Sewerage tussle spills over

09 August 2019 | Justice

Namibia Breweries Limited (NBL) and Windhoek municipality representatives are to continue negotiations in September to resolve a close to N$4 million lawsuit brought by NBL in connection with disputed sewerage service charges and wastewater sampling results.

The parties attended a High Court ordered mediation on 31 July and this week informed Judge Hannelie Prinsloo that they had agreed to continue settlement negotiations in September.

In March, NBL sued the municipality for N$3 933 426.07 in damages, based on penalty charges imposed by the municipality in 2017 for sewerage services at the NBL brewery in Windhoek's northern industrial area.

NBL informed the court that it had received a municipal bill for effluent services in March 2017, and then became aware that the municipality had, in addition to the normal monthly charge for sewerage, levied a penalty charge.





NBL further claims that although it objected to the multimillion-dollar charges levied against them for September and December 2016, and January and February 2017, it ultimately had to pay the charges, as the municipality refused to budge.

The NBL claims that the municipality, as the service provider, had a duty of care to exercise the skill and care of a reasonable supplier of the sewerage services, but was negligent in that regard, which led to the charges imposed on the NBL.

The negligence is related to the penalty charges based on samples taken of wastewater at the NBL plant.

The NBL argues the samples were “faulty and inaccurate”, and, moreover, that the municipality failed to take further samples to correct the mistake or inaccuracy of the original samples.

The NBL concludes that the municipality analysed these faulty and inaccurate samples and on that basis charged penalties that were “in excess of what the defendant was entitled to charge in terms of the sewerage regulations”.

They claim the sampling was not done in accordance with relevant regulations, and that moreover NBL was denied its rights to obtain half of the sample taken by the municipal engineer, and was not informed accordingly.



Denied

In its plea filed at court, the municipality denied wrongdoing, underlining that the samples were taken correctly and the analysis was accurate.

It further stated that the additional charges were a service charge for “dealing with the treatment of the excess industrial effluent and to address the environmental damage caused by the plaintiff's industrial effluent discharged into the defendant's sewerage system.”

NBL in a responding plea denied that the effluent discharged from its premises had caused any environmental damage.

The municipality further informed the court that the municipality charges a monthly service fee for authorised industrial effluent and any excess effluent.

It claims NBL was issued a sewage service permit, which sets out allowable thresholds of industrial effluent discharged into the sewerage system.

“It was a condition of the permit that the [NBL] is obliged to pay for excess.”

The municipality further denied that the sampling methods were faulty, stating it had used “prescribed methods of testing samples in determining the level of pollutants that the plaintiff dumps into the municipal sewerage system”.

It said in the case of testing samples at NBL, a composite or grab sample was taken to determine the pollutant levels, as per regulations.

Based on these samples, the municipality says it “then made a determination of the applicable charge, which is correct, fair and reasonable”.

A report submitted to court, based on an investigation launched by the municipality following NBL's inquiry into its effluent charges, states that the sampling found unusually high chemical oxygen demand (COD) levels in its industrial effluent in September 2016 and February 2017.

The investigation report indicates that the NBL at the time wrote to the municipality that the “possibility of such high COD is nearly impossible”.

Mark Kutzner of Engling, Stritter & Partners is representing NBL while the municipality has brought on board Orben Sibeya of Sibeya & Partners Legal Practitioners as their representative.

The case was postponed to 19 September for a status hearing.

JANA-MARI SMITH

Similar News

 

Bizarre scenes as massacre suspect appears

1 week ago - 08 November 2019 | Justice

Sem Nauyoma Petrus (26), accused of hacking three members of his family to death with a panga on Tuesday morning, appeared before Magistrate Ilge Rheent...

Sentences slashed, convictions overturned

1 week ago - 07 November 2019 | Justice

At least seven people who pleaded guilty to crimes involving drugs, assault and theft recently had their convictions and sentences either tossed out or dramatically...

Schiefer appeals again

1 week ago - 05 November 2019 | Justice

A second appeal by Romeo Schiefer, who was sentenced to an effective 48 years in prison for the murder of his parents in October 2008,...

Govt in settlement talks over defective passport

2 weeks ago - 01 November 2019 | Justice

A father is in settlement negotiations with home affairs officials after suing the ministry for N$276 000 after a terrifying ordeal in which his 18-year-old...

Shanghala back in Kora frying pan

2 weeks ago - 29 October 2019 | Justice

ELLANIE SMIT Former attorney-general Sacky Shanghala has emerged at the centre of the removal of conditions in the...

Wasn't me – Shanghala on Kora

2 weeks ago - 28 October 2019 | Justice

Justice minister Sacky Shanghala says he was not responsible for the Kora money going missing, adding that there are deliberate political machinations at play to...

Inmate sues for N$6m over exams

2 weeks ago - 28 October 2019 | Justice

A Namibian prisoner is suing correctional services and education authorities for N$6 million, claiming he was denied the fundamental human right to education and became...

Cash-strapped health defies N$730k court order

3 weeks ago - 25 October 2019 | Justice

The health ministry has blamed a lack of money for failing to comply with a court order to pay a grieving widower N$730 000 by...

JSC probes Kora saga

3 weeks ago - 24 October 2019 | Justice

Chief Justice Peter Shivute has confirmed that the Judicial Services Commission (JSC) is trying to establish why the Kora Awards court case was recently marked...

Life for plotting husband's murder

3 weeks ago - 23 October 2019 | Justice

Rachel Rittmann (49), who arranged the murder of her husband Rudolph Rittmann (34) for financial gain and freedom to continue a love affair, was sentenced...

Latest News

August 26 CEO innovates

2 days ago - 15 November 2019 | Business

Elizabeth Joseph ...

Fishing quotas under scrutiny

2 days ago - 15 November 2019 | Fishing

President Hage Geingob and acting fisheries minister Albert Kawana will meet next week to discuss the credibility of the fishing quota allocation process, as well...

Geingob was 'talked out of'...

2 days ago - 15 November 2019 | Government

President Hage Geingob had written dismissal letters for ministers Sacky Shanghala and Bernhard Esau on Wednesday morning, but a high-level meeting that included Vice-president Nangolo...

Helping people help themselves

2 days ago - 15 November 2019 | People

Evany van WykMarjolize Scholtz has been a wellness professional for over 17 years. During her career her empathy towards people has grown immensely. Scholtz was...

Putting on a corporate...

2 days ago - 15 November 2019 | People

Elizabeth Joseph Margaret Thatcher once quipped that if you want something said, ask a man. If you want something done, ask a woman. Langford...

Fuelled by ­creativity

2 days ago - 15 November 2019 | People

Evany van Wyk “Every challenge is put on your path to groom you and build you and if I had the opportunity to change something...

A musician at heart

2 days ago - 15 November 2019 | People

Queen, Mumford and Sons, as well as Koos du Plessis are all musical influences that Ruan Greeff, or John Rock Prophet as you may know...

EVMs in the firing line

2 days ago - 15 November 2019 | Politics

Independent president candidate Panduleni Itula, the Electoral Commission of Namibia (ECN) and Swapo will square off in the electoral court on Tuesday, 19 November over...

Unshackling the toothless ACC

2 days ago - 15 November 2019 | Opinion

Much has been said about the Anti-Corruption Commission (ACC) over the years. Many have called it toothless.Revelations this week that it has been sitting on...

Load More