Stormy seas ahead

The scientific fraternity in Namibia is deeply concerned about the mismanagement of ocean resources.

06 July 2017 | Fishing

The worst culprits responsible for the poor health status of Namibia's ocean and possible future job losses in the fishing industry, as well as the threat of extinction of several marine resources, are weak governance structures, lack of political will and the inflated power of fishing companies.

Following a United Nations conference on the state of the world's oceans, the Namibian scientific community strongly agrees that Namibians should be deeply worried about the poor health of Namibia's marine resources, the lack of oversight of fishing practices, and the lack of political will to reverse the decline in the ocean's health.

A major concern is that scientific research and advice are often ignored, despite the economic and environmental consequences.

One recent example of the sidelining of scientists was the announcement by fisheries minister Bernhardt Esau of a 14 000-ton pilchard quota for 2017, undeterred by grave warnings from marine biologists that the pilchard stock had slumped to just over 1% of its former population and could be extinct soon if not allowed to recover.

Scientists have explained that a temporary ban on pilchard fishing as well as implementing strict by-catch penalties and engaging with neighbouring countries to institute similar strategies would not only allow the species to recuperate, but also boost jobs and resurrect the pilchard industry.

“Current harvesting levels are at a few thousand tonnes per year. With a recovered resource, we could be sustainably harvesting about a quarter of a million tonnes per year,” doctor of zoology and CEO of Namibia Chamber of Environment (NCE) Chris Brown told Namibian Sun.

He added that in the interim, “we could be substituting imported pilchards to keep the industry going – which is essentially what is happening at the moment, so small is our local catch.”

Explanations by the fisheries ministry that the likely loss of about 600 jobs in the sector took precedence over the risk of a collapsed pilchard population were dismissed by Brown.

“Any suggestions that we cannot do this because we need to keep the pilchard industry alive to protect jobs is just nonsense. We could vastly increase the number of jobs if we allowed the pilchard resource to recover.”

The cost of profit

The fishing industry's focus on profit, to the detriment of the ocean's health, and government's willingness to turn a blind eye are key problems contributing to the state of affairs.

“The industry is largely geared to greed and profit, with little thought of sustainability. Lip service is often paid by government who want scientists to provide information, and then to go away,” a marine biologist, who asked to remain anonymous for fear of retribution, told the newspaper.

And although “there are a range of efforts to improve political awareness, I am just not sure whether the penny has dropped at the right places yet. And when Minister Esau decides to give out a pilchard quota contrary to what his scientists recommend, then I don't think political awareness is sufficient,” another scientist, who also spoke anonymously, said.

The scientist added that while a range of measures have been formulated to address some of Namibia's challenges “many of them are paper dragons and are not implemented, are not implementable, or stagnate and end up on some bureaucrat's desk.”

The scientist added that political and public awareness on the deeply troubling state of the ocean is low.

Yet the lack of institutional integrity and strength, as well as transparency, is crippling the sector, scientists agree.

“Institutional weaknesses are at the heart of the problem. There is little transparency in the entire fisheries management process. Stock assessment data is kept out of the public domain. The methodology used and thus quality of data cannot be assessed and discussed openly. The process of deciding quotas for the different species is also kept out of the public domain,” Brown said.

Brown underlined that the fisheries scientists have “insufficient influence” and instead “commercial fishing companies have far too much influence, compounded by political decisions not based on scientific advice”.

Threat of extinction ignored

The impact of collapsed pilchard stock is most obviously reflected in coastal and marine seabirds, the scientists explained.

The African penguin population in Namibia has declined by more than 50% in the last three penguin generations, mainly because of a loss of the pilchard prey base.

The Bank cormorant has also experienced a greater than 50% decline in population in Namibia, for the same reason.

The Cape cormorant is declining, and the Cape gannet, over its last three generations, has declined by a massive 84%, mainly related to availability of food – pilchards.

“These trends would be similarly reflected in many aquatic species in the oceans, which are less easy to monitor, including some commercial fish species,” Brown explained.

A crucial difference could be made with the application of environmental impact assessments to the fishing industry, Brown said.

Currently, these are not applied but their implementation, as well as enforcing the fishing sector to have environmental management plans, could address several issues.

“We need to see a total reform of the way that the marine ecosystem and the marine fisheries in Namibia are managed,” he concluded.

