Soldiers, police accused of assault

A Rundu woman charged with illegal ivory possession is suing three government ministries for N$150 000, claiming that she was tortured after her arrest.

05 June 2019 | Justice

A 41-year-old Rundu woman is suing for N$150 000 in damages for torture she alleges was inflicted by members of an anti-poaching team who arrested her on a charge of possession of elephant tusks in February 2018.

In the lawsuit filed with the Windhoek High Court in April last year, Klementine Tjilepo Mungeli claimed her right to dignity was violated by at least three members of a team of soldiers and police. She claimed they slapped and beat her with a rifle after handcuffing her.

Initially, Mungeli's legal team cited the ministry of safety and security as the sole respondent in the case. But the case was amended to include the environment and tourism ministry and the defence ministry as second and third respondents.

The respondents have denied any wrongdoing.

The safety and security ministry stated that an internal investigation showed that three of the arresting officers were defence force soldiers, and that the police officer involved in the arrest denied she was tortured.

In papers filed last month, the government attorneys acting on behalf of the respondents asked the court to dismiss the claim with costs for a number of reasons.

In her particulars of claim Mungeli alleges three men assaulted her in the presence of another three arresting officers or soldiers, who did nothing to prevent the others from assaulting her.

She claims she was slapped, handcuffed and hit with an assault rifle on her upper body and buttocks several times. She has submitted photos to the court showing the bruising she allegedly sustained.

Further, she claims that she was forced to crawl on her knees for about five metres while handcuffed.

She claims that while shuffling on her knees, the beatings continued as she was hit with a stick and the butt of an assault rifle, while others aimed the rifle at her and threatened to kill her.

She says she “reasonably believed the members of the Namibian police were going to execute such threats.”

Mungeli claims she remained behind bars for three days and was not given an opportunity to visit a hospital or clinic.

She further claims that despite informing the personnel that she was diabetic, she was not given any food and she was also not provided with bedding while in custody.

The contains a list of damages Mungeli claims she sustained during her time in custody, including pain and suffering, injury to her self-esteem, bruised and swollen feet and toes, bruises and swelling to her buttocks, and general body pain.

“For two days Mungeli was unable to sit on her buttocks and thereafter for a further six days it was painful to sit on the buttocks,” the claim reads.

She claims that she had to undergo medical treatment and counselling because of the alleged assault.



Legal battle

In the past months, lawyers acting on behalf of the opposing parties have applied for the claim to be dismissed, based on legal wrangling around the respondents initially not listed in the claim filed by Mungeli.

Lawyers for the safety and security ministry further note that according to police records Mungeli had no injuries after her arrest. They further deny that the police failed to offer to take her to a hospital or clinic.

In addition, the papers claim she was released a day after her arrest, on 11 February, and rearrested ten minutes later for further investigation. Mungeli claims that she initially believed her alleged torturers were all members of the police force.

However, at the start of the criminal trial in which she is accused of illegal possession of elephant tusks, she realised the team had consisted of soldiers, police and employees of the environment ministry

Mungeli was represented by Ricardo Mukonda while government attorney Wensie Uakuramenua represented the ministries. Judge Herman Oosthuizen presided.

In May the case was postponed to 1 July for a case management conference hearing.



JANA-MARI SMITH

Similar News

 

'Councillor punched me till I coughed blood'

3 days ago - 01 July 2020 | Justice

KENYA KAMBOWERUNDUKristine Tjarura Likakatere (63), who was allegedly assaulted by her cousin, Rundu Rural constituency councillor Michael Shikongo, says she was slapped and punched in...

Fishcor's Nghipunya denied bail

3 days ago - 01 July 2020 | Justice

OGONE TLHAGEWINDHOEKMike Nghipunya, the suspended CEO of the National Fishing Corporation of Namibia (Fishcor), was denied bail by the Windhoek Magistrate's Court yesterday.He is implicated...

Babi and follower charged with bribery

4 days ago - 30 June 2020 | Justice

FRANCOISE STEYNBERG WINDHOEKAccused rhino poacher Jackson Babi (30) and one of his followers, Ananias Ananias, appeared on two corruption charges before the Windhoek Magistrate's Court...

