• Home
  • JUSTICE
  • Court claim fails after family member's death
DISMISSED: The High Court on Friday dismissed a case in which the family of a man who died in hospital almost 10 years ago sued the health ministry, claiming his death was caused by medical negligence. PHOTO: FILE
DISMISSED: The High Court on Friday dismissed a case in which the family of a man who died in hospital almost 10 years ago sued the health ministry, claiming his death was caused by medical negligence. PHOTO: FILE

Court claim fails after family member's death

Kristien Kruger
Four people who claimed around N$1.5 million from the state for the death of a family member, failed in their court application.

Victor Kamwi Liwela died on 15 December 2016 at the Katutura State Hospital and the family alleged the doctors and nursing staff acted in defiance of their duty, which they claim subsequently led to Liwela's death

The deceased's brother, Obrine Liwela; his son, Carl Liwela; his niece, Katrina Liwela; and a representative of his two minor children, Shozi Liwela, filed the case against the Ministry of Health and Social Services in 2018.

They argued that the deceased was in the hospital for two days, failed to diagnose his condition properly, and allegedly failed to treat him on an urgent basis. Additionally, they argued that the staff did not monitor his condition.

Obrine Liwela testified during the trial that the manner in which Victor died traumatised them as a family. “They trusted the hospital to help the deceased get better, but instead they neglected him and caused his death through their negligence.

“They failed to monitor his condition with the proper care expected of medical practitioners. It was their duty to help him and look after him, but they didn't do it," he claimed in court.



CASE DISMISSED

The High Court in Windhoek dismissed the claim on Friday after the health ministry brought an application for absolution from the instance.

The application was brought after the Liwelas closed their case and is based on the claim that they did not provide sufficient evidence to succeed in their application.

Judge Shafimana Ueitele granted the application and struck the case from the roll.

“The plaintiffs' evidence in relation to the defendant's alleged breach of his legal duty was weak, unreliable, improbable and not credible.

"Based on the law and the evidence placed before the court, I find that there is no evidence on which a court, applying its opinion reasonably to such evidence, could find in favour of the plaintiffs."

There was no cost order made against the Liwela family.

