Chicken import war

In its papers the Meat Board says the applicant “has little interest in supporting the local poultry industry and that it insists upon allocation of a quota well in excess of what it is entitled to”.

10 September 2019 | Justice

A South African citizen, and owner of African Meals Catering at Otjiwarongo, is suing the Meat Board and the ministers of industrialisation and agriculture in a bid to import an extra 95 tonnes of frozen chicken monthly.

In his particulars, signed on 24 May this year, Sarel Oberholzer asks the court to review, correct or set aside the decision by the Meat Board to allow him to import only 5.963, 5.608 and 5.194 tonnes of chicken for the months of April to June this year.

Oberholzer's company supplies frozen chicken to the Namibian Defence Force and school hostels across Namibia.

“In order to meet its needs in respect of frozen chicken, [African Meals Catering] requires no less than 100 tonnes monthly. Given that insufficient frozen chicken is produced in Namibia, [African Meals Catering] is constrained to import its monthly chicken requirements from South Africa,” Oberholzer's court documents state.





'Premium' price of N$10

He told the court that other importers “such as Deep Catch are permitted to import more than 20 times as much” and that he is then forced to buy this chicken “at a premium of at least N$10 a kilogram,” which he says costs him N$600 000 a month.

He attached a letter from his lawyer, Mark Kutzner of Engling, Stritter & Partners, to the Meat Board, dated 18 September last year, to this effect.

In its response on 27 September 2018, the Meat Board said it had approved imports of 6.966 and 8.649 tonnes for September and October last year.

Oberholzer says he buys 25 to 30 tonnes of local chicken from Namib Poultry Industries but his permissible imports have been reduced monthly.

This, he says, limits his right to constitutionally protected trade.

By way of its general manager Paul Strydom, the Meat Board hit back with a scathing affidavit in which it describes the procedures for quota allocations. These, Strydom says, are based on a formula and are allocated without “fear or favour”. Currently, the maximum allowable imports are 1 500 tonnes monthly.



Enough local stock

Strydom says that Oberholzer claimed that “insufficient chicken is produced locally and he is constrained to import his monthly chicken requirements from South Africa”.

Attached to his affidavit is a letter from the commercial manager of NPI, Pieter van Niekerk, confirming sufficient local stock. The letter is dated 10 July 2019.

Van Niekerk says: “Stockpiles for the last year have been in excess of 1 000 tonnes, currently standing at 1 686 tonnes. We can supply more than 100 tonnes on whole birds or any portion of the whole bird.”

Strydom told the court that “it follows that [African Meals Catering] has little interest in supporting the local poultry industry and that it insists upon allocation of a quota well in excess of what it is entitled to with consequent prejudice to other importers (including those who give local support).”

There are currently more than 60 importers in Namibia and the total quota is shared between these companies. The allocation of quota is made by the Meat Board based on the current demand, local supply, the importer's historical market share over a period of 12 months, and the extent of the importer's purchase of locally supplied poultry in the two months preceding the application.



Low local support

Strydom is of the view that Oberholzer is well aware of the formula and yet, “expects preferential treatment”.

“Increased quota,” Strydom writes, “can only be achieved by buying locally.” Moreover, the quota can be increased if the importer provides proof that no local product is available. This, he says, Oberholzer did not do.

“I dispute [Oberholzer's] claim to giving local support. During the past 24 months, 116.3 tonnes were bought, an average of 4.8 tonnes per month of which 59% were bought over the last four months.”

With respect to Oberholzer's claims of his constitutional rights as well as “unreasonable, unfair or irrational restriction to his right of trade”, Strydom told the court that “in light of the obvious rationale and purpose behind the import restrictions, clearly made and implemented in the interest of Namibians, he disputes those grounds.

He also asked the court that the matter be dismissed because the allocations that Oberholzer wanted set aside had already expired at the end of July, having been valid for only 30 days.

In closing, Strydom also made it known that as of 1 July this year, the Meat Board would no longer manage the poultry marketing promotion scheme and the management of import permits.

Last week, before Deputy Judge President Hosea Angula, Oberholzer's counsel filed a notice that it would bring an application on 30 September to compel the Meat Board to provide the full records it has on African Meals Catering.

The matter was postponed to Wednesday of this week for a status hearing.

Tobias Louw from Theunissen, Louw and Partners appears for the Meat Board while the government attorneys act for the two ministers.

Oberholzer made the news some years ago when it came to light that he was part owner, along with former Windhoek mayor Matheus Shikongo, in August 26 Logistics at the time it was awarded the tender to supply food to the Namibian Defence Force. The then Tender Board had not given the ministry of defence an exemption to bypass it in the N$5 billion tender. Oberholzer is also a director of Natural Namibian Meat Producers, which operates the abattoir at Aranos. At the time of its establishment, Shikongo was a shareholder but it is not known whether he retains those shares at this time.

