Calle's nasty tightrope walk

22 October 2019 | Economics

Finance minister Calle Schlettwein, who will present his midterm budget review in the National Assembly today, once again faces an unenviable task, according to analysts.

Among the tightrope issues Schlettwein will have to navigate are cash transfers to failing SOEs, additional requirements for drought relief, as well as containing the bloated civil service wage bill.

Simonis Storm junior analyst Indileni Nanghonga says during Schlettwein's 2019/2020 budget speech earlier this year the minister said he aimed to stimulate economic growth, bring about decent jobs and further adjust the public fiscal stance to sustainable levels.

She says so far economic growth has been sluggish, -2.9% in the first quarter and -2.6% in the second quarter of 2019, and a lack of decent jobs has supressed the nation.

“We reiterate our concern whether this budget will ensure macroeconomic stability. We expect the midterm budget to give a clear indication of the state's finances and provide clarity on how it will deal with cash-consuming SOEs,” Nanghonga says. Cirrus Capital economist Robert McGregor says Schlettwein once again finds himself in an unenviable position, with a contracting economy and “the imperative need to walk the fiscal tightrope”.

“The most important thing for this (midterm) budget will be to contain expenditure, particularly as the weak economy does not bode well for revenue collection and any larger budget deficit requires additional debt financing.

“There are several risks to the expenditure outlook, such as transfers to failing SOEs, additional requirements for drought relief, as well as containing the civil service wage bill.

“Our debt-to-GDP ratio will likely already look worse, given the contracting economy (forecasts in the initial FY2019/20 budget still anticipated growth), which means there is already a smaller denominator in the calculation, while there is risk that the numerator (i.e. total public debt) will increase.

“The additional uptake of debt would be a concern, as our current debt trajectory is already unsustainable,” McGregor said.

He said more of the same will be dangerous for the economy, especially increases in taxes on the productive sectors within the economy.

“The weak macroeconomic environment already makes it challenging for businesses to operate, and increases in taxes for the productive part of the economy - in order to draw more revenue for the state - will not have the desired consequences.

“If I could change one thing, it would be tax reform. This is not necessarily tax cuts across the board, but rather targeted interventions such as lower taxes for small business, in order to incentivise entrepreneurship which should, in turn, improve business activity and employment, thereby generating additional tax revenue,” McGregor says.

He also anticipates that, like in previous years, much of the development budget expenditure will be reallocated to plug shortfalls in the operational budget, which comes at the cost of future economic growth prospects as less is dedicated towards growth-generating activities such as infrastructure development.

“We also anticipate updated information regarding SACU (Southern African Customs Union) transfers, more specifically whether we will see additional revenue from this source in 2020.

“We hope to see announcements regarding tax proposals floated in the budget earlier this year, such as developments around the dividends tax and non-deductibility of royalties for mining companies, to name just two.

“We also hope to see an explicit announcement regarding transfers to SOEs, such as Air Namibia. Will failing SOEs continue to benefit from taxpayer-funded bailouts, will they be forced to get their act together or face closure without additional help from the state, or will there be some level of privatisation? Transfers to SOEs pose a significant risk to public finances, something also highlighted in Fitch's recent downgrading decision.”

IJG research analyst Dylan van Wyk says the most important thing would be the continued commitment to the fiscal consolidation course that has been set.

“We would like to see that spending is kept within the budgeted limits and that progress is being made to rein in fiscal deficits. Given the low growth in the economy, we hope to see that revenue targets have been revised to better reflect the economic realities and that expenditure is aligned to these forecasts.

“The most irresponsible thing would be an unexpected increase in unproductive spending or a sharp increase in corporate income taxes.

“A slip in expenditure would undermine the progress made on fiscal consolation, while increases in corporate tax would put the brakes on an already slow economy,” he says.

“I would reduce spending in the development portion of the defence budget, and reallocate this to higher priority needs such as long-term water sustainability.”

Van Wyk also says there is a very slim possibility that the liquidation of Air Namibia may be on the cards.

“This would imply an immediate expense, which some have estimated at roughly N$2.5 billion to exit leases and close the airline. We would view this as a more positive development than further bailouts.”


