'Strange’ Gustavo judgement criticised

High Court judge Herman Oosthuizen’s comments that the Fishrot accused is unlikely to be found guilty of the charges against him have been labelled ‘strange’ and ‘pre-emptive’.

23 December 2021 | Justice

JEMIMA BEUKES







WINDHOEK

The comprehensive bail but ‘strange’ judgement of one of the Fishrot accused by High Court Judge Herman Oosthuizen has ruffled some feathers.

According to Oosthuizen, it is unlikely Ricardo Gustavo will be found guilty of all or some of the charges - a position experts have criticised as presumptive.

Oosthuizen said while under oath, Gustavo not only proclaimed his innocence and his intention to stand trial, but also said he would not evade justice or interfere or tamper with state witnesses. He added that he believes Gustavo went out of his way to show that he is willing to cooperate with the State, such as having himself fitted with a GPS device to have his movements monitored around the clock.

“It is true that the State supplied the court with numerous documents it intends to use at the trial. It is also true that on some of those documents, the applicant was at pains to give a compelling explanation indicating innocence per se, but then it was not his duty. At the trial, the State will have the duty to prove that the accused is guilty beyond reasonable doubt.”

‘Strange’

Political commentator Ndumba Kamwanya found Oosthuizen’s judgement “strange and pre-emptive”, which may not bode well for the future of the Fishrot trial.

“I think it is very strange to make these remarks in a bail hearing, because it pre-empts the criminal case. That pre-emptory statement is troublesome in terms of the pending case and gives a wrong impression... I am sure from a legal perspective it is something permissible to say, but my understanding is that the bail hearing should solely focus on the bail aspect,” he said.

Analyst Graham Hopwood said the judge is entitled to that view, but added that he thought the prosecution showed they had a serious case during the bail hearing.

“But the decision on guilt or innocence can only be taken by the trial judge on full presentation of the evidence.”

Dismissive

Hopwood added that while it is commonly understood that a judge will base his or her judgement on matters of law and not on public opinion, it was unnecessary to dismiss public opinion and outrage the way he did.

“He didn't need to be so dismissive. He could have just said he is basing his decision on legal principles. It is surely a good thing if people are outraged by alleged corruption and being able to express such views is fundamental to democracy.”

In his judgement, Oosthuizen dismissed social media, public gatherings and protests as barometers of public interest.

Defending his position to grant Gustavo bail, he said he is convinced that “appropriate strict bail conditions serve the public interest” and the “proper administration of justice”, and allows an accused to properly prepare for trial.

[email protected]iansun.com

Similar News

 

NSFAF sticks to guns on Nghiwete reinstatement

16 hours ago | Justice

JEMIMA BEUKESThe Namibia Students Financial Assistance Fund (NSFAF) says the trust relationship between itself and its chief executive officer (CEO) Hilya Nghiwete has irretrievably broken...

In the jaws of justice

3 days ago - 21 January 2022 | Justice

ELLANIE SMIT, JANA-MARI SMITH, MATHIAS HAUFIKU AND OGONE TLHAGE · Esau spent N$900k from undeclared account while...

Missed birth defect leads to N$1m lawsuit

3 days ago - 21 January 2022 | Justice

JANA-MARI SMITH WINDHOEKA young mother whose baby lived for only six days is suing...

Anxiety, hope surround landmark same-sex marriage judgment

6 days ago - 18 January 2022 | Justice

JANA-MARI SMITHWINDHOEKThe long legal battle against the government by two Namibians and their same-sex, foreign-born spouses is heading towards a watershed judgment in the Windhoek...

Kora judgment delayed again

6 days ago - 18 January 2022 | Justice

ELLANIE SMITWINDHOEKJudgment in the legal battle involving the cancelled Kora Music Awards event has been postponed again.Judge Herman Oosthuizen, who was supposed to deliver the...

Murder-accused pastors, wives secure legal aid

1 week ago - 17 January 2022 | Justice

Kenya Kambowe KAHENGETwo self-proclaimed pastors and their customary wives from the Kavango West Region, who stand accused of three murders and...

Amadhila duped me, pensioner claims

1 week ago - 14 January 2022 | Justice

OGONE TLHAGE WINDHOEKA 69-year-old pensioner, Tobias Mundjele, claims he was cheated out of a closed corporation he started with northern-based businessman Tobias...

Boulter murder case halted

1 week ago - 12 January 2022 | Justice

ENZO AMUELEKAMANJABMurder-accused Harvey Boulter, who was last year released on N$500 000 bail, made a brief court appearance in the Kamanjab Magistrate’s Court yesterday.This while...

Job changes course on Red Line

2 weeks ago - 10 January 2022 | Justice

ELLANIE SMITWINDHOEKAffirmative Repositioning (AR) activist Job Amupanda has amended the particulars of claim in his court case seeking the removal of the controversial northern veterinary...

Gustavo bail: CRAN weighs in on GPS

2 weeks ago - 06 January 2022 | Justice

Comedy of errors over proposed tracking device CRAN, ACC and the PG have all indicated that they have no legal means to implement Judge Herman...

Latest News

U/20 trials an important starting...

16 hours ago | Sports

ANDREW POOLMANNewly appointed head coach Chrysander Botha accepted the challenge of putting together the strongest possible Namibian under-20 rugby team after the trials held in...

Desert Storm, Tugstsogt settle for...

16 hours ago | Sports

ATLANTIC CITY, N.J. — Sakaria (Desert Storm) Lukas stepped in to the opening bout of a Showtime Championship Boxing card, replacing the COVID-compromised Vic Pasillas in a...

Low volumes of cargo during...

16 hours ago | Economics

PHILLEPUS UUSIKUDuring the month of November 2021, exports amounting to N$5 billion, representing 56.6% of total exports left the country by sea, according to the...

NSFAF sticks to guns on...

16 hours ago | Justice

JEMIMA BEUKESThe Namibia Students Financial Assistance Fund (NSFAF) says the trust relationship between itself and its chief executive officer (CEO) Hilya Nghiwete has irretrievably broken...

Not our tradition – Onesi...

16 hours ago | Cultural

TUYEIMO HAIDULAONESIThe community of Onesi in the Omusati region is not in favour of legalising abortion because their tradition does not allow it.Speaking at the...

Churches condemn mandatory vaccination

16 hours ago | Health

ESTER KAMATIWINDHOEKThe Association of Christian Churches in Namibia (ACCN) has condemned the mandatory vaccination after some companies publicly implied that unvaccinated employees could lose their...

Corporates, don’t give up on...

16 hours ago | Sports

JESSE JACKSON KAURAISAWhen a child is misbehaving at home, as parents, our role is not to chase them away but to mentor them into becoming...

Five spots available for cyclists...

16 hours ago | Sports

NAMPA – The national coach at the cycling federation, Hans du Toit, says the Namibia Cycling Federation (NCF) will use upcoming races to select riders...

Poor nations to receive Merck...

16 hours ago | Economics

FRANCESCO GUARASCIONearly 30 generic drugmakers in Asia, Africa and the Middle East will make cheap versions of Merck & Co's Covid-19 pill, under a landmark...

Load More