Dippenaar crash survivor grilled

Witness accused of fabricating story

17 July 2017 | Crime

The evidence in chief delivered in the Swakopmund Regional Court last week by the survivor of an accident, which claimed the lives of six people, came under heavy fire on Thursday during the defence's cross-examination.

Advocate Louis Botes, who is representing the accused, Jandré Dippenaar, questioned the witness, Antonia (Toni) Klara Joschko repeatedly about her version of the events, which transpired on 29 December 2014, the day of the accident.

Joschko testified last week Wednesday that she was traveling with her father, Walter Helmut (48), mother, Stephanie Dorothea Schemick (49), and her older sister Alexandra (19), to Swakopmund from Cape Cross when the accident occurred.

“On our way to Swakopmund, I was speaking to my sister who was sitting on the back passenger seat with me. I was sitting behind my father who was driving and my mother was sitting in the front passenger seat. As we were driving up a small hill a big white vehicle suddenly appeared right in front of our car,” she said.

Her father, she told the court, had no time to react to avoid a collision as the accused's vehicle was too close and was travelling at a very high speed.

When questioned about discrepancies between her testimony, her statement to the police and other evidence before the court relating to which side of the road they were traveling on, Joschko said she was sure her father was driving in the correct lane.

“It was important for me to make that clear from the start, because I knew it would have been easy for people to blame my father for the accident because we are from Germany where we drive on the other side of the road,” she said.

Botes further questioned the witness about her testimony that she did not see the approaching vehicle of the accused until it was right in front of their vehicle.

“I put it to you that the reason you did not see the vehicle is because you were not looking at the road and if this horrific accident occurred on a hill the investigating officer would have mentioned it in his report,” Botes insisted.

He also submitted photographs to the court depicting the accident scene.

“These photographs indicate that there is no hill in the vicinity of the accident scene,” he said.

Joschko responded by saying that the photographs only show one perspective of the road and that she was sure that the hill would be visible on other photographs.

Botes, however, stated that her evidence does not correspond at all to what happened.

“I am sure that an expert must explain the marks not me, and every witness will have his own perspective and yesterday and today I explained mine,” she answered.

In his closing statement, Botes further lambasted the 19-year-old's evidence, claiming it was not adding up to other statements.

“Having regard to the real evidence we will argue that you are fabricating your story for two reasons. One, you want to exonerate your father for his wrongdoings. Two, you did not fully observe what happened that day. Or perhaps it is for a little bit of both these reasons,” he said.

It is alleged that the accused, Jandré Dippenaar, was in the process of overtaking another vehicle when he smashed into the Joschko's oncoming vehicle.

The vehicle which Dippenaar was driving burst into flames while the passengers were still trapped in the vehicle.

The other victims and the accused's passengers, were Dinah Pretorius (30), Charlene Schoombe (24) and J C Horn (27).

Dippenaar faces six charges of murder, reckless and negligent driving, fraud and non-possession of a valid driver's licence.

After Botes concluded his cross-examination and magistrate Gaynor Poulton postponed the case to 21 November for continuation of trial.


Similar News


Residents demand fair trial for killer cop

1 day - 18 April 2018 | Crime

Tsumeb residents held an emotional demonstration in front of the town's police office to demand that Chief Inspector Bernhard Nghuulivali, who is accused of having...

Man dies in shack fire

2 days ago - 17 April 2018 | Crime

A man burned to death in a fire which destroyed four shacks and a storeroom in Swakopmund’s Mondesa residential area on Sunday.Erongo police commissioner Erastus...

Stripped naked over missing key

3 days ago - 16 April 2018 | Crime

The prosecutor-general will decide whether to prosecute the bodyguard of former president Sam Nujoma, Nepando Amupanda, and six police officers from the Ondangwa police station,...

Rogue doctor driver gets bail

6 days ago - 13 April 2018 | Crime

The now notorious Otjiwarongo-based Zimbabwean doctor Yevai Chiradza, was granted N$12 000 bail at the Karibib Magistrate's Court this morning.He has been in holding since...

Murder and mayhem

1 week ago - 11 April 2018 | Crime

The violent death rate in Namibia is one of the highest in the world and in proportion to that of high-intensity conflict zones.At a rate...

Doctor in the dock for rape

1 week ago - 06 April 2018 | Crime

A 40-year-old doctor working at the Oshakati hospital, who was arrested on a charge of rape, appeared yesterday in the local magistrate's court. The...

No mercy for Chinese tax evaders

1 week ago - 06 April 2018 | Crime

Increasingly common cases of tax evasion and money laundering by Chinese nationals in Namibia were discussed during President Hage Geingob's weeklong state visit to China....

Violent Easter weekend

2 weeks ago - 04 April 2018 | Crime

The country experienced a violent Easter weekend that was marred by murders, gang fights, rapes and incidents of domestic violence. On Sunday a...

Namibian arrested for Zambian murder

3 weeks ago - 27 March 2018 | Crime

While details remain sketchy, reports have emerged that a Namibian truck driver, 38 years old, was arrested in Zambia on Sunday evening in connection with...

Bank deposit fraudsters on the run

3 weeks ago - 27 March 2018 | Crime

The Oshana police are hunting for two suspects who defrauded a shop in Ondangwa of items worth N$18 000, by using a bank deposit slip...

Latest News

Johannes promoted following gold

18 hours ago | Sports

Gold medallist Helalia Johannes has been promoted to the rank of Warrant Officer Class Two with immediate effect, after she won Namibia’s second gold medal...

Etosha debacle sparks national probe

18 hours ago | Environment

The environment ministry has launched a full-scale investigation at the Deeds Office in Windhoek to determine whether there is any privately owned land in Namibia's...

Acute teacher shortage

18 hours ago | Economics

The education ministry has appealed for leniency and recognition that despite the directive to reduce state wage bills the ministry is in dire need of...

Africa briefs

18 hours ago | Economics

SA's auditor general cancels all contracts with KPMGSouth Africa’s Auditor General said on Tuesday he is terminating all contracts with auditing firm KPMG over a...

NovaNam, Lalandii start new hake...

18 hours ago | Business

Staff reporter - Last week, Lüderitz-based hake fishing companies, NovaNam and Lalandii, commenced with the cutting of the steel to build the...

Ondonga heir apparent hits back...

18 hours ago | Cultural

One of the claimants to the Ondonga throne, Fillemon Shuumbwa Nangolo, has taken issue with urban and rural development minister Peya Mushelenga following his recent...

PM warns employees of shorter...

18 hours ago | Government

Prime Minister Saara Kuugongelwa-Amadhila this week warned staff members of her office that she would not accept complacency and that she would shorten the leash...

40 years after battle of...

18 hours ago | History

The Angolan president, João Lourenço will attend the Cassinga Day commemoration on 4 May as guest of honour and will lay a wreath at Heroes'...

New conservancy land disputed

18 hours ago | Environment

A Kavango West man has accused the Uukwangali Traditional Authority of stealing his land, which he claimed was now allocated to a newly proclaimed conservancy....

Load More