Man wins appeal against State

A man sentenced to 10 years in prison for an armed robbery in Oshakati has had his conviction overturned by the High Court.

30 September 2019 | Justice

A man who was facing 10 years in prison for a brazen robbery in Oshakati in 2007, and who spent three years in solitary confinement before his trial began last year, has successfully appealed against his conviction and sentence.

During the appeal judgment this month, High Court Judge Herman January, with the agreement of Judge Johanna Salionga, concluded that the State had failed to prove beyond reasonable doubt that Marius Romanus (36) had been involved in the robbery and that the magistrate's conviction and sentence should be set aside.

Last year Oshakati Magistrate Leopard Hangola handed down a 15-year prison sentence, of which five years were suspended, after finding Romanus guilty of the robbery.

January said the evidence on which the verdict was based was insufficient, primarily because the State relied on witnesses identifying the accused in court, in a method described as 'dock identification'.

Romanus's legal team argued that the dock identification of Romanus during the trial was of “such poor quality that no reasonable court could have convicted on it”.

Dock identifications have been described as unreliable, notably when used without additional evidence, because of the “inherent unfairness of the procedure”.

Witnesses tend to identify the accused “not because he is the person they saw committing the offence, but because he is the person sitting in the dock believed to have committed the offence,” a legal journal states.

January said on 19 September that other than the dock identifications, no identification parade was held prior to the trial, and none of the police investigators were asked to testify to “at least shed light on what grounds the accused was arrested”.

Further, none of the stolen items taken more than 11 years ago, including more than N$26 000, cellphones, a necklace and pistol, was ever recovered, and no fingerprints were lifted from the scene that linked Romanus to the crime.

The robbery that led to Romanus's arrest, and later re-arrest and three-year stint in solitary confinement, took place in June 2007 at Rochas Hotel in Oshakati.

The others involved in the robbery remain at large and unidentified. The robbers had entered Rochas restaurant in Oshakati, tied up a number of people at gunpoint and fled with a number of goods and cash.

Romanus was granted bail in July 2008, but never returned to court. Upon his re-arrest in 2015, he was transferred to Oluno Correctional Facility in Ondangwa, and placed in solitary confinement for three years.



Slim

He had denied guilt from the start, arguing that he was not in Oshakati but in Windhoek during the robbery.

In the notice of appeal, his lawyer, Marcia Amupolo, stressed that the magistrate had erred in his guilty conviction that the State had not proven its case beyond a reasonable doubt.

She argued that his prison sentence was “shocking and no reasonable court would have imposed it based on the facts in this case”.

January agreed in his judgment that the use of dock identification was unsafe in the circumstances.

He noted that while the first witness did not point the finger at Romanus, the second witness claimed he recognised him as one of the assailants, but admitted that at the time he had only glimpsed Romanus for 10 seconds before his head was covered with a plastic bag.

Judge January said the incident occurred in 2007, and the trial started in January 2018.

“He testified about nine years and seven months after the incident. He further testified that he is 'only seeing him today'.”

The witness was not able to tell the court what significant or distinctive features the witness relied on to identify the accused, the judge added. The third witness the State brought testified that he used to see Romanus socially in bars and clubs following the robbery, and was aware of gossip that implicated the accused.

The judge noted that “dock identification must be approached with caution”, and further, that single witness evidence must be approached with even greater caution in the cases of identification.

“In my view, that danger becomes even more pronounced where the identification of the alleged perpetrator is by means of a dock identification which had not been preceded by a proper identification parade.”

In his conclusion, the judge said the “State failed to prove that the accused is the robber beyond reasonable doubt”.

JANA-MARI SMITH

Similar News

 

Covid delays Möller murder trial

1 day - 22 September 2020 | Justice

ERWIN LEUSCHNERSWAKOPMUNDThe start of the murder trial of the five men accused of murdering Walvis Bay businessman Hans-Jörg Möller in 2016 has been delayed until...

Gertze's attempted murder case withdrawn

5 days ago - 18 September 2020 | Justice

OGONE TLHAGEWINDHOEKNamibia Qualifications Authority (NQA) CEO Franz Gertze is off the hook after the Office of the Prosecutor-General declined to prosecute him for a shooting...

