Landmark communal land rights victory

Same rights as freehold apply

27 November 2018 | Justice

A Zambezi woman has won a landmark Supreme Court appeal on the issue of communal land and her right to legal ownership and compensation under customary laws.

In his judgement, Supreme Court Deputy Chief Justice Petrus Damaseb pointed out the broad implications of his ruling when he addressed the fact that the government of Namibia, the third respondent cited alongside the Katima Mulilo town council and six others, “chose not to participate in the litigation although this case raises an important constitutional issue.”

He said their decision not to participate “is a matter for regret because the issues raised in the case have far wider ramifications than the litigants before court.”

Willem Odendaal of the Legal Assistance Centre, who represented appellant Agnes Kashela, said the judgement overruled a High Court ruling by giving people who live under customary law land rights the same rights as people living under common law.

Odendaal argued the case from a constitutional point of view, in that the constitution should apply equally to all in Namibia, whether a person lives on communal or commercial land, with regard to “just compensation as provided for in Article 16 in the Namibian constitution”.

Kashela approached the Supreme Court after the High Court ruled against her in a dispute that arose when the Katima Mulilo town council rented and later offered to sell portions of the communal land without compensation.

She argued she had rightfully inherited the land under customary laws.

Her father was allocated a portion of communal land by the Mafwe Traditional Authority in 1985.

After independence, all communal land in Namibia became the property of the state and in 1995 portions of the communal land was transferred to the Katima Mulilo town council.

At the time, Kashela's father was still alive and continued to live on the land until his death in 2001.

Kashela accused the town council of unlawfully taking portions of her land and unlawfully renting those to a business and four individuals.

She said the council had thus been “unlawfully enriched” at her expense.

In her second claim, she argued that the town council had unlawfully expropriated her land without just compensation at market value.

She asked the High Court to award her the rent received by the council, which amounted to N$720 000 over three years, plus the amount for which the land was offered for sale, totalling N$2.415 Million, as reasonable and just compensation.



Overruled

Damaseb set aside the High Court's ruling that Kashela was not entitled to be compensated for land which had been legally transferred as town land to the town council.

The land in question had ceased to be communal land, the High Court ruled, and Kashela had no claim to any communal land tenure rights.

Damaseb's judgment noted that the council's High Court plea was “silent on the allegations made in support of Kashela's second claim, which is predicated on the right to compensation”.

He further noted that the council had admitted that it had offered compensation to Kashela, but she had wanted more than their offer.

Further, that it was the council's policy to “compensate persons similarly situation as Ms Kashela”.

Damaseb noted that this should have “put the matter to bed and a judgment given in favour of Ms Kashela”.

He said Kashela had acquired a right of exclusive use and occupation of the land in dispute after her father's death under customary laws, and had thus acquired a right of exclusive use and occupation of the land even after its proclamation as town land.

He said this right is enforceable by the courts of law which must, in the case of a breach, tailor a remedy to meet the circumstances of the facts.

He ruled that the state had inherited, as successor-in-title to communal lands, “social obligations” and had to use land “for the public good”.

Damaseb added that the state had an obligation to “respect the interest held by affected communities in communal land, for most of whom it was, and remains, the only means of livelihood and survival”.

Damaseb set aside the High Court ruling and ordered that the parties meet within ten days of his order to generate a joint case management report on the future conduct of the case on the remaining issues, including fair compensation.

He did not rule on just compensation, which he said was a matter for the High Court, based on his judgement. The costs of the appeal were awarded to Kashela.

The matter was remitted to the High Court for Damaseb to designate a judge to preside over and finalise the matter, especially on compensation.

Similar News

 

Huang wins again

1 day - 19 July 2019 | Justice

Jinhao Investment CC, of which trade unionist Petrus Nevonga and former Swapo councillor Christian Itope are members, while Jack Huang's membership is still part of...

State sued for N$3.8 million

2 days ago - 18 July 2019 | Justice

A man who was cleared of murder and robbery charges after he had spent more than five years in jail awaiting the completion of his...

