Ex-lover sued over HIV infection, broken engagement
Marc Springer
WINDHOEK
In an unprecedented compensation claim, a woman has dragged her ex-lover to court, claiming he infected her with HIV/AIDS and allegedly breached his promise to marry her almost five years ago.
She now wants the court to award her damages of N$5.3 million.
In her particulars of claim, plaintiff ‘AH’ recounted that she and defendant ‘HG’ were in a romantic relationship between November 2016 and December 2017. During that period, she alleged, he wrongfully and unlawfully induced her to have sex with him without protection by misrepresenting to her that he was HIV negative, despite knowing he was infected with the virus.
She argued that HG either intended to infect her with HIV, engaged in sexual intercourse with her without disclosing his HIV status or failed to exercise a degree of care "normally expected from a reasonable person in a romantic relationship under the prevailing circumstances".
As a result, she also became infected and suffered damages deserving of compensation, she said.
Amongst these, she listed past and future medical expenses to the tune of N$155 000 as well as N$500 000 for pain and suffering allegedly endured as a result of her HIV diagnosis. Additionally, she claimed damages of N$1 million for a supposed violation of her constitutional right to dignity and for loss of amenities of life.
You promise, you pay
Furthermore, she asserted that HG on or about 14 December 2016 proposed to her, and she agreed to the marriage, which was set to take place on 17 December 2017 in Windhoek. She further claimed that during August 2017, he broke up with her to continue a relationship with another woman.
In terms of the marriage promise allegedly made to her, she pointed out that they agreed that she would resign from her job as a customer care consultant to pursue her studies in public relations.
AH maintained that she resigned on 28 February 2017, thereby forfeiting her monthly income of N$8 500 and suffering a loss of N$684 000 to date, which her former fiancé was liable to repay her, she said.
Meanwhile, as a result of HG’s alleged breach of contract, AH has also claimed for the “loss of financial benefits of marriage” amounting to N$3 million, and demanded repayment of "wasted expenses incurred in respect of bridesmaids’ dresses" to the value of N$6 000.
No way
In his plea, HG stated that the sex was always consensual, adding that they never discussed his HIV status. He said he wasn’t aware of his status during their relationship, but maintained that he never presented himself as HIV negative.
He further denied that he infected AH with HIV or that had the intention to do so.
With regards to their alleged engagement, HG said he never promised to marry AH and could, therefore, not have acted wrongfully by ending their relationship.
He added that he never expected his former lover to resign from her job and can thus not be held liable for her loss of income.
He is adamant that the monetary claim for breach of promise of marriage is not actionable and, therefore, not enforceable based on the Namibian Constitution and should be dismissed.
The matter, heard by Judge Hannelie Prinsloo, was postponed yesterday to 29 July for a further status hearing. Mbushandje Ntinda from Sisa Namandje & Co is acting on behalf of AH, while Norman Tjombe is representing HG.
WINDHOEK
In an unprecedented compensation claim, a woman has dragged her ex-lover to court, claiming he infected her with HIV/AIDS and allegedly breached his promise to marry her almost five years ago.
She now wants the court to award her damages of N$5.3 million.
In her particulars of claim, plaintiff ‘AH’ recounted that she and defendant ‘HG’ were in a romantic relationship between November 2016 and December 2017. During that period, she alleged, he wrongfully and unlawfully induced her to have sex with him without protection by misrepresenting to her that he was HIV negative, despite knowing he was infected with the virus.
She argued that HG either intended to infect her with HIV, engaged in sexual intercourse with her without disclosing his HIV status or failed to exercise a degree of care "normally expected from a reasonable person in a romantic relationship under the prevailing circumstances".
As a result, she also became infected and suffered damages deserving of compensation, she said.
Amongst these, she listed past and future medical expenses to the tune of N$155 000 as well as N$500 000 for pain and suffering allegedly endured as a result of her HIV diagnosis. Additionally, she claimed damages of N$1 million for a supposed violation of her constitutional right to dignity and for loss of amenities of life.
You promise, you pay
Furthermore, she asserted that HG on or about 14 December 2016 proposed to her, and she agreed to the marriage, which was set to take place on 17 December 2017 in Windhoek. She further claimed that during August 2017, he broke up with her to continue a relationship with another woman.
In terms of the marriage promise allegedly made to her, she pointed out that they agreed that she would resign from her job as a customer care consultant to pursue her studies in public relations.
AH maintained that she resigned on 28 February 2017, thereby forfeiting her monthly income of N$8 500 and suffering a loss of N$684 000 to date, which her former fiancé was liable to repay her, she said.
Meanwhile, as a result of HG’s alleged breach of contract, AH has also claimed for the “loss of financial benefits of marriage” amounting to N$3 million, and demanded repayment of "wasted expenses incurred in respect of bridesmaids’ dresses" to the value of N$6 000.
No way
In his plea, HG stated that the sex was always consensual, adding that they never discussed his HIV status. He said he wasn’t aware of his status during their relationship, but maintained that he never presented himself as HIV negative.
He further denied that he infected AH with HIV or that had the intention to do so.
With regards to their alleged engagement, HG said he never promised to marry AH and could, therefore, not have acted wrongfully by ending their relationship.
He added that he never expected his former lover to resign from her job and can thus not be held liable for her loss of income.
He is adamant that the monetary claim for breach of promise of marriage is not actionable and, therefore, not enforceable based on the Namibian Constitution and should be dismissed.
The matter, heard by Judge Hannelie Prinsloo, was postponed yesterday to 29 July for a further status hearing. Mbushandje Ntinda from Sisa Namandje & Co is acting on behalf of AH, while Norman Tjombe is representing HG.



Comments
Namibian Sun
No comments have been left on this article