Meatco board unlawful

28 November 2018 | Justice

The appointment of the six-member board of Meatco by former agriculture minister John Mutorwa was unlawful.

The High Court this week ruled that the appointment made on 16 February last year was in conflict with the Meatco Act, the Public Enterprises Governance Act and the Namibian constitution.

The court application was brought by five farmers - Amon Ngavetene, Elia Fasa Kandjii, Peter Kazongominja, Gottfriedt Tsuseb and Tjakazapi Janson Mbunguha.

The board members were Martha Namundjebo-Tilahun (chairperson), Ronald Kubas, Sophia Kasheeta, Ismael Ngangane, Fanie Oosthuizen and Mushokobanji Mwilima. Oostuizen is not on the board anymore.

The respondents in the matter were Meatco, the Meatco board members, Mutorwa and public enterprises minister Leon Jooste.

Judge Hosea Angula ordered the respondents to pay the applicants' costs.

The five livestock farmers argued that Mutorwa had no power in terms of the Meatco Act or the Public Enterprises Governance Act to appoint a new board on 16 February last year, while in law there was an existing board.





According to the court papers, Mutorwa in his capacity as agriculture minister contravened the provisions of the Meatco Act, Public Enterprises Governance Act and Article 18 of the Namibian constitution when he appointed the Meatco board in February 2017.

According to the farmers, Mutorwa on 4 October 2013 appointed members to the Meatco board for a three-year term.

Then, on 27 September 2016, Mutorwa extended their term by three months to 4 January 2017. He did that after a reminder had been sent to him to call a meeting where Meatco members could nominate board members. No such meeting was called.

On 21 December 2016 Mutorwa appointed the six board members as a “temporary” board for a period of six months with effect from 4 January 2017.

On 15 February 2017 Meatco and the livestock producers brought an urgent High Court application seeking an order to set aside the minister's decision and declare the board illegal.

Mutorwa settled the matter and agreed that his appointment of the temporary board be set aside.

Although the matter was settled on 17 February last year, Mutorwa had already appointed the same board permanently on 16 February.

The farmers argued that the court order regarding the matter was only issued on 15 March last year.

“It accordingly follows that Mutorwa had no power in terms of the Meatco Act, read together with the Public Enterprises Act, to take the decision to appoint a new board on 16 February 2017, while there was an existing board which still held office until 15 March 2017.”

The farmers also argued that Mutorwa had ignored their statutory role as members of Meatco when it came to the nomination of board members, while the Meatco board ignored the farmers' request that the board should resign as it was illegally appointed.

They said the Meatco Act expressly stipulates that all livestock producers registered with Meatco are automatically members and therefore also have a say in the composition of its board. They are legally authorised to nominate possible members of the board and to protect their interests in the company.

According to them Mutorwa was required to select board members from these nominees.

He disregarded that provision by first arbitrarily extending the term of the previous board and then appointing a new board without consultation with the livestock producers.

“Further, if the minister was entitled to appoint a new board on 16 February 2017 (which is denied), in so doing the minister was required to comply with the provisions of the Meatco Act in seeking nominations from interest groups,” the applicants argued.

According to the farmers no nominations were sought and they only heard about the appointment of the board in early March.

They said their dissatisfaction stemmed from the fact that a meeting had been called in August 2016 where Meatco members would have nominated people to represent them on the board.

The meeting was cancelled at short notice by the minister.

The former CEO of Meatco, Vekuii Rukoro, went ahead with a special members' meeting at which new board members were nominated.

Mutorwa rejected these nominations on the grounds that the term of office of the board had not yet lapsed.

ELLANIE SMIT

Similar News

 

Big win for Delgado-Lühl family

2 days ago - 14 October 2021 | Justice

JANA-MARI SMITH A two-year-old boy born via surrogacy to a Namibian citizen and his...

Win for Delago-Luhl family

3 days ago - 13 October 2021 | Justice

JUST IN: High court judge Thomas Masuku has granted citizenship to the son of Namibian Phillip Lühl and husband Guillermo Delgado. Yona and his twin...

