Feathers fly in chicken war

A war to stave off bulk imports of frozen chicken cuts from Brazil into the Namibian and South African markets has been brewing for years.

12 April 2019 | Agriculture

While international poultry players are battling it out over local market share, Namibian consumers are likely left to carry the burden of higher prices.

Of late, the South African Poultry Association (SAPA) has been making headlines in Namibia, expressing its support for the local broiler industry while lashing out at the dumping of Brazilian chicken products in the sub-region.

SAPA's recently appointed general manager of the Broiler Organisation, Izaak Breitenbach, has taken aim at the Brazilians for quite some time, starting with an open letter to the South African media in February this year to warn consumers about the “dangers” of eating Brazilian chicken.

Brazil is the third largest broiler producer in the world after the United States and China but its exports have exponentially increased and it has overtaken the United States as the world's largest chicken meat exporter. The country also exports beef and pork.

Brazil's meat industry has not been without its challenges and in 2017, Operation Carne Fraca, or 'weak meat', showed serious loopholes in the safety mechanisms at beef, poultry and pork processors in that country.

After that, the European Union banned imports from 20 Brazilian meat-processing plants (including beef, pork and poultry) while China banned all imports from Brazil and Saudi Arabia halted imports from five of the 58 companies involved.

But Brazil still exports far and wide and according to local economists, it makes all the profits it requires from high-value chicken breast exports.

The remaining leg quarters can then be sold at any price and that is what it exports to countries like Namibia and South Africa.





This is described as dumping - selling products at prices lower than their production cost.

Namibia's broiler industry is very small and it constitutes roughly 2% of South Africa's production.

What makes Breitenbach's recent statements of support for Namibia so surprising is that SAPA has been locked in a High Court battle since 2014, turning to the Supreme Court in the process, to have Namibian import restrictions set aside.

Experts say it is precisely this court action and the risk of a negative outcome that have restricted investment in the local broiler industry.

The entire industry is currently buoyed by Namib Poultry Industries, which is backed by Namib Mills.

Research performed by Cirrus Capital indicated that under the right conditions, which would include regulatory frameworks, the local chicken industry could grow to account for 2% of the gross domestic product.

Breitenbach told Namibian Sun that he could not comment about the court case “for obvious reasons”, adding that South Africa had a good relationship with the Namibian industry and “it certainly assists greatly in terms of technical matters and input to grow the industry”.

He added that they saw Namibia as an ally, not a threat, and would not dump products in Namibia “as the Brazilians do”.

The Namibian public's response to reports of dumping by Brazilian chicken producers has been one centred on cost.

The most recent Labour Force Survey indicates that the highest mean wage for Namibians is N$12 662 per month, with a low of N$1 113.

Namibian consumers are not exactly spoilt for choice when shopping and have to take that which is cheapest.

“Imports lower GDP, destroy jobs and make a nation poorer. One strategy for an economy that needs to catch up with countries that are ahead in industrialisation would be to create investment incentives to facilitate new expansions and create industries that can compete in export markets, while at the same time ensuring regulations are in place to restrict imports as far as possible,” Pieter van Niekerk, commercial manager at Namib Mills, told Namibian Sun.

“This will facilitate growth and ensure industries are in place when this, and future, generations look for jobs.”



Long-term regulation

Van Niekerk argues that the local industry could only grow and be competitive if there is long-term regulation surety.

“An effective regulation should ensure higher incentives for producing than for importing; otherwise we will just see an increase in imports and decrease in production.

“Very few large investments have been made in the poultry sector, as the current quantitative measure is being challenged in court. SMEs have grown quickly in a short period of time, but are stagnating as they struggle to find sufficient markets for their products, due to low-priced imported poultry,” he said.

“Namibian producers agree with SAPA's statement that Brazilian poultry is dumped into the region, putting much pressure on current jobs, new sector investments and GDP.”

Namibian poultry would become cheaper if production increased, but that would depend on import restrictions to protect the local industry.



According to Breitenbach, SAPA's support for Namibia will be “the increased import duties that it has applied for”.



SAPA last year applied to the International Trade Administration Commission (ITAC) to increase the general rate of customs duty on bone-in chicken portions from 37% to 82%, and that of boneless chicken portions from 12% to 82%.



SAPA is effectively seeking a substantial hike in import tariffs to protect the South African poultry industry, while at the same time asking Namibian courts to set aside Namibia's “procedurally unfair” import limitations.

It alleges that the Namibian government has violated the Protocol to the SADC Agreement and also the SACU Agreement.







Monopoly claims

Asked whether SAPA was trying to stop Brazilian imports so that SAPA could have the monopoly on chicken products in the sub-region, Breitenbach said: “In the sub-region, and more so South Africa, the industry is very competitive as indicated by weekly price changes.

“At present 33% of poultry meat is imported into South Africa. Brazil, however, does not reciprocate to allow imports from any country in the region.

