Tax evasion versus avoidance

11 March 2019 | Business

There is a thin line between tax evasion and avoidance as they both result in reducing taxes or not paying taxes at all.

Tax evasion refers to illegal activities deliberately undertaken by a taxpayer to free itself from a tax burden. The commissioner of inland revenue needs no special powers to counter tax evasion, which is in essence a fraud against the fiscus and if discovered, could result in heavy penalties being imposed.

Tax avoidance, in contrast, denotes a situation in which the taxpayer has arranged its affairs in a perfectly legal manner in order to minimise the amount of tax payable by the taxpayer.

For example, not declaring income arising from an all-cash business, foreign source or illegal activities (such as drug dealing or prostitution) may constitute tax evasion. However, increasing your retirement fund contributions or donating to an inland revenue registered welfare organisation in order to reduce your taxable income is regarded as tax avoidance or planning.

Guidance indicators are established under section 95, which enables the receiver of revenue to disregard a transaction for tax purposes if it can be proven that;

• The transaction, operation or scheme has the effect of avoiding, postponing or reducing the liability for the payment of any duty, levy or tax.

• It was entered into for the sole purpose of avoidance, postponement or reduction of any liability for the payment of any duty, levy or tax.

• It was entered into a manner that is abnormal when considering similar transactions, or

• It was entered into in a manner, which creates rights or obligations that would not normally be created between persons that are an arm’s length under similar transactions.

It is important to note that the provisions are not limited to the Income Tax Act but to any tax, duty or levy administered by the minister of finance.

According to section 95 for an impermissible avoidance arrangement to exist, the main purpose of the arrangement must be to obtain a tax benefit. However, at the same time for section 95 to be applied, all the above characteristics needs to be present to empower the commissioner to evoke the taxpayer’s taxability while inflicting penalties as per section 65 and 66.

Despite the fact that the Income Tax Act has specific and general avoidance provisions, it is not illegal for a taxpayer to plan their tax affairs in a manner that is the most beneficial to them as there is no obligation for a taxpayer to pay more tax than is legally required under the Income Tax Act.

The commissioner of inland revenue seeks only to disregard those transactions, which have been arranged with the intent to defraud inland revenue purposefully and within the criteria set out in Section 95 above.

Johan Nel is a partner: corporate tax service at PwC Namibia. This series on tax is published in Market Watch bi-monthly on a Monday.

Similar News


Business ponders mass exodus

2 days ago - 24 May 2019 | Business

A recent survey by the Economic Policy Research Association (EPRA) of close to 600 businesses concerned about the government's policy direction shows that a staggering...

MTC kickstarts NSX listing process

2 days ago - 23 May 2019 | Business

MTC issued a statement this morning saying it “has officially started its journey towards listing on the Namibian Stock Exchange”.MTC will be the first state-owned...

Mexican billionaire buys Erindi

3 days ago - 22 May 2019 | Business

Mexican billionaire Alberto Baillères is set to buy the sought-after 71 000-hectare Erindi Game Reserve, subject to approval. According to a media release, Baillères is...

Bidvest Nam to delist from NSX

4 days ago - 21 May 2019 | Business

Bidvest Namibia will delist from the Namibian Stock Exchange (NSX) on 11 June, the company said in an announcement on the local bourse.This follows a...

Debmarine to spend N$7bn on new vessel

1 week ago - 17 May 2019 | Business

Debmarine has announced that it will invest N$7 billion in a new vessel, which would contribute N$2 billion a year to the economy.The diamond miner...

Governmentpolicy causes economic decline

1 week ago - 17 May 2019 | Business

Local businesses burdened with a crushingly tough economic climate feel the government's policies have contributed to the current climate, particularly legislation aimed at empowerment and...

Phosphate mining headache continues

1 week ago - 16 May 2019 | Business

ELLANIE SMIT The Chamber of Mines of Namibia is concerned that a way forward on marine phosphate...

Save jobs, buy local

1 week ago - 16 May 2019 | Business

Team Namibia has urged Namibians “now more than ever” to buy local in order to have a positive impact on the economy, reduce poverty and...

Mining: Sunrise, sunset?

1 week ago - 15 May 2019 | Business

Jo-Maré Duddy - Namibia’s mining sector needs policies which will transform the sector from a perceived “sunset” industry to a “sunrise” industry.This will allow investment...

Elevating internal audit’s role: The digitally fit function

1 week ago - 15 May 2019 | Business

Organisations are rapidly rolling out digital initiatives in an arena defined by more data, more automation, sophisticated cyber attacks, and constantly evolving customer expectations. In...

Latest News

10% water hike coming

2 days ago - 24 May 2019 | Disasters

The City of Windhoek has proposed a 10% water and 5% sewer tariff hike to come into effect in July. The City's recently announced...

Low earners excluded from drought...

2 days ago - 24 May 2019 | Disasters

Households with a combined income of more than N$2 600 will not qualify for state drought assistance, which has effectively excluded even low-level civil servants...

How did we get here?

2 days ago - 24 May 2019 | Opinion

How did we get to a situation, as a country, where our government is asking already struggling workers to donate 2% of the salaries as...

AMTA ends Fysal agreement

2 days ago - 24 May 2019 | Agriculture

Fysal Fresh Produce is to retrench 60 employees at the end of this month after its contract with the Agro-Marketing Trading Agency (AMTA) was terminated....

Geingob grills Nanso

2 days ago - 24 May 2019 | Education

The Namibia National Students Organisation (Nanso) leadership received a grilling from President Hage Geingob on Wednesday during a meeting to discuss a number of issues,...

Fallout over 2% tax

2 days ago - 24 May 2019 | Economics

Political parties and analysts have called on the government to abandon a plan to introduce a “voluntary” 2% tax to fund drought relief.Prime Minister Saara...

Bild challenges Guibeb

2 days ago - 24 May 2019 | International

The German newspaper Bild has rubbished a claim by the Namibian ambassador to Germany, Andreas Guibeb, that no arrest warrant had been issued against him.The...

Namibia ranks poorly for diversity

2 days ago - 24 May 2019 | Cultural

For a country that is described by many as one of the most diverse in the world, Namibia has ranked fairly poorly in a new...

Business ponders mass exodus

2 days ago - 24 May 2019 | Business

A recent survey by the Economic Policy Research Association (EPRA) of close to 600 businesses concerned about the government's policy direction shows that a staggering...

Load More