The matter of chicken imports has been in the news of late, in particular with the South African Poultry Association trying to have import restrictions removed in the Namibian High Court in spite of asking for increased protection in their own country, and the recent revelation that roughly 5 000 tonnes of chicken were imported illegally into the country last year.

YANNA SMITH

Similar News

 

No reprieve for Fishrot 6

4 days ago - 21 February 2020 | Justice

The so-called Fishrot Six yesterday returned to the Windhoek Magistrate's Court, which ordered that they be remanded in custody until 23 April to allow for...

Judiciary hits back

6 days ago - 19 February 2020 | Justice

The Office of the Judiciary has defended itself against “undue attacks”, including a Landless People's Movement (LPM) allegation that it has been captured by the...

Lack of funds bedevils access to justice

1 week ago - 14 February 2020 | Justice

Namibia is struggling to serve justice because of inadequate funding, Chief Justice Petrus Shivute said at the official opening of the legal year this week....

Hands off Judiciary - Geingob

1 week ago - 13 February 2020 | Justice

President Hage Geingob has cautioned Namibians not to question the integrity of the Judiciary, because that would cause chaos or anarchy. Geingob was speaking...

Courts' hands tied

1 week ago - 12 February 2020 | Justice

Money and staff shortages have led to the National Forensic Science Institute (NFSI) being unable to conduct scientific examinations on time, which is causing court...

Court scraps EVMs without trail

2 weeks ago - 06 February 2020 | Justice

The Supreme Court yesterday declared that the use of electronic voting machines (EVMs) without a paper trail during the November 2019 presidential election was unconstitutional,...

Captain fined N$950k, Samherji vessel released

2 weeks ago - 06 February 2020 | Justice

The captain of an Icelandic vessel linked to the Fishrot bribery scandal has been fined N$950 000 or 12 years in prison by the Walvis...

Supreme Court upholds presidential poll result

2 weeks ago - 05 February 2020 | Justice

JEMIMA BEUKESThe Supreme Court has ruled it will not nullify the result and order a rerun of the 2019 presidential election, which means that Hage...

Itula vs Geingob: Endgame beckons

2 weeks ago - 05 February 2020 | Justice

STAFF REPORTER With judgment in the presidential election challenge brought by independent presidential candidate Dr Panduleni Itula set to be handed down...

Hanse-Himarwa suffers setback

3 weeks ago - 04 February 2020 | Justice

Former education minister Katrina Hanse-Himarwa suffered a setback yesterday when High Court judge Christie Liebenberg struck her appeal from the roll, saying he did not...

Latest News

Renter’s market a home truth

23 hours ago | Business

Jo-Maré Duddy – Potential tenants enjoy increasingly bigger bargaining power in the deposits they are willing to pay to rent a property in Namibia, the...

Swapo's moral compass is lost...

23 hours ago | Politics

Former Swapo secretary-general Pendukeni Iivula-Ithana said her party is encouraging a culture of 'convicted honourables' by not taking a firm and consistent stand on how...

Willem's 30km school walk on...

23 hours ago | Education

A 16-year-old boy from Vikota village in Kavango East Region walks 30 kilometres to and from school every day while only having one meal that...

Govt still tight-lipped on fishermen...

23 hours ago | Business

Acting fisheries minister Albert Kawana says he is waiting on Cabinet for “certain approvals” before making public pronouncements on the nuts and bolts of how...

TOV to inaugurate poultry enterprise

23 hours ago | Business

The TOV HIV/AIDS Orphans and Vulnerable Children Organisation based in Tsumeb will inaugurate its poultry enterprise worth N$1.1 million on Thursday. TOV and its partners...

First-time winner at 71!

23 hours ago | Business

Petrus du Plooy (71) answered a call two weeks ago informing him that he was a winner, although he had yet to find out what...

Stranded Africans plead to be...

23 hours ago | Economics

Elias Biryabarema and Josiane Kouagheu – When Margaret Ntale Namusisi's three daughters called her in Uganda to say they were being quarantined at their university...

Nandi-Ndaitwah whips up voters

23 hours ago | Politics

Swapo vice-president Netumbo Nandi-Ndaitwah launched the party's campaign for the Opuwo Rural by-election last Saturday by calling on voters to turn up in numbers on...

Independence is worth celebrating

23 hours ago | Opinion

“Freedom is not worth having if it does not include the freedom to make mistakes,” the great Mahatma Gandhi once said. Namibia is currently embroiled...

Load More