were misled, says NTB

1 day - 05 May 2021 | Justice

ELLANIE SMIT WINDHOEK The Namibia Tourism Board (NTB) was misled and wrongly made to believe that the organisers of the failed...

Police can’t find army general’s stock theft accomplice

1 day - 05 May 2021 | Justice

Kenya Kambowe RUNDUThe second suspect in a stock-theft case involving former Namibia Defence Force (NDF) Major-General Thomas Hamuyela is nowhere to...

Teek fails in compensation bid

3 days ago - 03 May 2021 | Justice

Marc Springer WINDHOEKNearly 11 years after he was acquitted on charges of abducting and raping two minor girls, former Supreme Court judge...

City Police slammed for 'arresting babies'

6 days ago - 30 April 2021 | Justice

JEMIMA BEUKESWINDHOEKThe City Police have come under fire for arresting seven minors, including nursing babies, and two pregnant women when they rounded up a group...

Kora dirty laundry to be aired next week

1 week ago - 29 April 2021 | Justice

ELLANIE SMIT WINDHOEKA controversial legal battle involving millions of dollars lost in an aborted music...

Hospitality outfits hunt down Old Mutual, Hollard over Covid...

1 week ago - 27 April 2021 | Justice

MARC SPRINGERWINDHOEKFollowing a N$638 million lawsuit against Hollard Insurance by Gondwana Selection Namibia, three more hospitality establishments are now attempting to force their insurers to...

Cash is king for James

1 week ago - 23 April 2021 | Justice

JEMIMA BEUKESWINDHOEKIndictment documents laid before the High Court at yesterday’s pretrial of the so-called Fishrot bribery case show that James Hatuikulipi received the lion’s share...

PG fingers Swapo in N$82m Fishrot loot

1 week ago - 23 April 2021 | Justice

MATHIAS HAUFIKUWINDHOEKIndictment papers filed by in the High Court by the prosecutor-general allege that the ruling party benefited from the N$82 million that was earmarked...

Judiciary tackles bottlenecks

1 week ago - 23 April 2021 | Justice

TUYEIMO HAIDULAOSHAKATI Chief Justice Peter Shivute on Wednesday called for combined efforts to help improve the justice system, stating that the police, magistrates and courts...

Latest News

N$278m payment for Air Namibia...

4 hours ago | Transport

OGONE TLHAGE WINDHOEKGovernment has paid part of N$278 million reserved for ex-gratia payments to...

Kora exposing political rot

4 hours ago | Opinion

The ongoing Kora trial is not just a civil matter between two parties contesting contractual interpretations and millions of dollars lost.Preliminary evidence points to a...

No corruption at fisheries –...

4 hours ago | Ministries

OGONE TLHAGE WINDHOEKNew fisheries minister Derek Klazen says the ministry is not plagued with corruption, contrary to public opinion.He made the comment...

UN highlights midwife shortage

4 hours ago | Health

JEMIMA BEUKES WINDHOEKA recent United Nations (UN) report has raised alarm over a...

Namibia-Angola border should be opened...

4 hours ago | International

NAMPAWINDHOEKThe continued closure of the Namibia-Angola border due to measures put in place to combat Covid-19 obstructs the legal free movement of people and goods...

Swapo unity in Kavango East...

4 hours ago | Politics

KENYA KAMBOWERUNDUWhile Swapo Kavango East regional coordinator Ottilie Shinduvi says all is well, some members have described the party's regional arm as a sinking ship.And...

Community hostels must shape up

4 hours ago | Education

KENYA KAMBOWERUNDUThe days are numbered for community hostels which misappropriate state funds and fail to produce audited financial reports.The education ministry has vowed not to...

Nakathila's toughest test draws near

4 hours ago | Sports

LIMBA MUPETAMIWINDHOEKWhether Jeremiah 'Low-Key' Nakathila is the king of the super featherweight division will be determined in the next couple of months with interesting competition...

Coe applauds organisers

4 hours ago | Sports

NAMPA/REUTERSWorld Athletics chief Sebastian Coe on Wednesday gave Tokyo Olympic organisers high marks for a marathon test event they staged in Sapporo, saying they were...

Load More