Land Bill is too simplistic

One-size-fits-all is no solution

16 February 2017 | Agriculture

CATHERINE SASMAN

A paper suggests that more thorough consultation is required on the Land Bill instead of it being removed from the public eye.

The Institute for Public Policy Review (IPPR) has suggested a thorough policy review of the entire land reform process before public comments are invited or the Land Bill is tabled in the National Assembly.

It says failure to recognise and analyse some of the complex and subtle differences in land issues across the country has resulted in a ‘one-size-fits-all’ legal framework that appears to be working in some regions, was rejected in others, and was perceived as useless in communal areas that depend on livestock farming.

It says the absence of meaningful consultation in preparation of the land policy and Land Act “reflects political short-term expediency” rather than addressing real land administration and tenure issues and removes policymaking from the public eye.

“Making land policy and laws in Namibia is largely the prerogative of politicians. This risks a situation where political expediency rather than long-term solutions are reflected in policy and legislation,” the IPPR says.

It suggests that the land and agricultural sectors need to be integrated in a comprehensive agrarian reform programme.

THE BILL

The Land Bill tabled in November last year by minister of land reform Utoni Nujoma aims to consolidate and amend the Agricultural (Commercial) Land Reform Act of 1995 and the Communal Land Reform Act of 2002 to ensure that all land in Namibia has the same status.

It provides for a unitary land system where Namibian citizens have equal rights, opportunities and security with regard to land irrespective of where the land is situated.

The IPPR says although the Bill has all the hallmarks of legislation drafted without a comprehensive policy framework, it does introduce a number of positive changes to existing laws.

One of the proposed changes is that procedures to appeal against decisions in traditional authorities and land boards in communal areas have been clarified.

However, the IPPR says, whether aggrieved parties can access the proposed process remains to be seen.

The bill also provides more detail on customary land rights and the modalities of where customary land rights apply.

The IPPR says while it improves the accountability of traditional authorities in general, it does not go far enough to enforce accountability.

In the commercial farming sector the bill seems to weaken the powers and functions of the Land Reform Advisory Commission (LRAC), the IPPR says.

Here, the lands minister is empowered to take decisions on several important aspects of land reform without consulting the LRAC.

The two main farmers’ unions - the Namibia Agricultural Union (NAU) and the Namibia National Farmers Union (NNFU) - would no longer be automatically represented on the LRAC.

Regional resettlement committees are to be established but their powers and functions are not detailed in the bill.

Similar News

 

'Shame on you'

1 day - 19 October 2018 | Agriculture

The Popular Democratic Movement (PDM) has launched a social media campaign to collect funds, as it prepares to drag the government to court over its...

Ombudsman studies ‘master list’

2 days ago - 18 October 2018 | Agriculture

JEMIMA BEUKES Ombudsman John Walters says he needs time to collate and verify the resettlement master list handed to...

Billionaire playground gets green light

2 days ago - 18 October 2018 | Agriculture

Audacious moves by the land reform ministry to accommodate the Russian billionaire Rashid Sardarov have resulted in the Russian oligarch buying four farms and donating...

Small-stock scheme hotly debated

3 days ago - 17 October 2018 | Agriculture

The Livestock Producers' Organisation (LPO) last week successfully held its annual congress with a wide range of topics impacting the sector, that were discussed. ...

Erratic rain expected

3 days ago - 17 October 2018 | Agriculture

With October rains yet to fall in Namibia, dam levels are alarmingly low and the seasonal outlook for rain does not look promising. Dam levels...

Studies to guide livestock policies

4 days ago - 16 October 2018 | Agriculture

The major challenge in the small-stock farming sector has been uncontrolled exports that threaten its sustainability.This is according to agriculture minister Alpheus !Naruseb in a...

Commercial farmers come to the party

5 days ago - 15 October 2018 | Agriculture

Commercial farmers last week resolved to heed President Hage Geingob's call on land reform. This includes the improvement of farmworkers' living standards, to reduce poverty,...

Aanafaalama taya tsakaneke omupresidende ondjilakati

5 days ago - 15 October 2018 | Agriculture

ELLANIE SMIT Aanafaalama yopangeshefa oya popi kutya otaya ka yambidhidha Omupresidende Hage Geingob momaindilo ge getulululo lyomavi.Shoka osha kwatela mo okuninga omalunduluko moonkalo dhiilonga dhaaniilonga...

Studies conducted to harness flood water

1 week ago - 12 October 2018 | Agriculture

Feasibility studies are being carried out looking into the opportunities of harvesting floodwater. This is according to agriculture minister Alpheus !Naruseb, whose speech was read...

N$5.4 billion for irrigated land

1 week ago - 11 October 2018 | Agriculture

The government plans to put 21 625 hectares under irrigation over the next 12 years, which will cost N$5.4 billion. Additional grain storage facilities with...

Latest News

Nail errant nurses - Haufiku

1 day - 19 October 2018 | Health

Health ministry permanent secretary Ben Nangombe has issued a directive that no nurses may use their cellphones while on duty, and that no health facilities...

No peace for Cheryl's family

1 day - 19 October 2018 | Crime

The police are still working around the clock to catch the killer, or killers, of nine-year-old Cheryl Avihe Ujaha although there has been a lack...

Recruiting the best staff

1 day - 19 October 2018 | Supplements

Below are some tips for employers on how to go about this often arduous task.Improve your candidate poolCompanies that select new employees from the candidates...

Taking Namfisa to new and...

1 day - 19 October 2018 | Supplements

Octavia Tsibes As the deputy CEO of prudential supervision at the Namibia Financial Institutions Supervisory Authority (Namfisa), Erna Motinga is responsible for strengthening its supervisory...

Our dismal public healthcare

1 day - 19 October 2018 | Columns

There appears to be no end in sight to the many and deep-seated problems at the heart of Namibia's public healthcare sector. It goes without...

A vivacious young woman

1 day - 19 October 2018 | Supplements

Born and raised in a small village called Kayira-yira, situated eight kilometres west of Rundu, Zonia worked very hard throughout her school years and moved...

Improving sustainability through change

1 day - 19 October 2018 | Supplements

Justicia Shipena Her key role is to help Namport deliver sustainable performance improvement by utilising people. Futher focusing on how change can influence, which includes...

Airport downgrade a major threat

1 day - 19 October 2018 | Transport

Analysts believe that if Hosea Kutako International Airport (HKIA) is downgraded by the International Civil Aviation Organisation (ICAO), it would lead to massive job losses,...

'Arrogant' Utoni under fire

1 day - 19 October 2018 | Government

Land reform minister Utoni Nujoma has been described as crude, dismissive and arrogant when it comes to dealing with the media.These were the sentiments of...

Load More