Aupindi's appeal dismissed

The former NWR boss was unsuccessful in his bid to have corruption charges against him and a co-accused set aside.

17 July 2017 | Justice

Former CEO of Namibia Wildlife Resorts Tobie Aupindi’s bid to review and set aside the contravention of provisions of the Anti-Corruption Act charges levelled against him was dismissed with costs by the full bench of the Supreme Court.

Aupindi had appealed against the judgment of the High Court after it dismissed his and his co-accused, Antonio Di Savino’s, application to review and set aside criminal proceedings before the Windhoek Magistrate’s Court.

The full bench was made up of Judges of Appeal Sylvester Mainga, Elton Hoff and Acting Judge of Appeal, Theo Frank.

“The refusal by the prosecutor-general to terminate the proceedings against the appellant and Savino, who is cited in the application as tenth respondent, could thus not be faulted,” the court found.

The highest court further held that the statements containing the alleged untoward conduct of the first respondent amounted to inadmissible hearsay evidence.

It concluded that Aupindi and Savino had failed to establish the facts necessary for them to either infer bias or a reasonable apprehension of bias.

“The appeal is dismissed with costs,” the Supreme Court ruled.

The criminal trial has not been finalised because it was interrupted by a recusal application.

Aupindi and Savino are both on trial for various charges under the Anti-Corruption Act.

They have both pleaded not guilty.

The trial was presided over by Magistrate Helvi Shilemba.

The State led evidence to establish that the appellant had not paid the costs involved in the installation of a swimming pool at his residence.

At the conclusion of the state case, both accused applied for discharge on all charges.

However, Shilemba dismissed the application and postponed the trial to a later date.

At the resumption of the trial, Aupindi called a certain Mr MacKay who is a former policeman and detective who he had requested to do certain investigations on his behalf.

In his testimony, the witness produced statements that he had procured from certain persons with allegations that Shilemba and the prosecutors were plotting to convict him on the charges he is facing, prompting Aupindi and Savino to make an application for recusal of the magistrate, saying they would not get a fair trial.

Shilemba after hearing the evidence dismissed the application on the basis that the duo failed to establish facts to prove that there was reasonable apprehension of bias on their part.

Aupindi and Savino dissatisfied with the ruling, brought a review application in the High Court to set aside Shilemba’s ruling.

However the High Court dismissed the review application and referred the case back to the Magistrate’s Court to proceed with the criminal trial against the two.

Aupindi in his appeal argued that the investigation by an official of the Anti-Corruption Commission was flawed and that the official failed to take a statement from the owner of the entity, a certain Mr Kühn, who had installed the swimming pool and who corroborated his version and Savino’s.

He further argued that the prosecutor should not have proceeded with the trial because the prosecutor-general was unaware of the corroborating version of Kühn when she decided to proceed with the prosecution.

In the recusal application the bone of contention was that the statements presented were sworn statements that indicated untoward conduct of the first respondent and this in itself was sufficient to create a reasonable apprehension of bias.


Similar News


Liquidators' powers reined in

18 hours ago | Justice

The extra powers granted to the two liquidators, Dave Bruni and Ian McLaren, by the High Court on 2 February, under whose management the liquidated...

Media censorship by 'apartheid' law condemned

1 day - 18 April 2018 | Justice

Media institutions have condemned the use of old apartheid laws to censor and silence the Namibian media and called on the government to immediately withdraw...

Witness bungles serial rape case

2 days ago - 17 April 2018 | Justice

FRED GOEIEMAN A defence witness in the trial of a 33-year-old man facing a murder charge and a number of...

Court spat puts prosecutor in jail

3 days ago - 16 April 2018 | Justice

A Windhoek public prosecutor, who was sentenced to 30 days' imprisonment on Friday after he was found guilty of contempt of court, was released later...

Chiradza gets bail

3 days ago - 16 April 2018 | Justice

The now notorious Otjiwarongo-based doctor, Yevai Chiradza, was granted bail on Friday in the matter of a 2015 crash he was involved in which killed...

Son appears for matricide

1 week ago - 12 April 2018 | Justice

Fillemon Uupindi, who allegedly killed his 66-year-old mother in the Omusati Region over the weekend, briefly appeared in the Oshakati Magistrate's Court on a charge...

Rape accused doctor in hospital

1 week ago - 12 April 2018 | Justice

A bail application by a doctor charged with raping a 20-year-old student could not be heard by the Oshakati Magistrate's Court yesterday.Bernhard Shitende Mulumba (40),...

14 years for girlfriend's murder

1 week ago - 12 April 2018 | Justice

A 22-year-old man has been sentenced to an effective 14 years in prison for strangling his girlfriend, 19-year-old Janetta Babiep, to death at farm Warmfontein...

Hit-and-run trial set for August

1 week ago - 11 April 2018 | Justice

The trial of the man accused of killing Junias Smith (23) with a red BMW in August 2016, and then fleeing the scene of the...

Magdalena Stoffels 'case' makes comeback

1 week ago - 11 April 2018 | Justice

Hope glimmers for man who says he was victimised in the aftermath of the murder of Magdalena Stoffels, as the Supreme Court struck from the...

Latest News

Johannes promoted following gold

18 hours ago | Sports

Gold medallist Helalia Johannes has been promoted to the rank of Warrant Officer Class Two with immediate effect, after she won Namibia’s second gold medal...

Etosha debacle sparks national probe

18 hours ago | Environment

The environment ministry has launched a full-scale investigation at the Deeds Office in Windhoek to determine whether there is any privately owned land in Namibia's...

Acute teacher shortage

18 hours ago | Economics

The education ministry has appealed for leniency and recognition that despite the directive to reduce state wage bills the ministry is in dire need of...

Africa briefs

18 hours ago | Economics

SA's auditor general cancels all contracts with KPMGSouth Africa’s Auditor General said on Tuesday he is terminating all contracts with auditing firm KPMG over a...

NovaNam, Lalandii start new hake...

18 hours ago | Business

Staff reporter - Last week, Lüderitz-based hake fishing companies, NovaNam and Lalandii, commenced with the cutting of the steel to build the...

Ondonga heir apparent hits back...

18 hours ago | Cultural

One of the claimants to the Ondonga throne, Fillemon Shuumbwa Nangolo, has taken issue with urban and rural development minister Peya Mushelenga following his recent...

PM warns employees of shorter...

18 hours ago | Government

Prime Minister Saara Kuugongelwa-Amadhila this week warned staff members of her office that she would not accept complacency and that she would shorten the leash...

40 years after battle of...

18 hours ago | History

The Angolan president, João Lourenço will attend the Cassinga Day commemoration on 4 May as guest of honour and will lay a wreath at Heroes'...

New conservancy land disputed

18 hours ago | Environment

A Kavango West man has accused the Uukwangali Traditional Authority of stealing his land, which he claimed was now allocated to a newly proclaimed conservancy....

Load More