SME Bank liquidation appealed

The Zimbabwean shareholders of SME Bank say other options should have been considered instead of closing the “tool of upliftment”.

11 October 2018 | Banking


The Zimbabwean Metropolitan Bank and World Eagle Properties have appealed to the Supreme Court to overturn the High Court order that placed the looted SME Bank in liquidation.

The two entities claim there was a “cumulative effect” of irregularities, non-compliances and abuses of Bank of Namibia (BoN) procedures in the process of placing the SME Bank in liquidation.

The legal representatives for MetBank and World Eagle, Sisa Namandje and advocate Anthony Bishop, argued that the provisions of the Banking Institutions Act, as well as relevant provisions of the Companies Act, were neither interpreted by the High Court nor applied by the BoN.

They claimed the BoN had “elevated” the operation of the Companies Act and the Banking Institutions Act to a position superior to that of the Namibian constitution, and thereby failed to pay sufficient attention to constitutional imperatives.

They said the SME Bank’s liquidation cannot be viewed as “ordinary” because the bank was created as a “tool of upliftment” for the previously disadvantaged and was aimed at raising the living standards of Namibians.

Therefore, MetBank and World Eagle Properties - minority shareholders in the SME Bank - stated that no liquidation order ought to have been given.

They argued that a liquidation order should only have been brought by the SME Bank itself, one or more creditors or members or the Master of the High Court.

Alternatively, they said, the SME Bank should have been placed under provisional judicial management and that the Namibian government, which has a 65% shareholding, should have explained why an order for the recapitalisation of the bank was not possible or viable.

Alleged non-compliances

Namandje and Bishop said there were various prejudicial non-compliances in terms of the Companies Act, which they said were wrongfully rejected by the High Court.

They said the application for the final liquidation was first lodged with the Master of the High Court before it was issued to the registrar of that court, saying this meant that the entire High Court application was a nullity.

They also said the liquidators of the SME Bank, David Bruni and Ian McLaren, had not been properly appointed, and the BoN had run roughshod over provisions of the Banking Institutions Act too.

They added that when the liquidators were appointed the BoN had failed to designate a banking expert to assist them, and that all decisions taken by Bruni and McLaren were therefore invalid.

The appeal was heard by judges Sylvester Mainga, Dave Smuts and Elton Hoff on Tuesday.

Similar News


FirstRand Foundation supports mentorship and business skills training

5 days ago - 19 October 2018 | Banking

FNB Business division’s new business development manager Alexzander Shikemeni on behalf of the foundation emphasised that SMEs in Namibia form the backbone of the economy,...

FNB Namibia supports the manufacturing association

6 days ago - 18 October 2018 | Banking

FNB Namibia’s business division has reiterated its support towards the Namibia Manufacturers Association (NMA) Manufacturer of the Year Awards ceremony, which will take place on...

Kamushinda accused of dirty tricks

1 week ago - 12 October 2018 | Banking

The Supreme Court of Namibia on Tuesday reserved judgement in a matter in which Metropolitan Bank of Zimbabwe and World Eagle Investment are trying to...

Bank Windhoek, Adonai Trust upskill Walvis Bay inmates

1 week ago - 12 October 2018 | Banking

A total of 86 inmates from the Walvis Bay Correctional Facility took part in a two-week Money Map training session hosted by Bank Windhoek and...

SME Bank liquidation appealed

1 week ago - 11 October 2018 | Banking

CATHERINE SASMAN The Zimbabwean Metropolitan Bank and World Eagle Properties have appealed to the Supreme Court to overturn the High...

Serving the people, the executive way

2 weeks ago - 09 October 2018 | Banking

Members of the executive leadership team of Bank Windhoek and its holding company, Capricorn Group, joined the rest of the world in paying homage to...

Bank Windhoek appoints national operations manager

2 weeks ago - 05 October 2018 | Banking

Bank Windhoek is pleased to announce the appointment of David Nell as its new National Operations Manager, effective 1 September 2018. David takes over from...

Lending a hand with serviced land

3 weeks ago - 28 September 2018 | Banking

In order to help municipalities and town councils speed up the servicing of land, FNB Namibia has decided to grant local authorities loans that they...

Bank Windhoek finances 5, 78 MW Solar Plant

3 weeks ago - 28 September 2018 | Banking

Bank Windhoek, in conjunction with Enertronica Group, recently financed the construction of the Trekkopje Solar Project, in the Erongo region as part of the development...

Entrepreneurs: When the going gets tough, the tough gets...

4 weeks ago - 25 September 2018 | Banking

Entrepreneurs are people are skilled at adapting and being resilient in uncertain situations and come up with new, different and innovative ideas.“The challenges currently being...

Latest News

Supreme Court upholds SME Bank...

6 hours ago | Justice

The Supreme Court yesterday dismissed an appeal by Metropolitan Bank of Zimbabwe and World Eagle Properties against a High Court order for the final liquidation...

Progress on revenue agency

6 hours ago | Government

The ministry of finance is positive that the new Namibia Revenue Agency (Namra) will become operational at the beginning of the next fiscal year. The...

City intrigue a big yawn

6 hours ago | Columns

The City of Windhoek, which has not exactly covered itself in glory when it comes to handling its finances and delivering services to residents, including...

Young businessman a vital cog...

6 hours ago | Business

Andreas Armas of Andreas Armas Stevedoring CC and Misty Bay CC says he runs successful businesses in this tough sector.“I started my stevedoring company in...

Africa news in briefs

6 hours ago | Economics

Author of critical book on Egypt's economy arrestedEgyptian police on Sunday arrested the author of a book about Egypt’s economy on charges of publishing false...

GIPF beneficiaries wait in abject...

6 hours ago | Government

An Omusati family from Ombwata village in Okahao are living in abject poverty, despite being entitled to a Government Institutions Pension Fund (GIPF) death benefit...

Procurement remains too secretive

6 hours ago | Government

The integrity of Namibia's public procurement system is undercut by a widespread lack of transparency and accountability, leading to serious concerns that state tenders remain...

Katima in refuse collection bind

6 hours ago | Government

The Katima Mulilo town council will no longer be able to provide its residents with refuse removal services, owing to the re-advertisement of a tender.Acting...

Earning your bonus

6 hours ago | Business

JAN COETZEEThe end of another year is rapidly approaching and all thoughts are on December and the festive season, which is the season of giving....

Load More