5-year shoe theft sentence slashed

23 August 2019 | Justice

A habitual petty thief who stole a N$45 pair of shoes from a discount store had his five-year prison term reduced this week during a High Court review of his case.

The original sentence was unjust and not fitting the petty crime, Acting Judge Orben Sibeya said in a review judgment.

The court upheld Musche Muchaka's theft conviction, but Sibeya said, “I hold the view that the sentence is not in accordance with justice.”

He set aside the five-year sentence, plus a previously suspended nine-month sentence for theft.

Instead, Sibeya sentenced Muchaka to an effective one year behind bars, while suspending an additional 12 months for five years on condition Muchaka is not convicted of theft for a fifth time.

Muchaka was convicted of theft three times in 2016. On the first two occasions, he was fined N$200 and N$300. On the third conviction, of stealing a packet of biscuits valued at N$41.85 at a Megasave store in December 2016, he received a two-year prison sentence.

“Notwithstanding his character manifested in his previous convictions, a sentence of five years' direct imprisonment for such a transgression cannot be justified as it is too excessive, shocking and startlingly disproportionate to the offence committed and thus not in accordance with justice,” Sibeya said, with Judge Nate Ndauendapo concurring.





Sibeya remarked that the magistrate who had imposed the sentence could not be faulted for taking this stance, as it was evident Muchaka is a habitual criminal.

He also noted that previous convictions would in appropriate cases lead to heavier sentences, but added that “such sentence should still be reasonable”.

He stressed that Muchaka's crime was “literally shoplifting from Jetmark stores”, and that the shoes had been recovered after his arrest.

Therefore, he said, the decision to impose a five-year sentence meant the magistrate had lost sight of the nature of the petty crime, as well as the nature of the prior crimes.

“The sentence to be imposed should at all times be meted out in proportion to the current offence,” Sibeya stressed.



Lucky

This is not the first time Muchaka has experienced the justice system's merciful side.

In early 2017, after he had pleaded guilty to stealing the N$41 packet of biscuits –“due to hunger” he explained, he was initially given a two-year direct prison sentence.

On review, that sentence was also set aside and declared to be disproportional to the crime committed.

Muchaka's two-year sentence was set aside, and he was given an effective nine-month prison term, and an additional nine months were conditionally suspended for five years.

This suspended sentence was added to the five-year prison sentence handed down earlier this year.



Bad habit

In 2017, when he was convicted of the biscuit theft, the magistrate reasoned that it was “evident the accused had not learned any lesson”, while also highlighting the high level of theft in the Zambezi Region and noting that it was in the interest of society to impose a custodial sentence.

Sibeya nevertheless this week stressed that despite the previous convictions of theft, the “punishment should fit the crime.”

He said the previous convictions were for “petty theft offences” and that the conviction on the charge of theft of the biscuits “is not different and I opine that it equally amounts to a petty offence”.

Moreover, he noted that the five-year prison sentence imposed against Muchaka for the theft of shoes valued at less than N$50 was based on the magistrate's view that a fine would not be appropriate as it had not stopped Muchaka from stealing again. The magistrate also noted that Muchaka had “made a mockery of the criminal justice system and disrespected it, because he knows that he would just receive suspended sentences or fines for his offences.”

Sibeya however referenced a previous High Court judgment in which the justices said: “Where it may be justifiable to impose escalating sentences on a repeat offender, there are boundaries to the extent to which sentences may be increased when dealing with petty crimes.”

JANA-MARI SMITH

Similar News

 

Lack of funds bedevils access to justice

5 days ago - 14 February 2020 | Justice

Namibia is struggling to serve justice because of inadequate funding, Chief Justice Petrus Shivute said at the official opening of the legal year this week....

Hands off Judiciary - Geingob

6 days ago - 13 February 2020 | Justice

President Hage Geingob has cautioned Namibians not to question the integrity of the Judiciary, because that would cause chaos or anarchy. Geingob was speaking...

