Corruption - A social disease (Part 167 b): Can Namibia be the least corrupt African country by 2020?

27 February 2020 | Columns

Johan Coetzee - Why are Namibians’ perceptions about corruption not improving?

Despite mechanisms such as the Anti-Corruption Commission (ACC) which has investigated corruption since 2006, the Financial Intelligence Centre (FIC) and Bank of Namibia (BoN) which monitor suspicious fund transfers (money laundering), the Prosecutor General (PG) and the Ombudsman, whom can investigate cases where the public’s rights are at stake, Namibia has not improved its international corruption rating since 1998.

These public rights include among others the right to fair treatment and access to public services.

The Whistleblower Protection Act, 2017 has not been implemented yet.

TENDER INFLATION

Contributors to non-improvement can be an increase in corruption from pre-tender to post-tender.

Examples include deliberate incorrect tender specifications, middlemen that charge facilitation fees, collusion between parties as well as tender fixing. Post-tender inflation was seen with the construction of the Neckartal dam and the petroleum depot at Walvis Bay, which will be completed years after the initial tender completion date and in both cases with an approximately inflation of 700%.

State Owned Enterprises’ (SOEs) debt is approximately N$45 billion based on 2019 figures.

An increase in the mismanagement of funds and incompetence by local authorities also contribute to perceptions about corruption.

EXECUTIVE POWERS

Another possible contributor is an increase in presidential powers since 1990. Amendments of the Constitution allow the President to appoint regional governors, the National Assembly was enlarged from 76 to 104 members (eight appointed by the President) and the National Council from 26 to 42 members.

Namibia has an all too powerful presidential position, even more powerful than the United States of America. The President appoints the Chief of Police, Defence Force and National Intelligence, the Ombudsman, Prosecutor General, Attorney General, Director General of the National Planning Commission, the Director General of the Anti-Corruption Commission and the Employment Equity Commissioner, to mention a few. Such powers can result in undue influence in terms of the seperation of executive, legislative and judicial powers.

An unchecked an all too powerful position is open for abuse because the system allows it. Namibia has a structurally inefficient and weak system of checking the powers of the President.

The executive have an increased dominance over the legislative branch of Government.

All cabinet members are appointed at the sole discretion of the President and constitute more than a third of the National Assembly. Cabinet members are firstly accountable to the president, secondly to the Politburo (100 members) of the ruling party and thirdly to the National Assembly - and in effect indirectly and lastly to the voters.

All MPs represent all voters and no one in particular. Such a political representation system is structurally inefficient because of a lack of direct political accountability to voters. The unclear and compromised lines of accountability is embedded in the quota system for electing members of the National Assembly. Voters vote for a party and not for individual politicians.

MIGHTY MINISTERS

Ministers have been granted increased discretionary powers through several pieces of legislation. For example, legislation pertaining to the allocation of fishing quotas, environmental clearance certificates, mining licences and imposing conditions on investors.

The Investment Promotion Act has been under review since 2016. Insecurity reigns in the investment climate.

The amendment of the Pension Funds Act, Article 28 (special purpose vehicle) mandated the Government Institutions Pension Fund (GIPF) to invest in unlisted funds (Brownfield projects) that include high risk start-up companies that do not have a sound operational track record. This is expected to contribute to a further reduction of internal and external investment confidence and outflow of capital.

The GIPF corruption scandal took place prior to the amendment of Article 28. Of the 20 cases of GIPF corruption that involved politicians, businessmen and allegedly also a judge, 18 could not be prosecuted due to lack of evidence and no court hearings has taken place.

The discretionary powers of ministers are not conducive to reduce corruption, because power has, can, and will continue to be abused. The practise of high-risk investments due to Article 28 may continue unabatedly and remain unchallenged by private equity companies.

ELECTIONS

It can be deduced that there is tolerance for corruption in Namibia that has become part of the culture of engrained corruption that has “infected” law-enforcement agencies, the private sector (Coetzee) and public institutions.

The Electoral Commission (ECN) and the former Minister of Urban and Rural Development failed to implement sections of the Electoral Act, which were ruled unconstitutional by the Supreme Court on 6 February 2019. The Supreme Court however ruled that the elections of 2019 is binding and legal. It raises several questions as to the independence of judges, whom are appointed by the President on recommendation of the Judicial Service Commission. How the outcome of an unconstitutional application of the Electoral Act can be acknowledged by the Court as legal, is unknown.