Estate agent guilty of stealing Congolese general's money

1 week ago - 16 September 2020 | Justice

JANA-MARI SMITHWINDHOEKA Swakopmund estate agent accused of stealing US$900 000 (N$6.7 million) from a Democratic Republic of Congo military general ten years ago has been...

Fishrot 7 could be released

1 week ago - 15 September 2020 | Justice

OGONE TLHAGEWINDHOEKA magistrate yesterday thinly suggested the court might have no further reason to keep the Fishrot accused in custody if investigators do not wrap...

Masule ruling on 28 September

1 week ago - 11 September 2020 | Justice

JEMIMA BEUKES WINDHOEKGovernment attorneys yesterday argued that the High Court does not have the jurisdiction to hear the urgent application brought by Anti-Corruption Commission (ACC)...

'Strike Fishrot case from the court roll'

1 week ago - 11 September 2020 | Justice

OGONE TLHAGEWINDHOEK Trevor Brockerhoff, the lawyer representing former Investec manager Ricardo Gustavo, has asked the Windhoek Magistrate's Court to consider striking the Fishrot...

Bribery saga accused make renewed plea for freedom

1 week ago - 10 September 2020 | Justice

OGONE TLHAGE WINDHOEKLawyers representing the Fishrot accused have asked the Windhoek Magistrate’s Court to provisionally release their clients, as the State cannot...

Court grants husband bail after wife dies in 'scuffle'

1 week ago - 10 September 2020 | Justice

NAMPAGOBABISThe Gobabis Magistrate's Court on Monday granted bail of N$2 000 to Fritz Paul, who allegedly killed his wife during a scuffle at Farm Kroonster.Court...

Con man sues for N$5m

2 weeks ago - 08 September 2020 | Justice

JANA-MARI SMITHWINDHOEK A Hardap prison inmate and South African citizen convicted on multiple charges of fraud has filed a N$5 million lawsuit against...

Woman sues after AK-47 beating by soldier

2 weeks ago - 07 September 2020 | Justice

JANA-MARI SMITHWINDHOEKA new lawsuit brought by a civilian against the Namibian police and army centres around an alleged savage attack by a soldier who beat...

Latest News

The evil that men do

8 hours ago | Crime

JEMIMA BEUKESREHOBOTH The mother of two-week-old Charmaine Moss, who died after allegedly being raped by her father, has revealed shocking details about what had transpired...

Death of football further divides...

8 hours ago | Opinion

At the time when Namibians are angry at so many things – Covid-19, high unemployment rates and general levels of poverty – sport is the...

IPC dissident opens case against...

8 hours ago | Politics

JEMIMA BEUKES WINDHOEK Independent Patriots for Change (IPC) outcast Henry Ngenomesho has opened a case of assault by threat against party president Dr...

Antipsychotic drugs back in stock

8 hours ago | Health

TUYEIMO HAIDULA OSHAKATI After being out of stock for six months, the country has finally received antipsychotic and antidepressant medication....

Meatco works towards inclusivity

8 hours ago | Agriculture

STAFF REPORTERWINDHOEKMeatco hosted a stakeholder engagement meeting with mainly weekend farmers and members of the Namibia Emerging Commercial Farmers Union (NECFU) last week.These farmers are...

Meat industry players meet

8 hours ago | Agriculture

STAFF REPORTERWINDHOEKThe Meatco board last week paid a courtesy visit to the Meat Board of Namibia to discuss how to address crucial matters hampering the...

Breaking the stigma of dementia

8 hours ago | Health

ERWIN LEUSCHNERSWAKOPMUNDSwakopmund's Alzheimer Dementia Namibia (ADN) Centre is the only one of its kind in the country. Here around two dozen people are cared for...

Horrendous abortion

8 hours ago | Opinion

Modestus H We cannot live in the present without the past; we have to link them together. In the past, abortion was not as...

A seatbelt can save your...

8 hours ago | Opinion

FABIAN AMUKWELELEIn highly motorised countries, many deaths have been prevented by seatbelts. Yet, seatbelt compliance remains worryingly low in those countries, including Namibia, where vehicle...

Load More