Courts' hands tied

1 week ago - 12 February 2020 | Justice

Money and staff shortages have led to the National Forensic Science Institute (NFSI) being unable to conduct scientific examinations on time, which is causing court...

Court scraps EVMs without trail

1 week ago - 06 February 2020 | Justice

The Supreme Court yesterday declared that the use of electronic voting machines (EVMs) without a paper trail during the November 2019 presidential election was unconstitutional,...

Captain fined N$950k, Samherji vessel released

1 week ago - 06 February 2020 | Justice

The captain of an Icelandic vessel linked to the Fishrot bribery scandal has been fined N$950 000 or 12 years in prison by the Walvis...

Supreme Court upholds presidential poll result

1 week ago - 05 February 2020 | Justice

JEMIMA BEUKESThe Supreme Court has ruled it will not nullify the result and order a rerun of the 2019 presidential election, which means that Hage...

Itula vs Geingob: Endgame beckons

2 weeks ago - 05 February 2020 | Justice

STAFF REPORTER With judgment in the presidential election challenge brought by independent presidential candidate Dr Panduleni Itula set to be handed down...

Hanse-Himarwa suffers setback

2 weeks ago - 04 February 2020 | Justice

Former education minister Katrina Hanse-Himarwa suffered a setback yesterday when High Court judge Christie Liebenberg struck her appeal from the roll, saying he did not...

High Court saves widow

2 weeks ago - 31 January 2020 | Justice

The Windhoek High Court has set aside a Gciriku traditional court ruling that a widow should pay 15 heads of cattle or N$30 000 to...

Magistrate under fire for 'grossly inadequate' GBV sentence

2 weeks ago - 30 January 2020 | Justice

The prosecutor-general's office has slammed a magistrate's decision to effectively impose zero prison time for attempted murder, after a man confessed to stabbing his wife...

Latest News

Towering above the rest

14 hours ago | Sports

LIMBA MUPETAMIToday is the 24th anniversary of Frank Fredericks’ world indoor 200m record sprint in Liévin, France. He remains the world record-holder with a time...

Oryx expects better year results

1 day - 18 February 2020 | Business

Jo-Maré Duddy - Oryx Properties expects its earnings per share (EPS), headline earnings per share (HEPS) and profit for the year ended 31 December 2019...

Price monster throws consumer a...

1 day - 18 February 2020 | Economics

Consumers had to wait 15 years to kick off a new year with meat in deflation and last month didn't disappoint: Annual meat inflation in...

Teachers share rooms with learners

1 day - 18 February 2020 | Education

Some learners at Sikarosompo Primary School in Kavango West have opted to rather walk between four to 20 kilometres to and from school every day...

N$500k to create jobs

1 day - 18 February 2020 | Labour

The labour ministry only received N$500 000 in its annual budget for employment creation, its executive director Bro-Matthew Shinguadja has confirmed.“We budgeted N$500 000 and...

Cops nab Fishcor's Nghipunya

1 day - 18 February 2020 | Crime

Fishcor CEO Mike Nghipunya is being questioned in connection with the Fishrot bribery saga. Police spokesperson Deputy Commissioner Kauna Shikwambi confirmed Nghipunya's arrest yesterday.Anti-Corruption Commission...

Africa Briefs

1 day - 18 February 2020 | Economics

SA union says wage deal not open for reviewSouth African trade union NEHAWU, one of the country's largest public sector unions, said on Friday that...

SA's plans to open up...

1 day - 18 February 2020 | Business

South Africa's announcement that it will open up electricity generation to other players, effectively breaking Eskom's monopoly, has been welcomed by many, especially the mining...

Don't insult anyone, young or...

1 day - 18 February 2020 | Opinion

Police chief Sebastian Ndeitunga was at the centre of a storm all weekend for remarks he made that he would arrest young people hurling insults...

Load More