Quota auction disaster

Government yesterday conceded failure of its inaugural fish quota auction, which generated a shocking return on one of the country’s leading resources.

01 October 2020 | Fishing



A series of schoolboy errors has led to a massive failure of the government’s recent fish quota auction, which netted the state a paltry N$8.4 million out of successful bids that were initially worth N$464.9 million.

The successful bidders from the first round of the auction were awarded bids valued at a collective amount of N$627.9 million, but some could not make it to the second round where further scrutiny occurred.

The auction, held in part to raise funds to fight the Covid-19 pandemic, was conducted on the advice of the Presidential High Level Panel on the Namibian Economy (HLPNE).

The Johannes !Gawaxab-led panel concluded that key national resources should be disposed of more to the benefit of the broader society than that of a few rich individuals, as has been the case for decades.

Out of the highest successful bidders, only five managed to take up their offers and settled their payment obligations, which amounted to N$8 446 000, finance minister Ipumbu Shiimi told journalists late yesterday.

What may be deemed as a comedy of errors by government officials has contributed to the spectacular failure of the process that has generated controversy from the very beginning.

One such error, some may argue, was that the allocated timelines for payment and for harvesting the quota were too short to enable international companies to participate in the auction.

Out of time

Ipumbu says the government did not have enough time to ensure that all necessary measures were put in place before the auction took place.

“This was mainly due to the fishing season for some species, such as hake, which is ending today, and we wished to have the quota exploited before the end of the season. It was therefore difficult to provide a longer payment period for bidders,” the minister said.

Another challenge, the minister pointed out, was that “most, if not all” bidders do not own vessels.

“It also appears as if many fishing industry existing players that own vessels stayed away from the auction while those that participated, their bid prices were far lower than the reserved price,” he said.

“New players that participated in the auction claimed that they faced a number of challenges such as non-availability of Namibian-registered fishing vessels, which was a condition of the auction. The position of the industry, through the Confederation of Namibian Fishing Associations, is that it is not in support of auctioning of the governmental objectives quota.”

Bidders complained about the limited time left for them to catch their allocated quotas and requested an extension of the fishing season, but there were legal impediments to this.

“In respect to the request from bidders to extend the fishing season, it should be noted that in terms of section 38(1) of the Marine Resources Act, Act 27 of 2000, the minister of fisheries and marine resources limits the total allowable catch (TAC) for a given period. After the fishing season period, there is a time period for spawning (reproduce). Therefore, the quota cannot be harvested outside the fishing season,” Shiimi clarified.

The minister said because of the disappointing turn of events, there remains unallocated quotas for different species. They are 10 900 tonnes of hake, 70 483 tonnes of horse mackerel and 92 tonnes of monk.

Way forward

Despite the hard lessons, Shiimi says fish quota auctions will be held in the future.

“The technical committee [tasked with this process] has been directed to plan future government objective fish quota auction(s) for the next season for hake and horse mackerel, starting in November 2020 and January 2021 respectively, taking into account lessons learnt from this auction.

“We have learned good lessons from this auction and that will be valuable going forward. In the future, punitive measures will be introduced, including requirements for payment guarantees or bid securities before participation in the auction.

“This will ensure that bidders meet their financial commitments and will mitigate the risk of speculative bids. In addition, more time will be given to bidders to arrange their finances.”

Similar News


NGO fears losses after quota allocation

1 week ago - 16 October 2020 | Fishing

OGONE TLHAGEWINDHOEKA Lüderitz-based community trust, Eshisha Development and Reconciliation Organisation, fears financial losses over a small fishing quota allocation after it participated in the recent...


2 weeks ago - 09 October 2020 | Fishing

OGONE TLHAGE WINDHOEKThe National Fishing Corporation (Fishcor) has applied to be considered in the allocation of fishing quotas, and wants its status...

Kawana slams fishing's 'John Walkers'

2 weeks ago - 08 October 2020 | Fishing

ERWIN LEUSCHNERSWAKOPMUNDFisheries minister Albert Kawana has accused actors in the fishing industry of having become millionaires and leading luxurious lifestyles while their workers live in...

Seaflower boss blasts Kawana

3 weeks ago - 07 October 2020 | Fishing

OGONE TLHAGE WINDHOEK Fisheries minister Albert Kawana has demanded evidence from fishing executives accusing him of favouring those close to him...

Search on for Fishcor acting CEO

3 weeks ago - 07 October 2020 | Fishing

OGONE TLHAGEWINDHOEKThe search is on for a new acting CEO at the National Fishing Corporation (Fishcor), after its former acting CEO David Ngalangi was removed...

‘Vetting’ delays fish quota allocation

3 weeks ago - 02 October 2020 | Fishing

OGONE TLHAGEWINDHOEKThe allocation of fish quotas to new rights holders is being held up by a verification process which tries to establish, among other things,...

Quota auction disaster

3 weeks ago - 01 October 2020 | Fishing

STAFF REPORTERWINDHOEKA series of schoolboy errors has led to a massive failure of the government’s recent fish quota auction, which netted the state a paltry...

Nghipunya's future at Fishcor under discussion

1 month - 16 September 2020 | Fishing

OGONE TLHAGEWINDHOEKThe future of suspended National Fishing Corporation of Namibia (Fishcor) CEO Mike Nghipunya is currently under discussion, board chairperson Mihe Gaomab II has informed...

Fishcor chair condemns Seaflower deals

1 month - 10 September 2020 | Fishing

OGONE TLHAGEWINDHOEKThe newly appointed board chairperson of the National Fishing Corporation of Namibia, Mihe Gaomab II, has condemned agreements entered into by the company's subsidiary,...

Floodgates open for quota 'middlemen'

1 month - 02 September 2020 | Fishing

OGONE TLHAGEWINDHOEKThe government has confirmed there is nothing holding back the winning bidders of its “governmental objectives” quotas from profiting by reselling the hake, horse...

Latest News

Education ministry to advertise 488...

4 hours ago | Education

The education ministry has, as part of their efforts of improving efficiency of use of resources, an internal audit was conducted to establish the magnitude...

Dead-end debt

16 hours ago | Economics

Jo-Maré Duddy – Government will spend about N$1.2 billion more in 2020/21 on interest on its debt than on its entire development budget for Namibia.The...

'Stuck without tap water since...

16 hours ago | Economics

A group of Helao Nafidi residents on Monday started excavating a traditional well to use as their source of water after the town council failed...

Emerging markets' debt tops US$4...

16 hours ago | Economics

US dollar-denominated debt in emerging markets has risen past US$4 trillion for the first time following a surge in issuance during the Covid-19 crisis, data...

'Calibre' of youth worries Swapo

16 hours ago | Politics

TUYEIMO HAIDULAOSHAKATI“We are ready to pass on the seats but when you see the calibre of young people we have and the utterances they make...

Old guard must go and...

16 hours ago | Politics

JEMIMA BEUKESWINDHOEKWalvis Bay Urban constituency councillor Knowledge Ipinge, who is vying to retain his seat in the upcoming local and regional authority elections, says it...

Pandemic slashes tourism by 70%

16 hours ago | Economics

Madrid - International tourists arrivals plunged by an annualised 70% during the first eight months of 2020 because of the coronavirus pandemic, the World Tourism...

China brainstorms new 5-year plan

16 hours ago | Economics

BEIJING - China's fifth Communist Party Plenum - which runs through Thursday behind closed doors – is expected to lay out the framework for the...

Namibians feel unsafe

16 hours ago | Crime

ELLANIE SMITWINDHOEKNamibians polled by an international organisation say they do not feel safe walking the streets, while Namibia has once again been ranked as one...

Load More