IMF loan option welcomed with a pinch of salt

30 July 2020 | Economics

OGONE TLHAGE

WINDHOEK



While the reputation of the International Monetary Fund has not been seen as favourable, local economic commentators have welcomed the government's intention to borrow from the Bretton Woods institution, arguing that its relatively low rates in the face of the Covid-19 pandemic makes it the ideal lender.

Namibia had submitted a request to borrow N$4.5 billion in an effort to fund its responses to the Covid-19 pandemic. This breaks a 30-year commitment not to borrow from the IMF, which often attaches strict conditionalities to money it lends.

Many countries lose their fiscal sovereignty because of the terms of these loans. The institution has made funding available for the pandemic and with that, relaxed some conditions, which countries like Namibia find appealing.

Namibia's debt to Gross Domestic Product is expected to reach 69% by the end of the fiscal year while elevated debt levels have always drawn concern from rating agencies Moody's and Fitch.

The Bank of Namibia indicated in June that the country's debt to GDP ratio stood at 56.8%.



Low rates tempting

University of Namibia academic Omu Kakujaha-Matundu says although the rates are attractive, there are concerns going forward about how Namibia will service this debt.

“The low rates at which these IMF Covid-19 loans are offered are tempting. However, the main concern is that the Namibian economy will take long to recover, and government could struggle to service its increasing debt stock. Another risk is if the Namibia dollar depreciates against the US dollar, the N$4.5 billion could increase and balloon the total debt stock,” Kakujaha-Matundu said.





IJG head of research Eric Van Zyl agreed with Kakujaha-Matundu that the low rates would be more attractive than other conventional sources of finance.

“The IMF is generally also a relatively cheap source of funding given the risky situations in which they extend credit. In return for this relatively cheap funding the IMF may impose conditions on the fiscus with regards to economic policy,” he said.

“It may be the case that Namibia is able to secure relatively cheap funding with few of the restrictive conditions which generally accompany these loans,” he said.

He added that taking up an IMF loan could affect Namibia's fiscal sovereignty, leaving the treasury with limited control over spending.

Klaus Schade, who serves on President Hage Geingob's High-Level Panel on the Economy, also welcomed the loan application, provided it was attractive.

“The final decision where to borrow the required funds should be based on the terms and conditions, such as repayment period, interest rate, currency, as well as conditions regarding the use of the loan. As long as these conditions are favourable to Namibia, the government should consider making use of available loan facilities from the IMF,” he said.



Domestic borrowing insufficient

Kakujaha-Matundu also argued that Namibia's financing options internally are limited.

“Borrowing locally seems foreclosed. Local lenders could charge government speculative rates, which are much higher than the IMF rates. Also, there is a risk of crowding out the private sector by driving up interest rates, which will fly in the face of Bank of Namibia's low interest rate strategy.”

Schade held the same view, saying: “The government faces an extraordinarily high budget deficit this financial year that cannot be covered by borrowing from the domestic market alone.”

According to Schade, the government could also use other approaches to raise funds.

“There are also various options to increase revenue, such as leveraging state assets and improving the business environment in order to attract more investment, but to implement these will take time. Therefore, the government needs to seek funding from abroad and should explore all available options,” he said.



Treasury's new normal

With the take-up of the loan, Van Zyl said the government would be required to walk a financial tightrope in future and rein in existing debt.

“Guidance from the IMF should also put some pressure on the fiscus to slow the growth trajectory of debt levels. Thus, if a loan is granted it would be adding to the debt burden in the short term but placing pressure on government to bring the debt burden under control going forward,” he said.

“Given that the IMF has vastly relaxed conditions on funding which may limit fiscal independence due to the crisis, and that the funding is generally cheap, it is unlikely that there are better sources of funding in international capital markets,” Van Zyl added.

Similar News

 

Nam has exhausted 75% of its drivers for growth

6 hours ago | Economics

PHILLEPUS UUSIKUAccording to the World Bank’s 2020 Doing Business Report, Namibia’s ranking has deteriorated significantly in the last decade, falling from 66th place in 2010...

