The nature of corruption in the land sector

14 February 2020 | Opinion

Theodor Muduva



It is difficult to obtain an accurate picture of the extent of corruption in any sector because of its hidden nature. However, available data shows that it is possible to get an idea of some trends and areas most affected by land corruption in particular. A survey of 69 countries done in 2009 by the global coalition against corruption called Transparency International (TI) found that the judiciary, police and government bodies which oversee the land sector were the most plagued by service-level bribery.

Land is a valuable asset in most developing countries, accounting for 30-50% of the national wealth; hence the land sector is particularly susceptible to corruption (Kunte et al, 1998). The value of land tends to create opportunities for corruption on the part of those with legal authority to administer this valuable resource.

Land corruption takes many forms and occurs in both rural and urban areas. Regarding rural land corruption, the literature points to large-scale land deals and land administrative services as scenarios prone to corruption. High-profile land grabs and illegal state land capture are being exposed across a number of African nations with abundant natural resources, while petty corruption is embedded in many public institutions (Burns et al, 2010).

There has been a growing demand from multinational entities (including national and international investors) over the last decade or two, to acquire rural land deemed suitable for cultivation, extractive activities, timber concessions and infrastructure projects. Data provided by Land Matrix reveals that between 2000 and 2017 an estimate of 1 347 transnational deals have been concluded, covering more than 49 million hectares of land, with the majority of documented deals in Africa (41.3%), followed by South-East Asia.

Land corruption in urban areas manifests mainly in two scenarios; urban land markets and urban development. With regard to urban land markets, land corruption in the cities takes place in the context of rapid urbanisation, the increase in demand and value of land, loose or weak laws and poor urban land governance. The high demand for urban land consistently exceeds the supply and the consequent rise in price not only presents great opportunities for public revenue, but also private enrichment.

Corruption in urban development involves bribing politicians to obtain development projects, the manipulation of land registries by developers to evict people, and subsidising housing to patronage political supporters, among other practices (Zúñiga, 2018).

Much of the land corruption which takes place in the rural and urban land settings as discussed above cannot be addressed without understanding the underlying origin and causes. Land corruption is prevalent at the following key stages and levels: policy-making, legal and administrative processes. Land corruption at the policy-making stage of land governance takes the form of political or grand corruption and state capture. Grand corruption takes place at the higher levels of the political system.

Political corruption can be expressed in favouring investors that have financially contributed to a political party or campaign. The state can be captured by individuals, families, groups and even commercial companies who influence public policy to satisfy their private interests. The capture of the judicial system by political elites influences the courts scrutiny and ruling on land deals involving the ruling elites (TI, 2018). Corruption in policy-making can be conducted through bribing judges to make preferential decisions concerning land deals or disputes, irrespective of evidence (TI, 2011). It also involves influencing the police to intimidate those with complaints about corrupt land governance.

Land corruption in the legal system usually happens in societies where statutory and customary law and rights coexist. In these cases, corruption tends to occur in the legal gaps created by the disconnection between the two legal systems. This includes the lack of recognition of customary laws that protects indigenous rights over their community land by the judiciary, which increases the opportunities for abuse and for corruption regarding that land (TI, 2018). In addition, the complexity of some legal systems (including regulations), can also facilitate illegal conduct and corrupt activities.

With regard to land administration processes globally, corruption is often a common practice in everyday land administrative services. Some of the areas vulnerable to corruption in land administration are: demarcation and titling of land, identification of the land according to state categories, planning and zoning, land valuation, land sales and leasing, enforcement of land rights and compensation. for instance, with regard to the “identification of the land according to state categories”.

Governments hold a powerful tool in being able to define land as “unused”, “underutilised”, “vacant” or of “public interest”. When land is used sporadically for activities that support livelihoods for communities, such as obtaining bush food, collecting firewood and even grazing, it is often officially considered as “unused” (Zúñiga, 2018). The category of unused is often employed to facilitate elite capture for personal gain. Authorities might also recognise land as “underutilised” when it is being used regularly but the community does not have a title recognised by the government. In addition, there is no consensus about the definitions of “public interest” and this situation is sometimes used by authorities to their own selfish interests. In actual fact, the word “public” indicates that expropriation should never involve solely private or commercial interests (TI, 2018).

There are many drivers of land corruption and among these are: weak land administration systems, limited legislation, weak institutions, lack of transparency, lack of effective oversight institutions, and reduced social participation. In order to counteract land corruption, improving land governance is a necessary first step and needs to be applied at the policy, legal and administrative levels with the aim of making them more transparent, efficient and participatory.