B1 City fraud accused loses lawyer

2 days ago - 18 July 2019 | Justice

Hafeni Nghinamwaami, one the three businesspeople implicated in the fraud and corruption case surrounding the B1 City property development project, is without legal representation after...

Mom begs for mercy

3 days ago - 17 July 2019 | Justice

A mother of three minor children is asking the High Court to reduce her four-year prison sentence, or fine her instead, after she pleaded guilty...

Meatco to sue feedlot trustees

4 days ago - 16 July 2019 | Justice

The matter in which Meatco is suing JP Jooste, the owner of Big J Feedlot at Gobabis, for millions in relation to missing cattle has...

Omuniilonga gwaUnam otaka pangulwa

4 days ago - 16 July 2019 | Justice

Oshipotha moka omundungiki moshiputudhilo shoUniversity of Namibia (Unam) a yaha nokweehameka aamwayinathanamati yaali sha ningilwa moRundu, omwedhi Desemba otashi ka pulakenwa muSepetemba.Nelson Antonio, 44,...

Magistrate career down the drain for N$5 500

5 days ago - 15 July 2019 | Justice

YANNA SMITHMelaney Theron has thrown her promising career as a magistrate down the drain for a mere N$5 500.Last Thursday, Judge Nate Ndauendapo found the...

Unam lecturer to be prosecuted

5 days ago - 15 July 2019 | Justice

The case of the University of Namibia (Unam) lecturer, who allegedly shot and wounded two brothers last December in Rundu has been remanded to September....

Same-sex marriages before full bench

5 days ago - 15 July 2019 | Justice

The fate of three Namibians who tied the knot with their same-sex partners in countries where gender is not a barrier to marriage, and who...

Kalenga a kanitha olugodhi luukwaniilwa

5 days ago - 15 July 2019 | Justice

Endopo lyaningwa kuKonisa Eino Kalenga oku pataneka euliko netulo koshipundi shuukwaniilwa lyaFillemon Shuumbwa Nangolo onga omukwaniilwa gwaNdonga pethimbo, ogamwe gomomatompelo kutya omolwashike Omupanguli Thomas Masuku...

Latest News

Making employees feel at home...

1 day - 19 July 2019 | Business

Jonell Malan Human resource management is essentially the management of human resources (HR). It is a function in organisations designed to maximise employee performance in...

Fascinated by consumers

1 day - 19 July 2019 | Business

Evany van Wyk Rozanne van der Merwe comes across as being the epitome of female empowerment and friendliness. And this is exactly who she is....

No dazzling half-year for Namdeb

1 day - 19 July 2019 | Business

Jo-Maré DuddyNamdeb Holdings recorded its worst first half-year since 2016, with diamond production for the six months ended 30 June plummeting by nearly 22% compared...

Vulnerable and alone

1 day - 19 July 2019 | Social Issues

After an initial projection in 2008 that there would be 250 000 orphans and vulnerable children under the age of 15 by 2021, President Hage...

Zero cattle on offer at...

1 day - 19 July 2019 | Agriculture

The Oshana Regional Livestock Marketing Cooperative suspects that livestock prices have dropped so low because of the drought that farmers are no longer willing to...

Hope rekindled at Linus Shashipapo

1 day - 19 July 2019 | Education

Hope has been finally been rekindled that Linus Shashipapo Secondary School, which is currently in a sorry state, will be renovated.This comes after a tender...

Resilient and strong

1 day - 19 July 2019 | Business

Mariselle StofbergWith her tenacious attitude, collaborative nature and desire to always learn and draw from other people’s knowledge and experience, Leorine Waggie is clearly on...

Being unapologetically you

1 day - 19 July 2019 | Banking

Mariselle Stofberg Adriano Visagie went from playing in the dusty streets of Katutura to becoming a powerhouse in the entertainment industry and has created...

The great unwind and calls...

1 day - 19 July 2019 | Economics

Lazarus Shigwedha - Balance sheet recessions are the toughest to manage when they occur simultaneously with distressed debt conditions in the wider economy. During balance...

Load More