Education employees value their labour services more

3 days ago - 22 January 2021 | Economics

PHILLEPUS UUSIKUDuring the third quarter of 2020, the Government Wage Index (GWI) stood at 130.4 basis points, posting a marginal increase of 0.9 percentage points...

Price monster in South Africa under control

3 days ago - 22 January 2021 | Economics

AMBAR WARRICKSouth Africa's rand led gains across emerging market currencies on Wednesday as domestic inflation remained steady, while stocks hit a record high on hopes...

Kenya's remittance inflows jump by nearly 11%

3 days ago - 22 January 2021 | Economics

Remittance inflows into Kenya jumped by nearly 11% in 2020 to US$3.09 billion as technological innovations helped people overcome the economic struggles brought on by...

Zambia expects to find new Mopani Copper investor

3 days ago - 22 January 2021 | Economics

CHRIS MFULAZambia's mining investment arm ZCCM-IH said it expects to find a new investor for Mopani Copper Mines by the end of the year, as...

China restructuring Kenya's debt

3 days ago - 22 January 2021 | Economics

Kenya has secured a debt repayment moratorium from China which will save it 27 billion shillings (US$245.23 million) in the period to June, its finance...

Namibia in desperate need of Foreign Direct Investment

4 days ago - 21 January 2021 | Economics

PHILLEPUS UUSIKUNamibia is in desperate need of Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) and policy certainty is of critical importance to boost investor confidence. Following a depressing...

Algeria's crude output tumbled in 2020

4 days ago - 21 January 2021 | Economics

Algeria's oil revenues collapsed in 2020, according to energy ministry figures released Monday, exacerbating an economic crisis in the North African country which is heavily...

Namibia more of a consumer than a producer

5 days ago - 20 January 2021 | Economics

PHILLEPUS UUSIKUNamibia recorded a trade deficit to the tune of N$1.4 billion in November 2020. The recent figure shows that the deficit improved by...

Ivory Coast rains support abundant cocoa mid-crop

5 days ago - 20 January 2021 | Economics

Above average light rains mixed with spells of sunshine last week in most of Ivory Coast's cocoa regions provided the right growing conditions for the...

Latest News

New year, same old auction...

6 hours ago | Fishing

MATHIAS HAUFIKUWINDHOEKTroubled state-owned fishing company Fishcor hoped to have secured N$33 million in an auction of fishing quotas whose bids closed on Friday, in part...

Govt backs Recon’s Kavango oil...

6 hours ago | Energy

KENYA KAMBOWEKAWEDespite a number of objections against the planned oil and gas exploration at Kawe village in the Kavango East Region, the government has given...

I owe GIPF nothing –...

6 hours ago | Business

STAFF REPORTERWINDHOEKBusinessman Ranga Haikali on Friday said he owes no money to the Government Institutions Pension Fund (GIPF) from the fund’s ill-fated Development Capital Portfolio...

New Shell service station opened...

6 hours ago | Business

PHILLEPUS UUSIKUThe new Oshakati Shell opened its doors over the festive season to an expecting public. With refuelling and eating options, the new Shell facility’s...

SA’s Mr Price posted a...

6 hours ago | Business

South Africa's Mr Price on Friday posted a 5.8% rise in third-quarter retail sales, supported by Covid-19 relief packages and demand for household items as...

MTC records 2.66 percent increase...

6 hours ago | Business

Mobile Telecommunications Company (MTC) on Thursday announced a 2.66 percent increase in revenue from N$ 2.613 billion recorded in 2019 to N$ 2.683 billion in...

SA’s Mr Price posted a...

6 hours ago | Business

South Africa's Mr Price on Friday posted a 5.8% rise in third-quarter retail sales, supported by Covid-19 relief packages and demand for household items as...

Heavy rain, flooding expected this...

6 hours ago | Weather

ELLANIE SMITWINDHOEKThe weather bureau has warns that heavy rain with localised flooding is likely in the Omaheke Region tomorrow.This will spread to the central-northern areas,...

Press resilience in the time...

6 hours ago | Opinion

The Namibian media have been bold in recent months, shining light in the darkest corners of unholy activities of the political establishment.We have seen in...

Load More