Foreign med students had shorter exam time

02 July 2019 | Education

Experts called to evaluate and compare the contested 2018 Health Professions Councils of Namibia (HPCNA) pre-internship exams for medical graduates from foreign medical schools to the exams local students take in their final year, have found the papers are similar but that University of Namibia (Unam) students are given more time to complete the test.

The team of experts was appointed to an independent examination evaluation panel tasked to report their findings to an appeals committee.

Apart from the time discrepancy, the experts highlighted that the papers are similar in structure and difficulty, but are not necessarily based on the Namibian context.

The appeals committee is set to decide on the grievances lodged by more than 100 graduates who qualified at foreign medical schools in Eastern Europe and Asia, most of whom failed to pass the six modules of the pre-internship evaluations in November last year.

Only two out of 207 of the graduates passed all six modules of the evaluation, health minister Dr Kalumbi Shangula told parliament in March, while 62 did not pass any module.

Dr Laimi Ashipala, a neutral expert appointed by mutual agreement by all parties, concludes in her report, seen by Namibian Sun that “the examinations are of the same quality with discrepancy in the time allocation”.

She noted that the time allocated for final-year Unam exams is longer than the time allocated for the HPCNA exams.

Dr Shonag Mackenzie, who was appointed for the appellants, concluded that the HPCNA candidates have “over an hour less than the Unam candidates to answer the same or equivalent questions”.

Mackenzie further concludes that “there being no known standardisation of the answers of the HPCNA papers, that the HPCNA November 2018 examination is not equivalent to the Unam final-year exams”.

Her review of the papers also questions the accuracy of the answers in some sections and she states “this is a serious cause for concern as if the candidates gave the correct answer; they would have been given no marks”.

Out of context

On the content of both papers, Ashipala cautions that “most of the questions of both examinations are not at a level of a graduate”.

She underlined the papers were mostly similar in content, structure and the same level of difficulty.

She added that the content of both papers is mostly of general medicine knowledge and “not common cases that graduates will encounter during practice”.

Ashipala notes that most of the questions are taken from the United States Medical Licensing Examination (USMLE) website, which helps to assess a physician's ability to apply knowledge, concepts and principles and demonstrate fundamental patient-centred skills that are important in health and disease.

She concludes that these questions constitute the “basis of safe and effective patient care in an American context and not necessarily in the Namibian context”.

A report submitted by Dr Rod Lichtman, an expert appointed to the panel by the respondents, notes that the two sets of papers are similar both in content and difficulty.

Lichtman adds that he regards many of the questions in the papers as “too difficult and also inappropriate for a final-year medical student planning to practice as a GP in Namibia”.

He concludes that “it appears the majority of questions are cut and paste questions that come off the internet and do not represent medical practice and clinical situations in Namibia”.

A ruling by the appeals committee is expected in late August.

Questions emailed to the HPCNA yesterday remained unanswered at the time of going to print.


Similar News


88 schoolgirls fall pregnant in Oshana

15 hours ago | Education

Eighty-eight learners, including two girls in Grade 7, fell pregnant in the Oshana Region during the first term of 2019. Oshana governor Elia Irimari...

Houses turned into ablution blocks

1 day - 16 July 2019 | Education

Three incomplete teacher's houses constructed at Kasivi Combined School in the Kavango West Region have been turned into ablution facilities for learners.When Namibian Sun visited...

Preparing pupils for emergencies

1 day - 16 July 2019 | Education

Ester Kamati The disaster risk management school quiz is an initiative driven by the City of Windhoek and was introduced with the aim of ensuring...

Russia digs deep to feed pupils

1 day - 16 July 2019 | Education

652 tonnes of wheat and 51 tonnes of cooking oil valued at N$1.5 million to the education ministry’s school feeding scheme.The handover ceremony took place...

Quality education jaded at 'uneconomical schools'

1 day - 16 July 2019 | Education

Most school-going children undertake their studies in a formal structure with access to the resources that enable their learning, including qualified teachers and adequate learning...

100 years of excellence

1 day - 16 July 2019 | Education

Justicia ShipenaOne hundred years ago, on 8 July 1919, St George’s Diocesan School opened its doors for the first time with three staff members and...

A whole new world

1 day - 16 July 2019 | Education

Jacobina Kalunduka I am studying towards a bachelor of accounting degree at the University of Stellenbosch. I started studying last year. I chose accounting...

Privaatskool Welwitschia spog met nuwe perseel

1 day - 16 July 2019 | Education

Michelline Nawatises Privaatskool Welwitschia het op 3 Julie amptelik die nuwe perseel van sy laerskool in Mozartstraat in die hoofstad ingewy. Die hoërskool is...

1 000 schoolgirls receive pads

6 days ago - 11 July 2019 | Education

A local organisation that produces washable and affordable sanitary pads distributed packs consisting of six pads each in varying sizes to 1 000 girls in...

Andjaba to act in Katrina's place

6 days ago - 10 July 2019 | Education

The Namibian Presidency, by way of its press secretary Alfredo Hengari, has announced that Martin Andjaba, currently minister of presidential affairs in the Presidency, has...

Latest News

Keeping up with the neighbours

15 hours ago | Economics

LuandaYou would need around US$2 535.97 in Windhoek to maintain the same standard of living that you can have with US$7 600 in Luanda, assuming...

88 schoolgirls fall pregnant in...

15 hours ago | Education

Eighty-eight learners, including two girls in Grade 7, fell pregnant in the Oshana Region during the first term of 2019. Oshana governor Elia Irimari...

Stop blaming Aawambo - Kapofi

15 hours ago | Government

Home affairs minister Frans Kapofi has cautioned against tribalism and pointed out that there is a growing perception that only the Aawambo are beneficiaries of...

Mom begs for mercy

15 hours ago | Justice

A mother of three minor children is asking the High Court to reduce her four-year prison sentence, or fine her instead, after she pleaded guilty...

Relevant IFRS themes: Anytime, anywhere

15 hours ago | Business

A good understanding of International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS) is crucial to the financial reporting process of IFRS reporters. Banks and Insurers in particular have...

Standard Bank faces strike vote

15 hours ago | Labour

ELVIRA HATTINGH Members of the Bank Workers Union of Namibia (Bawon) are to vote on whether to strike...

Let us tread carefully

15 hours ago | Opinion

When expectations are not met, citizens wronged in this regard should have channels, means and ways to air their grievances and have them addressed effectively.In...

Big banks target South Africa's...

15 hours ago | Business

Emma Rumney - South Africa's biggest banks are betting cut-price accounts, big mortgages and offers on everything from Adidas backpacks to Xboxes will help them...

Zim inflation almost doubles, stirring...

15 hours ago | Economics

MacDonald Dzirutwe and Karin Strohecker - Prices of cooking oil and other basics soared in Zimbabwe as inflation nearly doubled in June, piling pressure on...

Load More