Corruption - A social disease (Part 168): Policy making procedures must be reviewed

17 November 2020 | Columns

Johan Coetzee - What may the deterioration of the public service morale and competency levels, an increase in political interference and an increase in corruption have in common?

There can be quite a few commonalities. Decision making (governance) for policy implementation is one.

A deterioration in public policy implementation is taking place contrary to international trends such as the knowledge-based economy, e-governance, value added governance, network governance and sustainable governance as reflected in the Sustainable Development Goals of the United Nations (UN).

A review of the policy making process is required.

AN INTEDEPENDEND AND INTERRELATED SYSTEMS

Policy is a process that is part of a larger system that can be found in philosophy as well as processes and practices as reflected in portfolios, programmes and projects.

Public policy making and implementation are processes of a value chain that requires cross checks and balances between all six phases (but not limited to) identification, agenda setting, formulation, adoption, implementation and monitoring, and evaluation/assessment. Currently there is limited commitment to measure indicators for improved implementation.

Although indicators can be improved at all levels, some contributors to limited implementation are vested in the implementation or rather non and limited implementation and repetitive policy and project implementation oversights.

Over the years Namibians have observed excellent plans such as Harambee. However, the momentum to monitor ongoing implementation of plans and institutionalising it into policies and workable programmes and projects to rectify shortcomings are evident in a graveyard of unachievable outputs and outcomes.

Covid-19 and resulting inconsistent implementation is still fresh in the memories of Namibians. The recent opening and closing of boarders is a prime example of such incoherence.

LEGISLATION AS ENABLER

An increase is observed in legislation that is vague, open for discretion, an administrative nightmare to implement and challengeable in court, for example changes to the Marine Resources Act that legalized the corruption of Fishrot.

The National Equitable Economic Empowerment Framework (NEEEF) and Bill (NEEEB) and the implementation thereof will not contribute to successful policy implementation, because the bill in its current form is unsustainable and an administrative nightmare.

A lot of legislation are outdated and originated from the Apartheid era. Such legislation needs to be scrapped and/or revised, like the Terrorism Act.

Successful policy formulation and implementation starts with sound and legitimate legislation that represents the will of the people, not the will of a government that wants to score political points. People resist such legislation and policies and its implementation.

The Procurement Act is an example of legislation that probably created more uncertainty and loopholes.

ACCOUNTABILITY AND POLICY MONOPOLIES

To improve policy making and implementation, accountability should be increased. Delegation should be used to make that possible.

Policy making is a system and systems engineering can be used to improve it.

The current system of policy making has almost no ability to rectify itself because public servants seems to shy away from accepting accountability (maybe because they are just following instructions, political interference and protecting their jobs), are not reprimanded for no or partial implementation and those in control of the policy making process (senior public office bearers), also protect their positions and they are protected by the politicians that appoint them and to whom they report.

Adequate checks and balances are not in place to rectify policy failures. Monopolies in policy implementation should be minimized to provide more checks and balances for improved implementation. Such monopolies prevent self-correction and/or rectification.

RETHINKING THE ROLE OF GOVERNMENT

The approach that government should be the main driver of policy formulation and implementation should be aligned with international trends of value-added governance and network governance where government is just one player in the policy making process.

Government is supposed to only facilitate the social dialogue for enabling all stakeholders to participate. Government is not supposed to drive the process of policy formulation. This should be done by the public in the form of active interest groups and making use of social media platforms.

Interest groups and advocacy groups are not adequately involved and not respected by Government for their input. The absence of senior public officials attending interest group presentations is evident and demonstrated over decades the inability of Government to facilitate policy formulation based on ongoing social dialogue for continues improvement of public policy based on research, international trends and best practices. Interest groups tend not to receive feedback regarding policy formulation.

Government rather entertains a short process of public consultation before implementation. The process is also too centralized and driven by Government instead of being tested and verified based on public demand.

For example, NEEEB seems not be driven by the public, but rather by political opportunism.

A new culture of democratic policy formulation should be facilitated.

[email protected]

Similar News

 

How we welcome new employees

1 week ago - 19 February 2021 | Columns

Alphons Within the workplace, induction refers to the process of getting new employees acquainted with your business, helping them to settle in and giving them...