The so-called “jury” is still out on how the international community will respond to this ruling. The investment community’s response may be more negative than positive.

REFERENCES

Coetzee, J.J. (2018). The role of the private sector in tackling corruption. Institute for Public Policy Research, Briefing Paper, 9 May, Windhoek. Available at: https://ippr.org.na.

[email protected]

Similar News

 

Virus detected, disruption activated

4 days ago - 27 March 2020 | Columns

Chaze NalisaThere was a time, literally a couple of weeks ago, when someone sneezed and the reaction of those around them would be a simple,...

The building blocks of an empire

1 week ago - 24 March 2020 | Columns

Justicia Shipena Imagine a world where every day you have to worry about the threat of a second alien invasion. Military officials plug a...

Corona virus: our reality

2 weeks ago - 17 March 2020 | Columns

Octavia TsibesCovid-19, also known as the coronavirus, ladies and gentlemen. To be honest with you, when news broke out that Covid-19 has landed on Namibian...

Let’s raise debate levels

2 weeks ago - 13 March 2020 | Columns

With a new parliament set to be sworn in soon, there is a sense of something new brewing in terms of vigorous and forthright debates...

Service, please!

3 weeks ago - 10 March 2020 | Columns

Ester Kamati Many of us are at that age where we need to transition from a “mommy’s girl” or “mommy’s boy” who can always count...

Corruption - A social disease (Part 167 d): Can...

3 weeks ago - 06 March 2020 | Columns

Johan Coetzee - The reluctance of the executive to get rid of the rotten and invested wood in their ranks is an indication that the...

Corruption - A social disease (Part 167 c): Can...

3 weeks ago - 05 March 2020 | Columns

Johan Coetzee - Justice delayed is justice denied.The Teckla trio case, in which a former Public Service Commissioner and her two Chinese business associates were...

More than cosmetics

4 weeks ago - 03 March 2020 | Columns

Everywhere across the country in households, belts are being tightened. Whether that home is a five-bedroom villa in the hills of the capital, or a...

The quiet hours

4 weeks ago - 03 March 2020 | Columns

Elizabeth Joseph I love those hours when it’s just you and your thoughts. It used to be the morning hours between 04:00 and 05:00. Now...

Is Geingob overly scrutinised?

4 weeks ago - 02 March 2020 | Columns

President Hage Geingob's visit to Omukwaniilwa of Ondonga, Fillemon Shuumbwa Nangolo, on Saturday sparked another wave of criticism against the head of state. Antagonists of...

Latest News

Budget delayed 'until further notice'

4 hours ago | Economics

New finance minister Iipumbu Shiimi has announced that the tabling of the 2020/21 budget will be “delayed until further notice”.Shiimi issued a statement saying the...

Skorpion, MUN at loggerheads

13 hours ago | Business

Jo-Maré Duddy – The Mineworkers Union of Namibia (MUN) yesterday called for the urgent intervention of president Hage Geingob after Skorpion Zinc Mine and Refinery...

Coronavirus: Aochamub could be discharged...

13 hours ago | Disasters

TOIVO NDJEBELAWINDHOEKNamibian ambassador to France Albertus Aochamub says he has made a good recovery from coronavirus and may be discharged from hospital this week, having...

Budget faces downward revision

13 hours ago | Economics

OGONE TLHAGEWINDHOEKHeavy knock expected on· VAT· Company tax· PAYE· ...

‘Conflicted’ Muinjangue removed from genocide...

13 hours ago | Cultural

JEMIMA BEUKESWINDHOEKThe Ovaherero Traditional Authority (OTA) has recalled Ester Muinjangue as the chairperson of the Ovaherero Genocide Foundation (OGF), following her appointment as deputy health...

Booze sellers in trouble for...

13 hours ago | Business

ILENI NANDJATOPolice in the north have arrested five people who refused to close their informal busi­nesses. One of them is a teacher who owns a...

Church bell stolen

13 hours ago | Disasters

ELLANIE SMIT WINDHOEKThieves paid little attention to the teachings of the Bible when they stole a church bell valued at N$100 000 this past weekend....

Needed: Stimulus packages

13 hours ago | Opinion

Many countries hit by the coronavirus scourge have hammered out ways in which to keep their economies afloat, especially after the stay-home directive is over...

Local banks drop digital fees

13 hours ago | Banking

Both FNB Namibia and Standard Bank Namibia this weekend lowered fees on their digital platforms to encourage the public to stay at home during the...

Load More