Lightning-fast Covid scanners spark debate
The new technology, which is said to measure a person's electromagnetic waves, has digital rights advocates worried about what data it can access.
12 July 2021 | Technology
That's the compromise you make when you come here. We signed a deal with this system in exchange for safety and security. – Anonymous consultant, Abu Dhabi
The Abu Dhabi health department says the EDE scanners can confirm a Covid-19 infection by measuring an individual's electromagnetic wave emissions, which it says are altered when the coronavirus is present.
The new system has rights groups and even some residents worried.
"I went to a mall, and instead of a temperature scan, the [security guard] appeared to be taking a picture on a cellphone," said Firas, a consultant who has been living in Abu Dhabi for nine months and asked to use a pseudonym.
He said the guard informed him that the phone camera was not only testing his electromagnetic emissions but also conducting a retina scan, which the guard said could tell him whether Firas was vaccinated or had had a recent PCR test.
Firas suspected the scanner was linked to the digital identification system used by the United Arab Emirates (UAE) to provide residents access to their health records, visa applications and other official processes.
"That's the compromise you make when you come here. We signed a deal with this system in exchange for safety and security," he said.
A media office spokesperson told the Thomson Reuters Foundation that "the scanners are not linked to any identification system and no one is identified when scanned," adding that the system neither captures nor stores any personal data.
Authorities in the UAE have relied heavily on artificial intelligence for years, including facial recognition technology.
In 2018, Dubai police launched a network of thousands of cameras – dubbed Oyoon, Arabic for "eyes" - to help them fight crime across the emirate.
After the onset of the coronavirus pandemic, UAE police deployed smart helmets to scan the temperatures of up to 200 passersby a minute, while police in Dubai pledged to publish photos of anyone violating curfew restrictions without blurring their faces.
Matt Mahmoudi, a technology researcher at Amnesty International, called it "the surveillance-for-services trade-off" often seen in smart cities.
"That particular type of facial recognition [the kind rolled out in Abu Dhabi] is worrying because the technology of mass surveillance stands to be in violation of people's right to privacy," he said over the phone.
The UAE is rated "not free" by the US-based think tank Freedom House, which said state surveillance of the internet was widespread, infringed on users' right to privacy, and did not appear to be regulated by any "meaningful legal oversight."
‘OPAQUE LEGL FRAMEWORK’
That "opaque legal framework" could specifically lead to the harassment of religious or sexual minorities in the largely conservative emirates, said Mohamad Najem, executive director of Lebanon-based digital rights group SMEX.
Khalid Ibrahim, executive director of the non-profit Gulf Centre for Human Rights, also worried the technology could lead to more surveillance of migrant workers in the UAE, which the International Labour Organisation says hosts the fifth-largest migrant population in the world.
The rollout of Abu Dhabi's new scanners "was not transparent," Ibrahim said, demanding more details from the government on how the technology works, what role facial recognition plays in it, and if security forces would have access to the results.
"These are all important questions that the government's shrinking amount of transparency have not addressed," he said. – Nampa/Reuters