Last throw of the dice

Independent candidate Panduleni Itula has given notice that he will approach the Supreme Court to challenge the outcome of the presidential election, but some analysts say they expected more evidence of poll manipulation in his 126-page affidavit with annexures.

13 December 2019 | Politics

JEMIMA BEUKES AND OGONE TLHAGE



Electoral Commission of Namibia (ECN) chief electoral officer Theo Mujoro is adamant that they will be able to produce a paper trail of results from the controversial electronic voting machines (EVMs) used in the 27 November general election, “when a competent court orders them to do so”.

He was responding to independent candidate Panduleni Itula giving notice that he will be approaching the Supreme Court to challenge the results of the presidential election.

Mujoro explained they were in consultation with government attorneys.

Analysts also weighed on Itula’s affidavit yesterday, with constitutional expert Nico Horn saying it was probably one of the best election cases in years, because the Supreme Court would not have to find that anybody cheated.

Horn said the court only needed to find that the result could not be reliably corroborated by anything in the EVMs.

Late last month the ECN announced that President Hage Geingob had been re-elected for a second term and had garnered 56.3% of the presidential vote, while Itula secured only 29.4%.

However, a week later on 5 December 2019, the ECN updated its results for the Windhoek Rural Constituency after confirming that 7 000 votes for Itula had mistakenly been allocated to United Democratic Front (UDF) presidential candidate Apius Auchab.

Itula’s lawyer Elize Angula last week asked the ECN for access to all electoral materials used in the presidential election, including the authenticated printout of voting results at all the polling stations, access to all EVM motherboards, memory cards and inspection reports for the voting machines, among other things.

The information was supposed to be provided by last Thursday, with Angula saying failure to do so by the ECN would result in Itula approaching the Supreme Court.

On Wednesday afternoon, Itula gave notice of his intention to approach the highest court in the land and included a 126-page affidavit and annexures outlining why the presidential election results should be nullified. He wants the court to order a rerun as soon as possible.

Itula is being supported in his court bid by Republican Party (RP) president Henk Mudge, Namibia Economic Freedom Fighters (NEEF) president Epafrans Mukwiilongo, All People’s Party (APP) President Ignatius Shixwameni and Rally for Democracy and Progress (RDP) president Mike Kavekotora, who appear as applicants.

There are 29 respondents cited, who will have to decide whether they will oppose the application.

Missing EVMs cited

Itula cites the recent revelation by the ECN that EVMs booked out for the Swapo Party Elders Council (SPEC) congress in 2017 had gone missing.

“Since July 2017 up to the presidential election in 2019 there thus existed ample opportunity for gaining intimate knowledge of the machines’ hardware and software.

“The risk of discovering means of tampering with the EVMs is real, as lawyers and politicians pointed out immediately when the news first broke in October 2019.

“They cautioned that the election could be rigged and the integrity of its outcome would become questionable.

“Yet, the self-same models of EVMs were used one month later during the 2019 elections. This without the safeguards parliament enacted, a verifiable paper trail,” said Itula in his affidavit.

Horn said Itula is correct to say that without a paper trail the entire election process becomes unmeasurable.

He added Mujoro had made a mistake during the elections when he said anyone could access a paper trail if so needed, which according to insiders does not seem to be the case.

“Now, Dr Itula says there is no way that anybody can tell him how he voted and how anybody can find out because there is no paper trail.

“And therefore there is no way that an appellant or an applicant can prove that there was no cheating, because it is only figures that you are dealing with. You cannot recount like in the olden days.

“And you cannot in any way sort of way measure the correctness of the results or how a specific person voted by going back to his vote.

“So his point is that no matter how good the rest of the machine is set up and what else it can do, the major thing needed for a second run at the counting is absent.

“There is no way that you can rerun the machine and get a different result or that you can rerun in such a way that it will show defaults or faults,” said Horn.

More evidence of manipulation

Political commentator Graham Hopwood said he was quite surprised that the court documents are focused on the issue of Section 97 of the Electoral Act, and whether it was legal for the clauses relating to the paper trail to be suspended.

“I was expecting some evidence of possible manipulation of results to be included. However, we will have to see how the case develops and if further evidence is introduced.

“Perhaps the complainants think the EVM issue has never been fully considered by a court, since technical and timing issues have been used in the past to dismiss cases,” Hopwood said.

Political analyst Ndumba Kamwanyah said it would be a tall order for Itula and the opposition to prove their case successfully.

