‘Insurers are trying to escape Covid liability’

19 November 2020 | Business

An expansionist approach to the construction of insurance clauses is ... not an appropriate or principled solution. - John Lockey, Lawyer representing Arch

Kirstin Ridley and Carolyn Cohn - Insurers are trying to escape liability for pandemic-related business losses with counter-intuitive arguments that go against the essential purpose of insurance, Britain's markets watchdog told the UK Supreme Court on Tuesday.

A lawyer for the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA), which brought a test case against insurers on behalf of policyholders, said insurers had reached an "extraordinary conclusion" that business losses were largely uncovered during the coronavirus pandemic because of the widespread havoc it has caused.

"[Insurers] are saying: 'We insure perils but not ones that are going to cost us a huge amount of money. We never contemplated that'. Well, that isn't an answer," Colin Edelman, the FCA's lawyer, told the second day of a four-day appeal, watched by thousands of businesses brought to their knees during the pandemic.

Small businesses from holiday cottage firms to restaurants and night clubs had to shut down or restrict trading after government-ordered lockdowns and say they face ruin after insurers rejected claims for business interruption cover.

PLAYING WITH WORDS

The case revolves around whether 21 policy wordings, affecting potentially 700 types of policies, 60 insurers, 370 000 policyholders and billions of pounds in claims, should cover disruption caused by responses to the virus.

The wordings cover business interruption when insured premises cannot be accessed because of public authority restrictions, in the event of a notifiable disease within a specified radius and hybrid wordings.

Tuesday's hearing focused on how insurance law clauses, such as a so-called "but for" test, disease, composite peril, prevention of access and trends, should be applied in the case.

A lower court in September found largely in favour of the FCA and the Hiscox Action Group, a policyholder action group that represents hundreds of policyholders that has joined the lawsuit, when judges ruled some insurers were wrong to reject claims.

But the FCA, the action group and six insurers - Arch, Argenta, Hiscox, MS Amlin, RSA and QBE - are all challenging elements of the ruling they lost.

‘EXPANSIONIST APPROACH’

Insurers, which have said they are paying valid claims, argue that most disease or "prevention of access" clauses in insurance policies do not cover the pandemic and that any pay-outs should reflect the wider economic downturn caused by coronavirus.

"An expansionist approach to the construction of insurance clauses is ... not an appropriate or principled solution," John Lockey, a lawyer representing Arch, told the hearing.

Jonathan Gaisman, a lawyer for Hiscox, said prevention of access clauses were designed only for closure by a public authority in situations specific to a business premises, such as the presence of rats or mice, food poisoning or drainage problems, as well as certain diseases.

"Lockdown in the case of a worldwide pandemic is totally different," he said. – Nampa/Reuters

Similar News

 

COMPANY NEWS IN BRIEF

1 day - 27 November 2020 | Business

Exxon and Total in talks ExxonMobil and Total are in negotiations over their massive LNG projects in Mozambique, with each seeking to extract more gas...

Election campaigns boost business

2 days ago - 26 November 2020 | Business

Ndalimpinga Iita - At his business premises in the northern part of Namibia, entrepreneur John David handles various branded promotional items including T-shirts, caps and...

Construction takes plight to MPs

4 days ago - 24 November 2020 | Business

The Construction Industries Federation of Namibia (CIF) recently hosted a series of five business breakfast briefings for members of parliament (MPs). In total, 45 members...

Medical aid shows Covid symptoms

4 days ago - 24 November 2020 | Business

The average claims per medical aid fund beneficiary in Namibia in the first three months of this year was nearly 28% more than in the...

Oshikuku entrepreneur launches biogas production

4 days ago - 24 November 2020 | Business

Parliamentarian, Modestus Amutse launched the Thikamapo Biogas Farming, a small-scale renewable energy entrepreneurial project that aims at driving Namibia to self-reliance in energy production at...

Black Friday madness continues

4 days ago - 24 November 2020 | Business

Julienne van Rooyen - Black Friday is just a few days away, and this year we can probably predict that there will be stricter measures...

COMPANY NEWS IN BRIEF

4 days ago - 24 November 2020 | Business

Prosus' HY earnings surge 29%Technology investment company Prosus NV said yesterday core earnings for the six months ended Sept. 30 surged 29% to US$2.2 billion,...

Company news in brief

4 days ago - 24 November 2020 | Business

Prosus' HY earnings surge 29%Technology investment company Prosus NV said yesterday core earnings for the six months ended Sept. 30 surged 29% to US$2.2 billion,...

Half-a-billion SME loan scheme launched

5 days ago - 23 November 2020 | Business

PHILLEPUS UUSIKU – Government, in partnership with four participating commercial banking institutions and with the financial support of the Bank of Namibia (BoN), on Friday...

Namfisa silent on Covid-19 claims

5 days ago - 23 November 2020 | Business

Jo-Maré Duddy – The Namibia Financial Institutions Supervisory Authority (Namfisa) has for more than two months refused to provide any information on insurance claims of...

Latest News

Kenya's economic growth to rebound...

1 day - 27 November 2020 | Economics

Duncan MiririKenya's economic growth is expected to bounce back next year, the World Bank said on Wednesday, as it emerges from a projected decline in...

Man kills, buries his partner

1 day - 27 November 2020 | Crime

TUYEIMO HAIDULAOKATANAA 36-year-old man has been arrested in connection with a body discovered on Wednesday at Omayanga village in the Okatana Constituency, Oshana Region. The...

Swapo holds on by fingernails

1 day - 27 November 2020 | Politics

TOIVO NDJEBELAWINDHOEKSwapo continued from where it left off with its downward spiral in last year's election by having its hold onto key constituencies and local...

Iipinge taps out

1 day - 27 November 2020 | Politics

JEMIMA BEUKESWINDHOEKOutgoing Walvis Bay Urban constituency councillor Knowledge Iipinge, who has conceded to Independent Patriots for Change (IPC) candidate Florian Donatus Tegako, says his work...

Nigerians to slide into further...

1 day - 27 November 2020 | Economics

Camille Malplat and Louise Dewast More than 200 million Nigerians will slide further into poverty as the coronavirus pandemic has sent oil prices tumbling and...

Hit the ground running

1 day - 27 November 2020 | Opinion

At the time of penning this down yesterday, the tabulation of election results was still under way. It didn’t look like a good day at...

Auto Sueco gunning the future...

1 day - 27 November 2020 | Politics

OGONE TLHAGEwindhoekFrom its humble beginnings in 2004, Auto Sueco Namibia is now a reckoned force in the Extra heavy and heavy commercial vehicle market with...

Ivory Coast raises 1 billion...

1 day - 27 November 2020 | Economics

Ivory Coast's Eurobond sale this week, sub-Saharan Africa's first of the pandemic era, raised 1 billion euros (US$1.19 billion) and was five times oversubscribed, the...

Open defecation remains a problem

1 day - 27 November 2020 | Health

ELLANIE SMITWINDHOEKIt is estimated that 14% of Namibians living in urban areas practise open defecation, while 77% of people living in rural areas do the...

Load More