Chinese murder suspects to plead in August

4 days ago - 30 June 2020 | Justice

KENYA KAMBOWERUNDUTwo Chinese shop owners, Xuefeng Chen (30) and Zhenhai Zhou (32), who allegedly killed an employee at Andara village in the Kavango East by...

Rape accused denied bail at Mariental

1 week ago - 25 June 2020 | Justice

NAMPAMARIENTALA 39-year-old man who was arrested this past Saturday for allegedly raping of a 21-year-old woman in Mariental's Ombili informal settlement made his first court...

Lack of magistrates frustrates lawyers

1 week ago - 24 June 2020 | Justice

ILENI NANDJATO OSHAKATI A lack of magistrates in northern courts is frustrating lawyers operating in this area. They say there is...

Kora dirty laundry to be aired in September

1 week ago - 23 June 2020 | Justice

ELLANIE SMITWINDHOEKThe Kora All-Africa Music Awards scandal, in which N$23 million was paid from government coffers for an event that never took place, will play...

Covid-19 fugitive can't appear in court

1 week ago - 22 June 2020 | Justice

OGONE TLHAGEWINDHOEKImmanuel David, a Namibian-born South African passport holder who entered the country illegally by crossing the Orange River in a canoe, is yet to...

G4S sued for N$1m by security guard

2 weeks ago - 17 June 2020 | Justice

JANA-MARI SMITHWINDHOEKA security guard is suing G4s Security Services and a senior manager there for N$1 million for an alleged death threat made during an...

No arrest warrant for fugitive Fishrot lawyer

2 weeks ago - 16 June 2020 | Justice

OGONE TLHAGEWINDHOEKThere is still no warrant of arrest out for fugitive lawyer Marén de Klerk, wanted in connection with N$90 million paid out in dubious...

Latest News

Big honour for Air Namibia’s...

1 day - 03 July 2020 | People

MICHELLINE NAWATISES Victor Nghifindaka, who hails from the Ondobe-yeno village in the Ohangwena Region, has been appointed as a member of the International Air...

Swapo exposes Nujoma to attacks...

1 day - 03 July 2020 | Politics

STAFF REPORTERWINDHOEKFormer youth minister Kazenambo Kazenambo says Swapo must take the blame for founding president Sam Nujoma being called a 'thug and liar' in parliament...

Mask-less Iipumbu spat on me:...

1 day - 03 July 2020 | Politics

STAFF REPORTERWINDHOEKSwapo MP Natangwe Iithete says he shoved Namibia Economic Freedom Fighters (NEFF) counterpart Kalimbo Iipumbu in the National Assembly on Wednesday because the opposition...

Conquering the logistics world every...

1 day - 03 July 2020 | People

Michelline Nawatises Oscar Kanovengi was born in Windhoek on 17 September 1978, the year in which the Herero Paramount Chief Clemence Kapuuo was assassinated....

Child marriage still prevalent

1 day - 03 July 2020 | Cultural

ELLANIE SMITWINDHOEKA total of 7% of girls in Namibia are married before the age of 18 and 2% are married before their 15th birthday.Although the...

Reconciliation too loose a concept

1 day - 03 July 2020 | Opinion

Reconciliation has become a buzzword lately in the National Assembly, but this has only solicited insults and physical scuffles.Part of the problem is that the...

Mayana community demonstrates over land

1 day - 03 July 2020 | Economics

The community of Mayana in the Kavango East region held a demonstration against what they termed “illegal land grabbing” by the Mayana Small Scale Irrigation...

Harnessing curiosity

1 day - 03 July 2020 | Banking

Mariselle Stofberg The diverse and ambitious Marion Scheün advises young individuals to find something that they are passionate about and cultivate that into a career....

Quarantine options under stage four

1 day - 03 July 2020 | Health

OGONE TLHAGEWINDHOEKPeople who do not want to commit themselves to quarantine facilities funded by the state will have the option to do so once the...

Load More