He emphasised they needed concrete evidence to prove their case.

“However, that does not mean that the election was fair. It was free but not fair due to a lot of technical errors. I don't think the election was intentionally rigged, but yes the technical glitches are and should be a big concern,” he said.

[email protected]

Similar News

 

Last throw of the dice

2 days ago - 13 December 2019 | Politics

JEMIMA BEUKES AND OGONE TLHAGE Electoral Commission of Namibia (ECN) chief electoral officer Theo Mujoro is adamant that...

Rundu chaos engulfs Swapo again

2 days ago - 13 December 2019 | Politics

The same chaos that engulfed the Rundu town council office-bearers election late last year, which dragged on to earlier this year, is once again playing...

A house divided

3 days ago - 12 December 2019 | Politics

Swapo has entered the final weeks of 2019 in disarray, as factional battles characterise the election of mayors and other political office-bearers in local authorities...

By-elections galore in January

6 days ago - 09 December 2019 | Politics

Four by-elections are scheduled to take place on 15 January in constituencies vacated by councillors who resigned because of the enforcement of Article 47 of...

Article 47 bites back at ECN

1 week ago - 06 December 2019 | Politics

The Electoral Commission of Namibia (ECN) has approached attorney-general Albert Kawana for legal advice on how to deal with the situation arising from its enforcement...

Infighting over seats ensnares PDM

1 week ago - 05 December 2019 | Politics

The Popular Democratic Movement (PDM) is embroiled in a nasty battle over the 16 seats it won in the just-ended National Assembly election.Disgruntled party members...

ECN did not learn from its mistakes

1 week ago - 03 December 2019 | Politics

A political analyst has described the Electoral Commission of Namibia's handling of last week's national and presidential elections as appalling. The elections were marred...

LPM, RDP claim daylight robbery

1 week ago - 03 December 2019 | Politics

CATHERINE SASMAN The Landless People’s Movement (LPM) and Rally for Democracy and Progress (RDP) have both declared last...

Two-horse race

2 weeks ago - 29 November 2019 | Politics

With about 27% of presidential and National Assembly results revealed yesterday at constituency collation centres to our reporters in the field, a side-by-side tussle between...

Kavango remains loyal to Geingob

2 weeks ago - 29 November 2019 | Politics

Preliminary election results in constituencies in the two Kavango regions yesterday showed landslide victories for both President Hage Geingob and Swapo.However, this has led to...

Latest News

Rundu chaos engulfs Swapo again

2 days ago - 13 December 2019 | Politics

The same chaos that engulfed the Rundu town council office-bearers election late last year, which dragged on to earlier this year, is once again playing...

Intercape confirms terrifying bus robbery

2 days ago - 13 December 2019 | Crime

While confirming a terrifying incident in which Intercape passengers were robbed at gunpoint on their way to Harare, the bus company did not answer questions...

Action, not promises

2 days ago - 13 December 2019 | Opinion

Acting fisheries minister Albert Kawana's utterances on Wednesday in Walvis Bay, where he addressed the fishing industry, must have come as music to the ears...

Erastus gets CEO nod

2 days ago - 13 December 2019 | Business

Licky Erastus has been appointment as the new CEO of Mobile Telecommunications Limited (MTC). Erastus had served as the company's acting CEO since June...

Dam levels still critical

2 days ago - 13 December 2019 | Disasters

While several dams have received inflows following good rains over the majority of the country, forecasts indicate that most parts of Namibia can expect only...

N$100k fine for ivory possession

2 days ago - 13 December 2019 | Crime

A man has been sentenced to a fine of N$100 00 or four years in prison for illegal possession of four elephant tusks. Bangorogile Motsokwe...

Students accuse Schlettwein of 'sabotage'

2 days ago - 13 December 2019 | Education

The Students' Union of Namibia (SUN) has accused finance minister Calle Schlettwein of sabotage, saying he is yet to release monies to pay their tuition...

Hundreds of thousands food insecure

2 days ago - 13 December 2019 | Disasters

ELLANIE SMIT Namibia’s agricultural sector has been contracting for the past five years and rural households and small-scale farmers have been severely affected, with 700...

Rundu welcomes ACC probe

2 days ago - 13 December 2019 | Disasters

KENYA KAMBOWE Rundu mayor Isak Kandingu has responded to a letter circulating on social media which alleges that the Rundu town council illegally swapped land...

Load More