SME Bank liquidation appealed

The Zimbabwean shareholders of SME Bank say other options should have been considered instead of closing the “tool of upliftment”.

11 October 2018 | Banking


The Zimbabwean Metropolitan Bank and World Eagle Properties have appealed to the Supreme Court to overturn the High Court order that placed the looted SME Bank in liquidation.

The two entities claim there was a “cumulative effect” of irregularities, non-compliances and abuses of Bank of Namibia (BoN) procedures in the process of placing the SME Bank in liquidation.

The legal representatives for MetBank and World Eagle, Sisa Namandje and advocate Anthony Bishop, argued that the provisions of the Banking Institutions Act, as well as relevant provisions of the Companies Act, were neither interpreted by the High Court nor applied by the BoN.

They claimed the BoN had “elevated” the operation of the Companies Act and the Banking Institutions Act to a position superior to that of the Namibian constitution, and thereby failed to pay sufficient attention to constitutional imperatives.

They said the SME Bank’s liquidation cannot be viewed as “ordinary” because the bank was created as a “tool of upliftment” for the previously disadvantaged and was aimed at raising the living standards of Namibians.

Therefore, MetBank and World Eagle Properties - minority shareholders in the SME Bank - stated that no liquidation order ought to have been given.

They argued that a liquidation order should only have been brought by the SME Bank itself, one or more creditors or members or the Master of the High Court.

Alternatively, they said, the SME Bank should have been placed under provisional judicial management and that the Namibian government, which has a 65% shareholding, should have explained why an order for the recapitalisation of the bank was not possible or viable.

Alleged non-compliances

Namandje and Bishop said there were various prejudicial non-compliances in terms of the Companies Act, which they said were wrongfully rejected by the High Court.

They said the application for the final liquidation was first lodged with the Master of the High Court before it was issued to the registrar of that court, saying this meant that the entire High Court application was a nullity.

They also said the liquidators of the SME Bank, David Bruni and Ian McLaren, had not been properly appointed, and the BoN had run roughshod over provisions of the Banking Institutions Act too.

They added that when the liquidators were appointed the BoN had failed to designate a banking expert to assist them, and that all decisions taken by Bruni and McLaren were therefore invalid.

The appeal was heard by judges Sylvester Mainga, Dave Smuts and Elton Hoff on Tuesday.

Similar News


A mutual love for kapana

4 weeks ago - 17 May 2019 | Banking

Ester KamatiThe 2019 edition of the Nedbank Kapana Cook-off was launched on 10 May.The launch was hosted by Matthew Kapofi and included demonstrations by kapana...

Standard Bank: Investing in economic progression

1 month - 30 April 2019 | Banking

Standard Bank Namibia is fully committed to boosting investment and job creation through facilitating win-win smart partnerships that speak to managing economic headwinds, delivering on...

No more minting of 5c coins

1 month - 24 April 2019 | Banking

The Bank of Namibia (BoN) has discontinued the minting of 5c coins as from the beginning of the year, the central bank said in a...

Standard Bank awards bursaries

1 month - 18 April 2019 | Banking

Standard Bank recently awarded bursaries to four students studying cybersecurity, forensic science and actuarial science, as part of its annual bursary programme.The bank awarded bursaries...

SME Bank: Asset seizures coming

1 month - 17 April 2019 | Banking

Enock Kamushinda and other Zimbabweans implicated in the raiding of the SME Bank have until 14 June to explain why the deputy sheriff of the...

Longrich ordered to cease operations

2 months ago - 15 April 2019 | Banking

The Bank of Namibia (BoN) has declared Longrich Bioscience an illegal pyramid scheme and ordered all involved to cease operations immediately.A statement issued by the...

Longrich Bioscience an ‘illegal financial scheme’

2 months ago - 13 April 2019 | Banking

The Bank of Namibia (BoN) has issued a statement saying Longrich Bioscience is an illegal financial scheme and has warned the public not to engage...

Going, going, gone

3 months ago - 14 March 2019 | Banking

The sole director of, which was housed in a non-descript office in Centurion, Johannesburg, has given a first-hand account of how the millions raided...

'Ask no questions, hear no lies'

3 months ago - 12 March 2019 | Banking

The liquidators of the SME Bank, David Bruni and Ian McLaren, have applied to the Gauteng High Court in South Africa to freeze five bank...

How SME Bank was looted

3 months ago - 07 March 2019 | Banking

Advocate Raymond Heathcote, acting on behalf of SME Bank liquidators David Bruni and Ian McLaren, said in court this week that the case read like...

Latest News

Kalahari turns deadly

2 days ago - 14 June 2019 | Crime

Namibia's police chief has strongly condemned the killing of an unarmed taxi driver by a soldier attached to Operation Kalahari Desert and vowed this will...

Swapo suspends dissidents

2 days ago - 14 June 2019 | Politics

Swapo secretary-general Sophia Shaningwa yesterday refused to comment on the sudden suspension of six influential party leaders in Otjozondjupa. Otjozondjupa governor Otto Iipinge, along with...

Horrific, but inevitable

2 days ago - 14 June 2019 | Columns

Incidences of assaults by military personnel on civilians have been widely reported in the mainstream media and on social media over the last couple of...

Hopeless, destitute

2 days ago - 14 June 2019 | Social Issues

A family of five at Kayeura village in the Musese constituency of Kavango East are living amid hopelessness in a makeshift structure made of pieces...

Kingship battle escalates

2 days ago - 14 June 2019 | Cultural

An Ondonga faction backing Konis Eino Kalenga is likely to proceed with an application to interdict urban and rural development minister Peya Mushelenga and Oshana...

We are kept in dark...

2 days ago - 14 June 2019 | Life Style

Education minister Katrina Hanse-Himarwa says 'The Journey' human rights campaign, which ends today, is the perfect platform for even the most timid voices to speak...

The feisty hustler out to...

2 days ago - 14 June 2019 | Art and Entertainment

Having performed in Angola, Nigeria at the AYLIVE comedy concert, doing songs with Top Cheri and Zimbabwe's KNG BL, and being invited to represent Namibia...

NBC launches Body with Maria...

2 days ago - 14 June 2019 | Art and Entertainment

Host Maria Nepembe describes the show as a reality TV show that focuses on fitness and health. “We are getting 10 individuals who want to...

Let's talk hip-hop

2 days ago - 14 June 2019 | Columns

I remember mockingly being called a ‘n*gga’ in my location for my dress code, choice of music and how I chose to carry myself.Today I...

Load More