SME Bank liquidation appealed

The Zimbabwean shareholders of SME Bank say other options should have been considered instead of closing the “tool of upliftment”.

11 October 2018 | Banking


The Zimbabwean Metropolitan Bank and World Eagle Properties have appealed to the Supreme Court to overturn the High Court order that placed the looted SME Bank in liquidation.

The two entities claim there was a “cumulative effect” of irregularities, non-compliances and abuses of Bank of Namibia (BoN) procedures in the process of placing the SME Bank in liquidation.

The legal representatives for MetBank and World Eagle, Sisa Namandje and advocate Anthony Bishop, argued that the provisions of the Banking Institutions Act, as well as relevant provisions of the Companies Act, were neither interpreted by the High Court nor applied by the BoN.

They claimed the BoN had “elevated” the operation of the Companies Act and the Banking Institutions Act to a position superior to that of the Namibian constitution, and thereby failed to pay sufficient attention to constitutional imperatives.

They said the SME Bank’s liquidation cannot be viewed as “ordinary” because the bank was created as a “tool of upliftment” for the previously disadvantaged and was aimed at raising the living standards of Namibians.

Therefore, MetBank and World Eagle Properties - minority shareholders in the SME Bank - stated that no liquidation order ought to have been given.

They argued that a liquidation order should only have been brought by the SME Bank itself, one or more creditors or members or the Master of the High Court.

Alternatively, they said, the SME Bank should have been placed under provisional judicial management and that the Namibian government, which has a 65% shareholding, should have explained why an order for the recapitalisation of the bank was not possible or viable.

Alleged non-compliances

Namandje and Bishop said there were various prejudicial non-compliances in terms of the Companies Act, which they said were wrongfully rejected by the High Court.

They said the application for the final liquidation was first lodged with the Master of the High Court before it was issued to the registrar of that court, saying this meant that the entire High Court application was a nullity.

They also said the liquidators of the SME Bank, David Bruni and Ian McLaren, had not been properly appointed, and the BoN had run roughshod over provisions of the Banking Institutions Act too.

They added that when the liquidators were appointed the BoN had failed to designate a banking expert to assist them, and that all decisions taken by Bruni and McLaren were therefore invalid.

The appeal was heard by judges Sylvester Mainga, Dave Smuts and Elton Hoff on Tuesday.

Similar News


Cheques phased out by Bank Windhoek

4 days ago - 14 December 2018 | Banking

Bank Windhoek’s final cut-off date for processing of cheques as a means of payment will be 30 June 2019. “This is to meet the Namibian...

SME holiday preparation tips

2 weeks ago - 30 November 2018 | Banking

As the festive season approaches, some businesses will close for the holidays. This time of year allows businesses to reflect on their achievements and the...

Easy and accessible banking

2 weeks ago - 30 November 2018 | Banking

From humble beginnings in 1907 with only 12 employees in Lüderitz, the FirstRand Namibia Group today employs more than 2 300 people.FirstRand Namibia Group has...

Green giant rises in CBD

2 weeks ago - 28 November 2018 | Banking

Staff Reporter – Almost N$700 000 will be spent every day for the next two-and-a-half years building Nedbank Namibia’s new head office at Freedom Plaza...

FNB Namibia appoints national sales manager

3 weeks ago - 23 November 2018 | Banking

Kalla Toivo has been appointed as FNB’s national sales manager. Toivo joined FNB Namibia in 2008 as a seasonal worker in the exclusive banking department...

The Benefits of sustainable investments

3 weeks ago - 21 November 2018 | Banking

Claire HobbsIn many first world economies, the effects of global warming continue to manifest as a business reality. In response to this crisis, the Namibian...

Surviving Black Friday

3 weeks ago - 21 November 2018 | Banking

Before you head out the door this weekend with a strong cup of coffee, some patience for crowds and comfortable shoes, plan ahead with these...

Good Business

4 weeks ago - 20 November 2018 | Banking

The Development Bank of Namibia (DBN) held its annual Good Business Awards and Innovation Award ceremony in Windhoek on Thursday evening. The black-tie event saw...

Bank Windhoek rewards top coastal estate agents

1 month - 14 November 2018 | Banking

J&B Estates was awarded as the top estate agency for the coastal region at the recently concluded Bank Windhoek Coastal Estate Agents Awards ceremony hosted...

MSR brings hope

1 month - 09 November 2018 | Banking

Unemployment and poverty are just two socio-economic challenges that impede human progress. Not having the means to purchase essential goods, such as food, can impede...

Latest News

Police divers search for drowning...

21 hours ago | Crime

Police divers are searching for the bodies of four girls - aged 13, 15, 16 and 17 - who drowned in the Orange River on...

Support your child

21 hours ago | Columns

For many thousands of young Namibians, who wrote their grade 10 and matric examinations this year, it is a time of great uncertainty, as they...

PDM embarrassed by govt

21 hours ago | Politics

The Popular Democratic Movement (PDM) says 2018 was an embarrassing year, as government leaders failed to address rising labour, social and economic problems. PDM...

Iilonga to be buried in...

21 hours ago | People

President Hage Geingob has accorded liberation veteran, politician and unionist Petrus Iilonga a state funeral.In a media statement, the presidency announced that Iilonga would be...

Mujoro 'excited' about DRC EVMs

21 hours ago | Politics

With elections in the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC) slated for 23 December, Electoral Commission of Namibia (ECN) chief electoral officer Theo Mujuro is currently...

Litterbugs beware

21 hours ago | Environment

Littering and other environmental damage will not be tolerated in Namibia's national parks and protected areas this festive season. The environment ministry, together with the...

Van der Westhuizen tops

21 hours ago | Sports

An 80-year-old golfer, Piet van der Westhuizen, was recently crowned as the winner of the Bank Windhoek Senior Open Golf Championship that took place in...

Legends turn on Mourinho

21 hours ago | Sports

Jose Mourinho came under fire from Manchester United legends after his side's dismal display in a 3-1 defeat at Liverpool that underlined just how far...

Magic to tango with Julinho

21 hours ago | Sports

Tura Magic will clash with Julinho Sporting tonight in the 2018/19 Namibia Premier League (NPL).The match will take place at the Sam Nujoma Stadium at...

Load More