Immigration under scrutiny over domicile case

3 days ago - 13 October 2021 | Justice

JANA-MARI SMITH WINDHOEKImmigration authorities and their handling of a domicile case were subjected to intense scrutiny by three of Namibia’s top judges...

NIDA sued for N$40m for cancelled projects

4 days ago - 12 October 2021 | Justice

JEMIMA BEUKES WINDHOEKThe Namibia Industrial Development Agency (NIDA) is being sued for N$40 million for services rendered by a local architectural...

Jailed secretary earned N$600k using forged qualification

4 days ago - 12 October 2021 | Justice

STAFF REPORTER WINDHOEKThe Otjiwarongo Magistrate's Court last week sentenced Ester Hihanguapo, who worked as an executive secretary for corporate services at the...

Lichtenstrasser trial: Crime scene investigators testify

1 week ago - 06 October 2021 | Justice

STAFF REPORTERIn the Lichtenstrasser murder trial involving the two murdered NIMT directors Eckhart Mueller and his deputy Heimo Hellwig, prosecutor Antonia Verhoef last Wednesday called...

Job’s red line claim ‘embarrassing’, defendants say

1 week ago - 06 October 2021 | Justice

ELLANIE SMITWINDHOEKIt has been proposed that a status hearing for the controversial red line removal court case be set for January 2022.This is according to...

Murder-accused pastors’ wives arrested for concoction deaths

2 weeks ago - 27 September 2021 | Justice

Kenya Kambowe RUNDUThe customary wives of two pastors from the Kavango West Region who stand accused of three murders and an...

No legal aid for Dippenaar in civil lawsuit

3 weeks ago - 23 September 2021 | Justice

ERWIN LEUSCHNERSWAKOPMUNDClose to seven years after a devastating traffic accident near Henties Bay, which claimed six lives, a trial date is set to be fixed...

‘She is an unruly drunkard’

3 weeks ago - 21 September 2021 | Justice

TUYEIMO HAIDULA ONDANGWA The woman accused of beating her daughter Wilka Shikongo so...

Latest News

Creativity and mental health: Where...

1 day - 15 October 2021 | Health

Kalistu R Mukoroli, PR and brand strategistWe tend to preach about being creative, but isn’t this contributing to mental health issues? Creative people always push...

Soldiers turn to AR over...

1 day - 15 October 2021 | Health

STAFF REPORTER WINDHOEKSoldiers opposed to mandatory Covid-19 vaccinations have struck a defiant tone by...

Taxing the informal sector could...

1 day - 15 October 2021 | Economics

PHILLEPSU UUSIKUGenerally, the informal sector is considered difficult to tax as it is associated with high administration costs.Research papers have shown that attempts to tax...

Learning through play

1 day - 15 October 2021 | Society

Mariselle StofbergStimuBox is an online store that produces and sells personalised sensory boxes. These boxes contain fun and simple, age-appropriate activities that help with the...

Where heart meets experience

1 day - 15 October 2021 | Health

Mariselle StofbergWith her heart of gold, fierce determination to make a difference in the lives of others and ability to persevere, Dominic le Roux continues...

Living his passion every day

1 day - 15 October 2021 | Business

Michelline Nawatises Arne Schmid was born and raised in Windhoek. He completed high school at Deutsche Höhere Privatschule Windhoek (DHPS) and finished his studies...

EDITORIAL: No to forced vaccinations

1 day - 15 October 2021 | Opinion

We must encourage vaccination with every joule of energy we have, but must never force them upon anyone.We are pro-vaccination hardliners, but not to the...

Bahr celebrates 3 decades at...

1 day - 15 October 2021 | Society

Iréne-Mari van der WaltMarinda Bahr recently celebrated her 30th year with the Swakopmund municipality. Bahr’s colleague, Marolese Niemand, says she reported for duty two months...

Motivation to achieve and...

1 day - 15 October 2021 | Motors

Emilie Mandume Dean Gaeb started his education at Outjo Primary School in 2005 and completed his secondary education in 2017 at Outjo Secondary School.Rugby was...

Load More