He added that the country needs to establish a coastal and marine council, comprising of multiple agencies, both governmental and non-governmental, to provide oversight and to ensure that appropriate, transparent processes are in place.

“Until we do, our marine ecosystem will continue to be mismanaged, to the detriment of our economy and environment.”


Similar News


Tough luck for you

6 days ago - 19 September 2018 | Fishing

Fisheries minister Bernhardt Esau says government will no longer tolerate the selling off of fishing quotas, so people can make a quick buck.He made these...

5 193 fishing applications

2 weeks ago - 06 September 2018 | Fishing

The Ministry of Fisheries and Marine Resources says a total of 5 190 fishing rights applications were received by 31 August for the 90 to...

Over 5 000 fishing rights applicants

2 weeks ago - 05 September 2018 | Fishing

The fisheries ministry this afternoon said a total of 5 190 fishing rights applications were received by 31 August for the 90 to 120 rights...

Thousands put hope in fishing

3 weeks ago - 04 September 2018 | Fishing

The Business and Intellectual Property Authority (Bipa), the government agency registering companies, saw an unheard-of spike in registrations of companies towards the end of last...

Kwa ningwa omalunduluko momaindilo guumwene wokukwata oohi

1 month - 27 July 2018 | Fishing

Sha landula omanyenyeto ngoka ga ningwa koshigwana kombinga yiipumbiwa yimwe po tayi pumbiwa kwaamboka yahala okuninga omaindilo guuthemba wuumwene wokukwata oohi, uuministeli woonzo dhomomeya...

Look beyond fishing - ministry

3 months ago - 13 June 2018 | Fishing

Fisheries ministry national coordinator Anna Erastus says it will not be the end of the world if people are not successful with their fishing rights...

'Leave no one behind' is lip service

3 months ago - 05 June 2018 | Fishing

Questions continue to be raised about the government's stated intention to leave no one behind in contrast to seemingly excluding criteria as related to the...

Fishing quotas for elite, says PDM

3 months ago - 31 May 2018 | Fishing

The national chairperson of the Popular Democratic Movement (PDM), Jennifer van den Heever, said despite the country's vast natural riches that fishing quotas, among others,...

Scramble for fishing rights starts

3 months ago - 30 May 2018 | Fishing

The floodgates have opened after the long-anticipated announcement of new fishing rights up for grabs and all Namibians, particularly the formerly disadvantaged, are encouraged to...

All eyes on Fishcor quota

4 months ago - 30 April 2018 | Fishing

Once a crippled State-owned entity, Fishcor has resurged to becoming a profitable entity on the back of a horse mackerel quota allocation that has brought...

Latest News

Chinese swoop on Rössing

16 hours ago | Business

CATHERINE SASMAN State firm China National Nuclear Corporation (CNNC) is said to be in pole position to acquire the majority...

RDP bungles councillor’s resignation

16 hours ago | Politics

KENYA KAMBOWEA former Rally for Democracy and Progress (RDP) town councillor, who resigned from the party about seven weeks ago, says he is still receiving...

Asparagus project in Omusati boosted

16 hours ago | Business

Namibia's first-ever asparagus agro-processing factory will be sustained by a 360-hectare production area once full capacity is reached.A 60 ha plantation is already underway at...

Kalkfeld business market for free

16 hours ago | Business

A public market at the Kalkfeld business park under the Namibia Development Corporation (NDC) will be leased to the Otjozondjupa Regional Council (ORC) from October...

Swapo elders ‘ignorant’

16 hours ago | Politics

JEMIMA BEUKES The Damara King’s Council has branded the Swapo Party Elders’ Council ignorant following its suggestion last week that...

Entrepreneurs: When the going gets...

16 hours ago | Banking

Entrepreneurs are people are skilled at adapting and being resilient in uncertain situations and come up with new, different and innovative ideas.“The challenges currently being...

TransNamib’s shocking meltdown

16 hours ago | Columns

The Namibia Transport and Allied Workers Union (Natau) has become the latest organisation to hit out at the TransNamib board for alleged interference. The Paul...

Laughter is the best medicine

16 hours ago | Health

Henriette Lamprecht – It’s contagious and good medicine – not only for the body, but for the mind and soul as well. It lightens your...

Smelling the roses is not...

16 hours ago | Health

In today’s rat race it’s easy to lose your way in the daily grind while trying to keep your head above water. Our responsibilities as...

Load More