*Theodor Muduva is an advisor for academic cooperation on land governance in Southern Africa (GIZ-AU Office). He is based in the Department of Land and Property Sciences at the Namibian University of Science and Technology. He writes in his personal capacity

Similar News

 

Geingob needs support to lead successfully

1 day - 03 April 2020 | Opinion

President Hage Geingob often gets the stick for all the challenges that the country faces, but perhaps unfairly so at times.While he arguably did not...

Don't let Covid-19 become a hunger game

1 day - 03 April 2020 | Opinion

Qu DongyuRome The Covid-19 pandemic is putting enormous strains on the public health systems around the world, and millions of people in the world's most...

Creating employment through small-scale fishing

1 day - 03 April 2020 | Opinion

INOCENCIO VERDEWINDHOEKMy opinion comes at a critical hour because of the eminent amendment of the Marine Resource Act, 2000 (Act NO. 27 of 2000) and...

The media are key in coronavirus battle

2 days ago - 02 April 2020 | Opinion

A wave of misinformation, or fake news as Donald Trump would call it, has engulfed the fight against the coronavirus.Dr Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus, the director-general...

Needed: Stimulus packages

4 days ago - 31 March 2020 | Opinion

Many countries hit by the coronavirus scourge have hammered out ways in which to keep their economies afloat, especially after the stay-home directive is over...

Let’s be serious

5 days ago - 30 March 2020 | Opinion

News has started filtering in of unruly citizens who are defying the lockdown measures, including continuing to drink alcohol on the streets of Katutura and...

A test of our humanity

1 week ago - 27 March 2020 | Opinion

As the coronavirus continues to dominate our daily lives as humans, living like a thorn in our collective psyche, it also represents an opportunity to...

Focus on the poor!

1 week ago - 26 March 2020 | Opinion

While those of us privileged enough to work and earn salaries rush to stock up for the immediate lockdown of the economic powerhouse regions of...

These are extraordinary times

1 week ago - 25 March 2020 | Opinion

Namibia, like the rest of the world, is in a panic mode. The country’s streets, especially in the capital Windhoek, are reminiscent of Kolmanskop, a...

Cuito Cuanavale remembered

1 week ago - 25 March 2020 | Opinion

RODOLFO BENÍTEZ VERSON Monday, 23 March, marked the 32nd anniversary of the Battle of Cuito Cuanavale. That remote town in Angola became a symbol...

Latest News

Mariental flooded after cloudburst

1 day - 03 April 2020 | Disasters

ELLANIE SMITMARIENTALMajor flooding was experienced at Mariental yesterday morning after 120 mm of rain fell within a two-hour period.The rain started at about 08:00 and...

Geingob needs support to lead...

1 day - 03 April 2020 | Opinion

President Hage Geingob often gets the stick for all the challenges that the country faces, but perhaps unfairly so at times.While he arguably did not...

20 000 Jack Ma corona...

1 day - 03 April 2020 | Disasters

JEMIMA BEUKESWINDHOEKNamibia may only start using the 20 000 coronavirus testing kits donated by Chinese billionaire Jack Ma by the end of April.The government is...

Hefty lockdown violation fines revealed

1 day - 03 April 2020 | Disasters

ELLANIE SMIT WINDHOEKPeople who flout the lockdown rules during the coronavirus state of emergency could be fined up to N$2 000. This is in accordance...

Meatco to restart slaughtering

1 day - 03 April 2020 | Agriculture

ELLANIE SMIT WINDHOEK Meatco will restart slaughtering activities at its factory next week following a declaration that the agriculture value chain is an essential service....

Dams more than 50% full

1 day - 03 April 2020 | Weather

ELLANIE SMIT WINDHOEK The average dam level has risen to 56.9%, nearly twice as high as last season when the dams were only 31.1% full....

Fresh and Popping – Lockdown...

1 day - 03 April 2020 | Art and Entertainment

MICHAEL KAYUNDE WINDHOEK As you already know, Fresh and Popping is where we share trending songs, hot out of the booth. We tell you...

Sharing hope with gospel music

1 day - 03 April 2020 | Art and Entertainment

MICHAEL KAYUNDE WINDHOEKA genre with a devoted community of fans, Namibian gospel is producing more and more world-class content, like award-winning Manda Gabriel, who recently...

Keeping it real

1 day - 03 April 2020 | Art and Entertainment

Recently, we've had some new names on this page. The response has been awesome, but I've also received some resentful opinions. Asking why the page...

Load More