Top 10 HR trends to help shape your 2021...

1 month - 29 January 2021 | Columns

BAILI BIGHAMLast year will go down as one of the most infamous years of our lifetime. But we know that where there are challenges, there...

The true test of leadership: how to lead during...

1 month - 22 January 2021 | Columns

Anthony Mitchell Leadership is challenging at the best of times, but how you lead during an environment of complexity and ambiguity is the real test...

Repeating outfits is not a crime

1 month - 12 January 2021 | Columns

Enzo AmueleThe fear of repeating an outfit is shared across the globe. Societal norms have created this idea that you are not allowed to wear...

HR trends you need to know

2 months ago - 04 December 2020 | Columns

Ann SnookAs technology advances and best practices change, so does the face of human resources. If you want to work efficiently while recruiting strong candidates...

Human trafficking in Namibia

3 months ago - 18 November 2020 | Columns

Martha N.T. HasheelaNews headlines in recent months have shown that people are going missing at the speed of light. Our country is no longer safe,...

Making the lives of the Namibian youth better

3 months ago - 17 November 2020 | Columns

Monique AdamsThe statement “never forget where you come from” is something Robert Haihambo frequently reminds himself of.‘Do it for the Kids Namibia’ is a voluntary...

Expanding your territory

3 months ago - 17 November 2020 | Columns

Elizabeth Joseph The expansion of my territory is a term I’m very well acquainted with. And the last few months have been a complete test...

Corruption - A social disease (Part 168): Policy making...

3 months ago - 17 November 2020 | Columns

Johan Coetzee - What may the deterioration of the public service morale and competency levels, an increase in political interference and an increase in corruption...

A call for economic revival by all stakeholders

3 months ago - 06 November 2020 | Columns

LIBOLLY L. HAUFIKU The private sector in Namibia is in dire straits. The most recent report by the Namibia Statistics Agency (NSA), dated 11...

Latest News

Capricorn: Covid consumes millions in...

2 days ago - 26 February 2021 | Business

Jo-Maré Duddy – An increase of more than N$100 million in impairment charges and a N$41-million loss suffered by Cavmont Bank in Zambia shrunk Capricorn...

No gem of a year...

2 days ago - 26 February 2021 | Business

Jo-Maré Duddy – Covid-19’s “profound impact on global diamond supply and demand” left Nemdeb Holdings with an underlying EBITDA of US$113 million for the 12...

Govt silently files for liquidation

2 days ago - 26 February 2021 | Transport

OGONE TLHAGEWINDHOEKGovernment on Monday silently filed for the liquidation of beleaguered national airline Air Namibia despite a massive public outcry over the matter.Documents seen by...

Darkness falls on government buildings

2 days ago - 26 February 2021 | Government

MATHIAS HAUFIKUWINDHOEKAffected ministries:· Safety and security: N$34m· Defence: N$5.2m· Agriculture: N$3.8m· ...

All systems go for three-horse...

2 days ago - 26 February 2021 | Politics

OGONE TLHAGEWINDHOEKSwapo, the Landless People’s Movement (LPM) and Popular Democratic Movement (PDM) are all bullish ahead of regional and local authority election reruns slated for...

He is moulded by the...

2 days ago - 26 February 2021 | People

Michelline NawatisesLeslie Kaxwadi is a computer science graduate from the Namibia University of Science and Technology. He graduated in 2017. As a part of his...

Driven by quality service

2 days ago - 26 February 2021 | People

Tunohole Mungoba – OngwedivaBarnabas Shilongo established Shilongo Gravestones and Funeral Services in 2017, but only officially registered his business in 2019.“Shilongo Gravestones and Funeral Services...

South Africa boosts vaccine spending...

2 days ago - 26 February 2021 | Economics

Olivia Kumwenda-Mtambo and Mfuneko ToyanaSouth Africa could spend up to R 19.3 billion (US$1.33 billion) over the next three years to vaccinate most of its...

Swapo can’t be left alone,...

2 days ago - 26 February 2021 | Opinion

President Hage Geingob’s assertion that people shouldn’t worry about Swapo’s problems cannot be left unchallenged.The president’s remarks seem to be rooted in misconception that those...

Load More