Appeal court overturns farmer's wife killer conviction

08 May 2020 | Crime

ELLANIE SMIT

WINDHOEK



The Supreme Court has found that an appeal by farmer Willem Visagie Barnard, who was found guilty of killing his wife in 2018, should succeed.



His conviction and sentence have thus been set aside.

This is according to a judgement by Judge Dave Smuts, in agreement with Judge Elton Hoff, who said Barnard was entitled to an acquittal.



Barnard was found guilty by Windhoek High Court judge Naomi Shivute of killing his 55-year-old wife, Anette Barnard, with a single gunshot to the head at the couple's farm, Choris, in the Aranos area in April 2010.











Blacked out



Barnard claimed he had blacked out after a heavy drinking session combined with prescription drugs.



He said when he “woke up”, he found the deceased with her head on a coffee table with a bullet wound through her skull.



However, Judge Shivute was not inclined to believe his version of events.



The High Court found Barnard guilty of murder with direct intent on 23 January 2018.



He was sentenced to 18 years imprisonment with 10 years suspended on certain conditions.







Refused leave to appeal



“The High Court refused leave to appeal and leave was subsequently granted by this court on 23 October 2018 in respect of one aspect, namely on the question as to whether there was a reasonable possibility that the deceased committed suicide,” yesterday's Supreme Court judgement said.



The judgement pointed out that despite the overwhelming and unanimous evidence of those who attended the crime scene, that the appellant was very drunk, and which was also the express finding of the High Court, the main judgment comes to a contrary conclusion merely because a bottle of brandy encountered at the scene was half or quarter full.







Beyond reasonable doubt



According to the Supreme Court, the question that must be answered is whether the State's case had been proved beyond reasonable doubt when measured against the accused's conflicting version, or whether Barnard's version is reasonably possibly true, even if the court does not believe him.



“Whilst guarding against 'compartmentalisation' of evidentiary considerations, the court must measure the totality of the evidence, not in isolation, but by assessing properly whether in the light of the inherent strengths, weaknesses, probabilities and improbabilities on both sides, the balance weighs so heavily in favour of the State, that it excludes any reasonable doubt about the accused's guilt in one's mind.”



The Supreme Court ruling said that by applying this test to the facts of the matter, the State has not proven Barnard's guilt beyond reasonable doubt.

Similar News

 

Massive drop in crime rate

10 hours ago | Crime

ELLANIE SMITWINDHOEK Namibia has recorded a huge drop in the number of serious crimes such as murders, attempted murders and rapes since the coronavirus state...

Cops open N$14m fraud case

1 day - 02 June 2020 | Crime

EDWARD MUMBUU JNRWINDHOEKThe police have opened a case against businessman Amos Shiyuka for allegedly defrauding it of N$14.2 million.Official documents seen by Nampa show that...

Three toddlers drown

1 day - 02 June 2020 | Crime

ELLANIE SMITWINDHOEKThree toddlers drowned this weekend, while a man assaulted his sister with a broomstick.In two of the three drowning incidents, the toddlers drowned in...

Daylight robbers overturn getaway car

2 days ago - 01 June 2020 | Crime

ILENI NANDJATOOMAALALATwo suspects were still at large yesterday after the getaway vehicle four persons used in a robbery at Ondangwa on Friday overturned at Omaalala...

Fishrot investigations far from over

2 days ago - 01 June 2020 | Crime

NAMPA WINDHOEKInvestigations into the Fishrot case are far from complete for the setting of a trial date, because only four out of the nine involved...

Poaching suspects appear in camera

5 days ago - 29 May 2020 | Crime

ELLANIE SMITWINDHOEK Four of the eight suspects arrested in connection with the alleged poaching of two rhino horns near Gobabis appeared in the...

Girl repeatedly raped for years

6 days ago - 28 May 2020 | Crime

ELLANIE SMIT WINDHOEK Several rapes of minors by adult men, which sometimes stretched over months or years, were reported this past weekend....

Khomas boozers cough up

1 week ago - 27 May 2020 | Crime

ELLANIE SMITWINDHOEK The number of people arrested for violating alcohol restrictions in the Khomas Region has doubled during stage two of the coronavirus lockdown period,...

Disabled girl gang raped by 12 boys

1 week ago - 22 May 2020 | Crime

Kenya Kambowe RUNDU Police in Kavango East are investigating a case of a 14-year-old disabled girl from Rundu's Kaisosi location who was allegedly...

Man dies at China Town shop

2 weeks ago - 20 May 2020 | Crime

ELLANIE SMIT WINDHOEK A 27-year-old Namibian man died at China Town in Windhoek yesterday morning when a wall collapsed and fell on...

Latest News

NBL ready to deliver

10 hours ago | Business

Phillepus UusikuLife is slowing returning to normal as Namibians navigate the country’s gradual reopening following an easing of trade restrictions which were necessitated to combat...

Treasury demands reports of lockdown...

10 hours ago | Economics

OGONE TLHAGEWINDHOEKThe ministry of finance will demand full reports from public entities, ministries, agencies and offices detailing procurement expenditure incurred during stage one of the...

Over 120 lose jobs at...

10 hours ago | Labour

KENYA KAMBOWERUNDUAbout 120 people lost their jobs yesterday after a fallout between Chinese-born business magnate Stina Wu and a subcontractor that labour inspectors found to...

Namibia’s food security paradox

10 hours ago | Agriculture

Venomukona Tjiseua, sustainable agriculturalist: “The government must revisit its priority list and place agriculture at its correct spot.”With jobs disappearing, incomes drying up and savings...

The contest for hearts and...

10 hours ago | Opinion

Nightfall does not come all at once, neither does oppression. In both instances, there is a twilight, when everything remains seemingly unchanged.The above quote by...

Indemnity forms a matter of...

10 hours ago | Education

OGONE TLHAGEWINDHOEKWith some learners expected to return to schools today, education ministry executive director Sanet Steenkamp says parents will have to trust that schools have...

SA loosens lockdown to revive...

10 hours ago | International

South Africa sought to revive its stuttering economy on Monday with a partial lifting of its coronavirus lockdown, letting people out for work, worship or...

Rastafarian sues for N$1.4m

10 hours ago | Justice

JANA-MARI SMITHWINDHOEKA convict serving 35 years for murdering his girlfriend is suing prison authorities for N$1.4 million for cutting his hair.Petrus Fridel Frederik claims his...

No new stimulus package for...

10 hours ago | Health

STAFF REPORTERWINDHOEKGovernment will not offer new emergency income grants for residents of Walvis Bay whose town is back on lockdown for seven days after recording...

Load More