Aupindi's appeal dismissed

The former NWR boss was unsuccessful in his bid to have corruption charges against him and a co-accused set aside.

17 July 2017 | Justice

Former CEO of Namibia Wildlife Resorts Tobie Aupindi’s bid to review and set aside the contravention of provisions of the Anti-Corruption Act charges levelled against him was dismissed with costs by the full bench of the Supreme Court.

Aupindi had appealed against the judgment of the High Court after it dismissed his and his co-accused, Antonio Di Savino’s, application to review and set aside criminal proceedings before the Windhoek Magistrate’s Court.

The full bench was made up of Judges of Appeal Sylvester Mainga, Elton Hoff and Acting Judge of Appeal, Theo Frank.

“The refusal by the prosecutor-general to terminate the proceedings against the appellant and Savino, who is cited in the application as tenth respondent, could thus not be faulted,” the court found.

The highest court further held that the statements containing the alleged untoward conduct of the first respondent amounted to inadmissible hearsay evidence.

It concluded that Aupindi and Savino had failed to establish the facts necessary for them to either infer bias or a reasonable apprehension of bias.

“The appeal is dismissed with costs,” the Supreme Court ruled.

The criminal trial has not been finalised because it was interrupted by a recusal application.

Aupindi and Savino are both on trial for various charges under the Anti-Corruption Act.

They have both pleaded not guilty.

The trial was presided over by Magistrate Helvi Shilemba.

The State led evidence to establish that the appellant had not paid the costs involved in the installation of a swimming pool at his residence.

At the conclusion of the state case, both accused applied for discharge on all charges.

However, Shilemba dismissed the application and postponed the trial to a later date.

At the resumption of the trial, Aupindi called a certain Mr MacKay who is a former policeman and detective who he had requested to do certain investigations on his behalf.

In his testimony, the witness produced statements that he had procured from certain persons with allegations that Shilemba and the prosecutors were plotting to convict him on the charges he is facing, prompting Aupindi and Savino to make an application for recusal of the magistrate, saying they would not get a fair trial.

Shilemba after hearing the evidence dismissed the application on the basis that the duo failed to establish facts to prove that there was reasonable apprehension of bias on their part.

Aupindi and Savino dissatisfied with the ruling, brought a review application in the High Court to set aside Shilemba’s ruling.

However the High Court dismissed the review application and referred the case back to the Magistrate’s Court to proceed with the criminal trial against the two.

Aupindi in his appeal argued that the investigation by an official of the Anti-Corruption Commission was flawed and that the official failed to take a statement from the owner of the entity, a certain Mr Kühn, who had installed the swimming pool and who corroborated his version and Savino’s.

He further argued that the prosecutor should not have proceeded with the trial because the prosecutor-general was unaware of the corroborating version of Kühn when she decided to proceed with the prosecution.

In the recusal application the bone of contention was that the statements presented were sworn statements that indicated untoward conduct of the first respondent and this in itself was sufficient to create a reasonable apprehension of bias.


Similar News


Murder accused a no-show at trial

1 day - 19 September 2017 | Justice

A 50-year-old man from Karasburg, who is accused of killing his girlfriend, failed to turn up at the start of his trial where he also...

To bail or not

2 days ago - 18 September 2017 | Justice

Dozens of magistrates attended a workshop in Windhoek on Friday to fine-tune an understanding of the legal principles governing the granting of bail.A public outcry...

Lengthy delay in murder case

2 days ago - 18 September 2017 | Justice

The case against five men accused of killing Walvis Bay businessman Hans Jorg Möller has been postponed to 24 October. The accused appeared...

Inmate demands parole

5 days ago - 15 September 2017 | Justice

An inmate at the Windhoek Correctional Facility is demanding to be released on parole with immediate effect.Jermano Jeraldo Eiseb, in an urgent application filed with...

Namibian skulls found in US museum

6 days ago - 14 September 2017 | Justice

Four skulls of Nama and Ovaherero origin have been found in the Museum of Natural History of New York. According to Ovaherero Paramount Chief...

Alleged killer cop wants his job back

6 days ago - 14 September 2017 | Justice

FRED GOEIEMAN A former Gobabis police constable accused of murdering his two sons wants reinstatement in the force with the...

Schiefer gets 6 years' reprieve

1 week ago - 13 September 2017 | Justice

A young man serving an effective 48 years for the murder of his mother and father in 2008 received only partial reprieve from the Supreme...

Court gives drought-stricken farmer a break

1 week ago - 13 September 2017 | Justice

The High Court in Windhoek has shown leniency to a communal farmer who removed cattle from his drought-stricken farm in the Kunene Region without a...

Rhino horn suspect absconds

1 week ago - 12 September 2017 | Justice

A Chinese man accused of dealing in controlled wildlife products with a combined value of N$320 000 yesterday failed to turn up for court proceedings....

Suspects in bank theft denied bail

1 week ago - 08 September 2017 | Justice

Three of the six suspects arrested for a break-in at Bank Windhoek's Rehoboth branch, where N$1.3 million was stolen, have appeared before the Rehoboth Magistrate's...

Latest News

Namibian Sun turns 10

7 hours ago | History

We are proud to announce that your favourite newspaper, Namibian Sun, has reached an important milestone and is celebrating ten years of existence today. ...

MTC is sorry, free data...

7 hours ago | Technology

Namibia's telecommunications giant MTC hopes that a public apology and declaration of love for their 2.4 million customers, in addition to 300 megabytes of free...

'Teachers are overworked'

7 hours ago | Labour

The Teachers' Union of Namibia (TUN) has accused the government of deliberately overburdening teachers in order to save money while high-ranking officials are living in...

Topnaars fear donkey theft

7 hours ago | Agriculture

The Topnaar community living along the Kuiseb River in the Erongo Region is concerned that proposed donkey abattoirs could lead to an increase in donkey...

Govt explains UN vote

7 hours ago | International

The government has reiterated its commitment to the cause of human rights and ending suffering, and that it must be done through recognised bodies such...

Car crashes kill over 500...

7 hours ago | Accidents

More than 500 people have died in car accidents since January, according to the Motor Vehicle Accident (MVA) Fund.With three months to go until the...

Stepfather arrested on rape charge

7 hours ago | Crime

The Omusati police have arrested a 59-year-old man from Okalongo who is accused of having slept with his 17-year-old stepdaughter.Namibian Sun on Monday reported that...

Ex-manager pleads not guilty

7 hours ago | Crime

The State yesterday put charges to the former marketing manager of MultiChoice Namibia and she promptly denied that she had defrauded the company of more...

N$70k cash stolen from Ya...

7 hours ago | Crime

The wife of former Robben Island prisoner and icon of the Namibian national liberation struggle, Andimba Toivo Ya Toivo, has fallen victim to theft after...

Load More