“Imports from Brazil and other countries have decimated the poultry industries in Mozambique, Angola, Ghana, DRC, Congo Brazzaville and many more. That is why all trade must be on a fair playing field.

“Some 47% of the 370 small farmers that SAPA surveys and assists on a regular basis have gone out of production in the last six months due to imports.”

The Brazilian Association of Animal Protein holds a different view, saying the argument that South Africa, as a “globally efficient producer of chicken”, faces profit challenges and job losses because of imports of frozen chicken “does not sustain itself”.

It says that bird flu outbreaks since 2017 were the main reason why the poultry industry in South Africa is facing challenges.

SAPA reported that the impact of bird flu had resulted in a loss of revenue of N$954 million. The poultry industry in South Africa is worth around N$46 billion.



YANNA SMITH

Similar News

 

Dairy industry seeks solutions

2 hours ago | Agriculture

Dairy stakeholders recently met with agriculture minister Alpheus !Naruseb to discuss possible solutions to save the industry. During the meeting, that took place on 20...

New Meatco CEO emphasises quantity, quality

2 hours ago | Agriculture

New Meatco CEO Mushokobanji Mwilima has stressed that with the continued drought, the quantity and quality of livestock at abattoirs has to remain competitive, otherwise...

Oshakati abattoir grinds to a halt

5 days ago - 21 February 2020 | Agriculture

KIAT Investment, which was awarded a tender to operate the Oshakati abattoir, is unable to start slaughtering because it cannot afford to pay the electricity...

N$165 million for 13 farms

6 days ago - 20 February 2020 | Agriculture

The lands ministry spent N$165 million on the acquisition of 13 farms measuring 76 272 hectares to resettle landless Namibians during the 2017/18 financial year....

Namibian beef leaves for USA

6 days ago - 20 February 2020 | Agriculture

ELLANIE SMIT Meatco reached another major milestone yesterday when it sent its first commercial consignment of beef to the United States...

Challenges in agri sector can be overcome

6 days ago - 20 February 2020 | Agriculture

Agriculture minister Alpheus !Naruseb said the challenges facing the agriculture sector can be overcome with commitment, dedication and a conscious approach. Addressing ministry staff and...

Namibia eyes N$16m GEF funding

1 week ago - 19 February 2020 | Agriculture

In an effort to address climate change in Namibia, a meeting was held last week to discuss a proposal that has to be submitted to...

Unions reveal desperate drought conditions

1 week ago - 19 February 2020 | Agriculture

The Namibia Agriculture Union (NAU) and the Namibia Emerging Commercial Farmers' Union (NECFU) held a meeting with agriculture minister Alpheus !Naruseb to discuss the ongoing...

Meatco gets 87% of Norway beef quota

1 week ago - 13 February 2020 | Agriculture

Meatco has stressed the importance of the Norwegian beef export quota after being allocated 87.5% of the 1 600-tonne quota for this year. A quota...

Water flow resumes to Hardap irrigation scheme

1 week ago - 12 February 2020 | Agriculture

Ellanie SmitWater supply to the Hardap irrigation scheme from the Hardap Dam resumed this morning at 05:00. The supply has been guaranteed for the next...

Latest News

Let's work together and solve...

2 hours ago | Business

Chantell Husselmann - The PwC Business School has started the year 2020 on a high note with a special occasion that marks the first of...

Dark shadow over fishing quotas

2 hours ago | Opinion

With a total of 5 190 fishing rights applications received by 31 August 2018 for the 90 to 120 rights available in the new allocation...

NSX bears brunt of recession

2 hours ago | Business

Jo-Maré Duddy – The recession didn’t spare the Namibian Stock Exchange (NSX) last year: Trading volumes dropped and the share prices of most of the...

Nust staff expose 'rot'

2 hours ago | Education

A group of concerned Namibia University of Science and Technology (Nust) staff members have appealed to President Hage Geingob as the “last resort” to rescue...

Ndeitunga wants more operational manpower

2 hours ago | Police

Nampol Inspector-General Sebastian Ndeitunga says some of the biggest challenges facing the police force are the increase of violent crimes, gender-based violence and the high...

Dairy industry seeks solutions

2 hours ago | Agriculture

Dairy stakeholders recently met with agriculture minister Alpheus !Naruseb to discuss possible solutions to save the industry. During the meeting, that took place on 20...

New Meatco CEO emphasises quantity,...

2 hours ago | Agriculture

New Meatco CEO Mushokobanji Mwilima has stressed that with the continued drought, the quantity and quality of livestock at abattoirs has to remain competitive, otherwise...

Egypt hails new 'furniture city'...

2 hours ago | Economics

Mahmoud Mourad and Patrick Werr - Egypt has built a multi-billion-pound "furniture city" near the mouth of the Nile, a pilot for a series of...

Fishrot claims more jobs

2 hours ago | Crime

Around 210 employees of the MV Saga and MV Geysir vessels will be retrenched next month.These employees were left stranded earlier this month after both...

Load More