Inmate loses N$3.5m lawsuit

Jonas Penovanhu Shinana claims he went blind because prison medical staff did not provide him with the necessary urgent care when he reported eye problems in January 2015.

11 October 2019 | Justice

Namibian prison services were absolved of any blame in a N$3.5 million lawsuit brought by a prisoner who accused medical officers at the Windhoek prison of negligence that led to him losing his eyesight.

Jonas Penovanhu Shinana (35) filed the lawsuit in 2017, shortly before he was sentenced to two life terms for the murder of his two sons.

He sued for N$2 million for damages, plus N$1 million for loss of amenities in life, N$100 000 for post-traumatic stress and N$400 000 for general damages and wrongful stripping of his dignity.

Shinana claimed he went blind because medical staff did not provide him with the necessary urgent care when he reported eye problems in January 2015, and that he was never informed of the potential harmful side effects of the TB medication he had been given.

Acting High Court Judge Kaijata Kangueehi dismissed Shinana's case. Kangueehi ruled that Shinana did not provide the concrete evidence required to prove negligence.

“The court sympathises with the plaintiff,” the judge said, adding that Shinana also did not provide the court with the necessary evidence on how he had calculated his claim.

The judge said although Shinana's lawyers told the court in their opening statement that they would bring evidence to support the claim, “nowhere in the evidence in chief or cross-examination did the plaintiff, in any shape or form at least explain how he quantified the damages being claimed”.

The judge further noted that documents provided to the court, including Shinana's health passport and another document highlighting the side-effects of the medication, were not enough without being corroborated by an appropriate witness.

“The court has to this point not heard evidence to the effect of proving negligence,” the judge concluded.

Moreover, Kangueehi pointed out that two witnesses who “would have gone a long way in assisting” the case were never called to testify.



Blame denied

In his founding affidavit, Shinana claimed when he first complained of itchy and sore eyes in January 2015, he was told to “be a little more active, do some exercise”.

He said he was later told “there is no sign of eyesight problems and they proceeded to prescribe me Panado pills”.

In March, he was eventually referred to the Windhoek Central Hospital and underwent a scan which indicated abnormal swelling. He claims this condition was traced back to the TB medication he had been taking.

“After numerous follow-ups at the Windhoek Central Hospital, I was informed that I had lost about 80% of my eyesight and I was declared legally blind.”

While he was not called to testify, a witness statement provided to the court by Dr Willie Bruwer noted that that the medicine prescribed has the potential to lead to optic neuritis.

The doctor further said he was not able to find any evidence that Shinana had been advised of the possible side-effects of the medication.

He said it would have been diligent to immediately send the plaintiff for eye tests when he complained of itchiness and reddish eyes.

“It is medically possible that delay may have led to the plaintiff's current condition, as early removal of the causative agent may have stopped the process,” Bruwer wrote.

Papers filed on behalf of the safety and security ministry said the ministry denied any wrongdoing and that Shinana was provided with sufficiently quick medical help.

The defendants argued furthermore Shinana's blindness “was a gradual process and did not happen in one day or a week”.

They state further that Shinana “was unreasonable in taking too long to register the complaint about his deteriorating eyesight and painful eyes” and that he himself “brought about his own loss of eyesight”.

Shinana was represented by Taimi Iileka of Sisa Namandje and Co., while Freddy Kadhila was appointed as the government attorney.

JANA-MARI SMITH

Similar News

 

Who's who in EVM Supreme Court battle

23 hours ago | Justice

The bench Chief Justice Peter Shivute Justice Sylvester Mainga Justice Dave Smuts Justice Elton Hoff Justice Baaitse Nkabinde ...

Katrina turns to Supreme Court

23 hours ago | Justice

Former education minister Katrina Hanse-Himarwa is turning to the Supreme Court to challenge her criminal conviction.The former Hardap governor, who was found guilty of corruption...

Shanghala employeeon abandons bail bid

23 hours ago | Justice

Nigel Van Wyk, who faces charges related to the Fishrot corruption case, had to abandon a bail application scheduled for 10 January because he could...

‘Daddy touched my cookie’

1 day - 16 January 2020 | Justice

JEMIMA BEUKES The stepsister of an eight-year-old girl who was allegedly raped by her 69-year-old father has revealed that the family had...

Details emerge in councillor's assault case

1 week ago - 06 January 2020 | Justice

A Christmas get-together at Arevesheneka village in Kavango East led to the arrest of Ndiyona Constituency Councillor Eugen Likuwa and his wife Clementine Mpande, after...

Councillor denied bail in assault case

2 weeks ago - 31 December 2019 | Justice

The Swapo councillor for Ndiyona Constituency, Eugen Likuwa, (49), who was arrested for allegedly assaulting and threatening to kill his wife on Christmas Day, was...

Fishrot 6 stay in jail

2 weeks ago - 30 December 2019 | Justice

The so-called Fishrot Six will remain in prison until at least February 2020, after Acting High Court Judge Kobus Miller dismissed their urgent application to...

Jailbirds appeal long sentences

2 weeks ago - 30 December 2019 | Justice

At least three inmates facing decades behind bars with no prospect of release have taken steps to reduce the ultra-long sentences they are serving after...

ECN's Louw makes first court appearance

3 weeks ago - 23 December 2019 | Justice

Electoral Commission of Namibia (ECN) employee Milton Louw, who is charged with the alleged theft of five laptops from his employer, on Friday made his...

Xmas in cells for Fishrot 6

4 weeks ago - 20 December 2019 | Justice

Six men challenging their arrest on allegations of receiving millions of dollars in kickbacks, in exchange for availing Namibian fishing quotas to an Iceland seafood...

Latest News

Make education your New Year’s...

23 hours ago | People

Albin JacobsWith the holiday season drawing to a close it is time to focus on the new year, 2020. Almost everyone makes some kind of...

Suspended Okahandja CEO postpones swearing-in...

23 hours ago | Government

Okahandja municipal CEO Martha Mutilifa, who was put on suspension by the town's councillors, cancelled the swearing-in ceremony of office bearers at the town while...

Louw suspended for Cash Converters...

23 hours ago | Politics

The Electoral Commission of Namibia has suspended its technical director, Milton Shaanika Louw, who allegedly pawned five laptops belonging to the Commission. “I can...

EVMs challenged amid by-election joy

23 hours ago | Politics

The opposition, which now comprises of the new independent candidacy phenomenon, yesterday celebrated by-election victories against Swapo at Walvis Bay and Keetmanshoop on the eve...

Who's who in EVM Supreme...

23 hours ago | Justice

The bench Chief Justice Peter Shivute Justice Sylvester Mainga Justice Dave Smuts Justice Elton Hoff Justice Baaitse Nkabinde ...

Fearless manager - Game of...

23 hours ago | People

Michelline NawatisesLeandro van Wyk, call centre manager at MultiChoice Namibia, started his career in the banking industry in 2001 as a back-office ledgers clerk, after...

Connecting clients to the correct...

23 hours ago | People

Ester Kamati With internet connection, there is no stopping Macveren Kapukare, a telecommunication engineering graduate who is passionate about making a difference in the world...

Supreme Court must seal EVM...

23 hours ago | Opinion

Today the Supreme Court hears arguments about the use of electronic voting machines (EVMs) in Namibian elections, particularly those held on November 27 last year....

Leading by example

23 hours ago | People

Mariselle Stofberg A strong leader is able to inspire their colleagues to be the best version of themselves and encourage them to reach their full...

Load More