Hobbling SA govt relief package

The low uptake of the scheme suggests that businesses do not want to incur more debt in light of the economic uncertainty, South Africa’s Treasury says.

16 September 2020 | Economics

If we had a different fiscal position, I think we could have designed the scheme differently. – Kuben Naidoo, Head: Prudential Authority

Emma Rumney and Alexander Winning - South Africa's National Treasury plans no further easing of its coronavirus loan scheme criteria to stimulate uptake, it told Reuters, meaning almost a third of the government's R500 billion relief package may end up going unused.

The R200-billion loan programme is a pillar of South African efforts to shield small businesses from the impact of the pandemic. Conditions were tweaked in July, including expanding who qualifies and extending the repayment grace period, after relatively few firms applied for the loans.

Still, only R14.5 billion had been paid out through August. The Banking Association of South Africa (BASA) estimates at most around R44 billion will be deployed by January.

Despite that, the treasury said it was not planning to ease the scheme further to increase disbursals.

"The low uptake of the scheme also suggests that businesses do not want to incur more debt in light of the economic uncertainty," it said in response to Reuters' questions.

It added that the economy's reopening following a months-long lockdown meant firms would now need less financial support. The Treasury said it was also not considering releasing any of that amount as grants, as suggested by some trade unions.

Covid-19 has deepened a recession in Africa's most developed economy that predates the pandemic. Banks have reported a spike in bad loan charges.

Not wanted

Under the scheme, the government pledges to reimburse banks for a portion of any eventual losses on qualifying loans with the aim of lowering borrowing costs and making credit available to businesses that might otherwise be considered too high-risk.

By the end of August, some 35% of 42 202 loan applications had been rejected for not meeting the scheme's or banks' own risk criteria, according to BASA. The programme has attracted significantly less interest than similar initiatives launched in the UK and elsewhere.

More funds - over R30 billion - were disbursed under other earlier relief initiatives from lenders, such as payment holidays.

This, as well as high levels of uncertainty and low business confidence, suppressed demand for the guaranteed loans, BASA has said.

South Africa had to balance the desire to extend relief to businesses against the need to safeguard the treasury's already strained resources, said Kuben Naidoo, head of South Africa's Prudential Authority.

"If we had a different fiscal position, I think we could have designed the scheme differently," he said, though he added that the scheme had contributed to easing the impact of the crisis, along with lenders' other relief measures.

Other problems

And the need the initiative was designed to meet - buttressing businesses during the lockdown - no longer exists, said Stuart Theobald, chairman of financial consultancy Intellidex.

He said the economy now faces other problems, namely a recession, but in such an environment firms want equity, not debt.

Business owners still need support, said Alan Pullinger, CEO of major lender FirstRand, but they do not want loans they are not sure they can repay.

"I think if [government] really want to get ... R200 billion out the door, they have got to change it from a loan scheme to a grant. And the reality is we can't afford it." – Nampa/Reuters

Similar News

 

Nam has exhausted 75% of its drivers for growth

9 hours ago | Economics

PHILLEPUS UUSIKUAccording to the World Bank’s 2020 Doing Business Report, Namibia’s ranking has deteriorated significantly in the last decade, falling from 66th place in 2010...

Education employees value their labour services more

3 days ago - 22 January 2021 | Economics

PHILLEPUS UUSIKUDuring the third quarter of 2020, the Government Wage Index (GWI) stood at 130.4 basis points, posting a marginal increase of 0.9 percentage points...

Price monster in South Africa under control

3 days ago - 22 January 2021 | Economics

AMBAR WARRICKSouth Africa's rand led gains across emerging market currencies on Wednesday as domestic inflation remained steady, while stocks hit a record high on hopes...

Kenya's remittance inflows jump by nearly 11%

3 days ago - 22 January 2021 | Economics

Remittance inflows into Kenya jumped by nearly 11% in 2020 to US$3.09 billion as technological innovations helped people overcome the economic struggles brought on by...

Zambia expects to find new Mopani Copper investor

3 days ago - 22 January 2021 | Economics

CHRIS MFULAZambia's mining investment arm ZCCM-IH said it expects to find a new investor for Mopani Copper Mines by the end of the year, as...

China restructuring Kenya's debt

3 days ago - 22 January 2021 | Economics

Kenya has secured a debt repayment moratorium from China which will save it 27 billion shillings (US$245.23 million) in the period to June, its finance...

Namibia in desperate need of Foreign Direct Investment

4 days ago - 21 January 2021 | Economics

PHILLEPUS UUSIKUNamibia is in desperate need of Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) and policy certainty is of critical importance to boost investor confidence. Following a depressing...

Algeria's crude output tumbled in 2020

4 days ago - 21 January 2021 | Economics

Algeria's oil revenues collapsed in 2020, according to energy ministry figures released Monday, exacerbating an economic crisis in the North African country which is heavily...

Namibia more of a consumer than a producer

5 days ago - 20 January 2021 | Economics

PHILLEPUS UUSIKUNamibia recorded a trade deficit to the tune of N$1.4 billion in November 2020. The recent figure shows that the deficit improved by...

Ivory Coast rains support abundant cocoa mid-crop

5 days ago - 20 January 2021 | Economics

Above average light rains mixed with spells of sunshine last week in most of Ivory Coast's cocoa regions provided the right growing conditions for the...

Latest News

New year, same old auction...

9 hours ago | Fishing

MATHIAS HAUFIKUWINDHOEKTroubled state-owned fishing company Fishcor hoped to have secured N$33 million in an auction of fishing quotas whose bids closed on Friday, in part...

Govt backs Recon’s Kavango oil...

9 hours ago | Energy

KENYA KAMBOWEKAWEDespite a number of objections against the planned oil and gas exploration at Kawe village in the Kavango East Region, the government has given...

I owe GIPF nothing –...

9 hours ago | Business

STAFF REPORTERWINDHOEKBusinessman Ranga Haikali on Friday said he owes no money to the Government Institutions Pension Fund (GIPF) from the fund’s ill-fated Development Capital Portfolio...

New Shell service station opened...

9 hours ago | Business

PHILLEPUS UUSIKUThe new Oshakati Shell opened its doors over the festive season to an expecting public. With refuelling and eating options, the new Shell facility’s...

SA’s Mr Price posted a...

9 hours ago | Business

South Africa's Mr Price on Friday posted a 5.8% rise in third-quarter retail sales, supported by Covid-19 relief packages and demand for household items as...

MTC records 2.66 percent increase...

9 hours ago | Business

Mobile Telecommunications Company (MTC) on Thursday announced a 2.66 percent increase in revenue from N$ 2.613 billion recorded in 2019 to N$ 2.683 billion in...

SA’s Mr Price posted a...

9 hours ago | Business

South Africa's Mr Price on Friday posted a 5.8% rise in third-quarter retail sales, supported by Covid-19 relief packages and demand for household items as...

Heavy rain, flooding expected this...

9 hours ago | Weather

ELLANIE SMITWINDHOEKThe weather bureau has warns that heavy rain with localised flooding is likely in the Omaheke Region tomorrow.This will spread to the central-northern areas,...

Press resilience in the time...

9 hours ago | Opinion

The Namibian media have been bold in recent months, shining light in the darkest corners of unholy activities of the political establishment.We have seen in...

Load More