Similar News


Inflation slows down further

2 hours ago | Economics

Annual overall inflation in Namibia last month was 3.0%, down from 3.3% in September and 5.1% a year ago.Data released by the Namibia Statistics Agency...

Informal sector taxes off the table

3 days ago - 11 November 2019 | Economics

The ministry of finance has struck any plans to introduce a presumptive tax on the informal sector of the economy off the table and said...

Lifestyle audits kick off

1 week ago - 07 November 2019 | Economics

OGONE TLHAGE The ministry of finance is gunning after suspected tax defaulters by means of lifestyle audits.Tax commissioner Justus Mwafongwe told Namibian...

New cocoa deals help peasant farmers, but not enough

1 week ago - 06 November 2019 | Economics

David Esnault - The willingness of some multinational firms to pay a cost-of-living bonus for African cocoa planters is welcome but will not save many...

Debt relief a double-edged sword for S. Africans

1 week ago - 06 November 2019 | Economics

Emma Rumney - Solani Rivele, a single mother of four, earns about R800 a week but owes 100 times that amount in loans. Millions of...

Nigeria puts squeeze on oil majors

1 week ago - 06 November 2019 | Economics

Libby George - The Nigerian government has amended a bill that would render billions in planned offshore oil investments unprofitable and cut nearly 30% from...

N$2.5m salaries bailout for Agribusdev

1 week ago - 01 November 2019 | Economics

The agriculture ministry will seek treasury approval in order to divert N$2.5 million that will be used to pay Agribusdev staff, who are yet to...

N$54m lifeline for ailing NBC

2 weeks ago - 25 October 2019 | Economics

Finance minister Calle Schlettwein has emptied state coffers to the tune of N$54 million to bail out the Namibia Broadcasting Corporation (NBC). While Schlettwein...

A legacy in doubt

3 weeks ago - 23 October 2019 | Economics

Jo-Mare Duddy - With elections on the horizon, president Hage Geingob and his cabinet must decide what their legacy is going to be: will they...

Upbeat Calle preaches recovery

3 weeks ago - 23 October 2019 | Economics

Finance minister Calle Schlettwein says the domestic economy is projected to gradually emerge from the recession in 2020 with a moderate growth rate of about...

Latest News

A fish rots from the...

14 hours ago | Columns

“A lie can travel half way around the world while the truth is putting on its shoes,” Mark Twain once said.In the end, truth will...

Namcor ready to run fuel...

14 hours ago | Business

The Petroleum Corporation of Namibia (Namcor) expects to take delivery of the strategic fuel storage facility next month, a company official has told Namibian Sun....

How the 'sharks' were netted

14 hours ago | Fishing

An international scandal has erupted with an exposé of more than 30 000 documents released by WikiLeaks which show that an Icelandic fishing company, SAMHERJI,...

NSFAF explains payment woes

14 hours ago | Education

The Namibia Student Financial Assistance Fund (NSFAF) has blamed the delayed payment of non-tuition fees to students on the unavailability of funds and its internal...

Hospital ­denies Itula ­allegation

14 hours ago | Health

The regional directorate of health for Ohangwena has denied an allegation by independent presidential candidate Panduleni Itula that a patient at Eenhana district hospital had...

Devil's claw under threat

14 hours ago | Environment

The increase in illegal grazing in the Nyae Nyae Conservancy and Community Forest, as well as illegal fences in the N#a Jaqna Conservancy and Community...

More dark days ahead

14 hours ago | Sports

The Fifa normalisation committee says it still has to consult its lawyers before making a decision on the way forward for the Namibia Premier League...

Mining tourney hailed as a...

14 hours ago | Sports

A three-day tournament that featured different mining employees from across the country, which took place at Otjiwarongo from Friday to Sunday, has been described as...

They have to go, says...

1 day - 13 November 2019 | Crime

Staff ReporterHighly placed sources indicated this morning that President Hage Geingob is planning to jettison justice minister Sacky Shanghala and fisheries minister Bernhardt Esau from...

Load More