Comments

Namibian Sun 2025-02-14

No comments have been left on this article

Please login to leave a comment

Six Nations: Scotland 18 vs 32 Ireland | England 26 vs 25 France | Italy 22 vs 15 Wales Premier League: Everton 2 vs 2 Liverpool Katima Mulilo: 18° | 28° Rundu: 18° | 28° Eenhana: 18° | 27° Oshakati: 19° | 27° Ruacana: 18° | 27° Tsumeb: 18° | 25° Otjiwarongo: 18° | 24° Omaruru: 19° | 29° Windhoek: 19° | 28° Gobabis: 19° | 22° Henties Bay: 18° | 22° Wind speed: 21km/h, Wind direction: W, Low tide: 10:40, High tide: 04:44, Low Tide: 22:43, High tide: 16:54 Swakopmund: 17° | 18° Wind speed: 17km/h, Wind direction: NW, Low tide: 10:38, High tide: 04:42, Low Tide: 22:41, High tide: 16:52 Walvis Bay: 18° | 21° Wind speed: 18km/h, Wind direction: NW, Low tide: 10:38, High tide: 04:41, Low Tide: 22:41, High tide: 16:51 Rehoboth: 21° | 30° Mariental: 24° | 35° Keetmanshoop: 26° | 37° Aranos: 21° | 33° Lüderitz: 15° | 27° Ariamsvlei: 24° | 39° Oranjemund: 15° | 23° Luanda: 26° | 29° Gaborone: 20° | 31° Lubumbashi: 17° | 21° Mbabane: 17° | 24° Maseru: 18° | 31° Antananarivo: 18° | 22° Lilongwe: 19° | 29° Maputo: 22° | 31° Windhoek: 19° | 28° Cape Town: 19° | 24° Durban: 21° | 24° Johannesburg: 18° | 30° Dar es Salaam: 26° | 32° Lusaka: 17° | 19° Harare: 17° | 23° Currency: GBP to NAD 23.06 | EUR to NAD 19.25 | CNY to NAD 2.53 | USD to NAD 18.35 | DZD to NAD 0.14 | AOA to NAD 0.02 | BWP to NAD 1.28 | EGP to NAD 0.35 | KES to NAD 0.14 | NGN to NAD 0.01 | ZMW to NAD 0.64 | ZWL to NAD 0.04 | BRL to NAD 3.21 | RUB to NAD 0.2 | INR to NAD 0.21 | USD to DZD 134.95 | USD to AOA 912 | USD to BWP 13.83 | USD to EGP 50.59 | USD to KES 129.22 | USD to NGN 1509 | USD to ZAR 18.36 | USD to ZMW 28.15 | USD to ZWL 321 | Stock Exchange: JSE All Share Index 88717.13 Up +1.00% | Namibian Stock Exchange (NSX) Overall Index 1797.63 Up +0.36% | Casablanca Stock Exchange (CSE) MASI 16452.23 Up +0.33% | Egyptian Exchange (EGX) 30 Index 29997.11 Up +1.13% | Botswana Stock Exchange (BSE) DCI 10063.87 Same 0 | NSX: MTC 7.75 SAME | Anirep 8.99 SAME | Capricorn Investment group 17.34 SAME | FirstRand Namibia Ltd 49 DOWN 0.50% | Letshego Holdings (Namibia) Ltd 4.1 UP 2.50% | Namibia Asset Management Ltd 0.7 SAME | Namibia Breweries Ltd 31.49 UP 0.03% | Nictus Holdings - Nam 2.22 SAME | Oryx Properties Ltd 12.1 UP 1.70% | Paratus Namibia Holdings 11.99 SAME | SBN Holdings 8.45 SAME | Trustco Group Holdings Ltd 0.48 SAME | B2Gold Corporation 47.34 DOWN 1.50% | Local Index closed 677.62 UP 0.12% | Overall Index closed 1534.6 DOWN 0.05% | Osino Resources Corp 19.47 DOWN 2.41% | Commodities: Gold US$ 2 880.61/OZ DOWN -0.0173 | Copper US$ 4.63/lb DOWN -0.0255 | Zinc US$ 2 857.30/T DOWN -0.07% | Brent Crude Oil US$ 74.98/BBP DOWN -0.009 | Platinum US$ 1 003.32/OZ DOWN -0.0343 Sport results: Six Nations: Scotland 18 vs 32 Ireland | England 26 vs 25 France | Italy 22 vs 15 Wales Premier League: Everton 2 vs 2 Liverpool Weather: Katima Mulilo: 18° | 28° Rundu: 18° | 28° Eenhana: 18° | 27° Oshakati: 19° | 27° Ruacana: 18° | 27° Tsumeb: 18° | 25° Otjiwarongo: 18° | 24° Omaruru: 19° | 29° Windhoek: 19° | 28° Gobabis: 19° | 22° Henties Bay: 18° | 22° Wind speed: 21km/h, Wind direction: W, Low tide: 10:40, High tide: 04:44, Low Tide: 22:43, High tide: 16:54 Swakopmund: 17° | 18° Wind speed: 17km/h, Wind direction: NW, Low tide: 10:38, High tide: 04:42, Low Tide: 22:41, High tide: 16:52 Walvis Bay: 18° | 21° Wind speed: 18km/h, Wind direction: NW, Low tide: 10:38, High tide: 04:41, Low Tide: 22:41, High tide: 16:51 Rehoboth: 21° | 30° Mariental: 24° | 35° Keetmanshoop: 26° | 37° Aranos: 21° | 33° Lüderitz: 15° | 27° Ariamsvlei: 24° | 39° Oranjemund: 15° | 23° Luanda: 26° | 29° Gaborone: 20° | 31° Lubumbashi: 17° | 21° Mbabane: 17° | 24° Maseru: 18° | 31° Antananarivo: 18° | 22° Lilongwe: 19° | 29° Maputo: 22° | 31° Windhoek: 19° | 28° Cape Town: 19° | 24° Durban: 21° | 24° Johannesburg: 18° | 30° Dar es Salaam: 26° | 32° Lusaka: 17° | 19° Harare: 17° | 23° Economic Indicators: Currency: GBP to NAD 23.06 | EUR to NAD 19.25 | CNY to NAD 2.53 | USD to NAD 18.35 | DZD to NAD 0.14 | AOA to NAD 0.02 | BWP to NAD 1.28 | EGP to NAD 0.35 | KES to NAD 0.14 | NGN to NAD 0.01 | ZMW to NAD 0.64 | ZWL to NAD 0.04 | BRL to NAD 3.21 | RUB to NAD 0.2 | INR to NAD 0.21 | USD to DZD 134.95 | USD to AOA 912 | USD to BWP 13.83 | USD to EGP 50.59 | USD to KES 129.22 | USD to NGN 1509 | USD to ZAR 18.36 | USD to ZMW 28.15 | USD to ZWL 321 | Stock Exchange: JSE All Share Index 88717.13 Up +1.00% | Namibian Stock Exchange (NSX) Overall Index 1797.63 Up +0.36% | Casablanca Stock Exchange (CSE) MASI 16452.23 Up +0.33% | Egyptian Exchange (EGX) 30 Index 29997.11 Up +1.13% | Botswana Stock Exchange (BSE) DCI 10063.87 Same 0 | NSX: MTC 7.75 SAME | Anirep 8.99 SAME | Capricorn Investment group 17.34 SAME | FirstRand Namibia Ltd 49 DOWN 0.50% | Letshego Holdings (Namibia) Ltd 4.1 UP 2.50% | Namibia Asset Management Ltd 0.7 SAME | Namibia Breweries Ltd 31.49 UP 0.03% | Nictus Holdings - Nam 2.22 SAME | Oryx Properties Ltd 12.1 UP 1.70% | Paratus Namibia Holdings 11.99 SAME | SBN Holdings 8.45 SAME | Trustco Group Holdings Ltd 0.48 SAME | B2Gold Corporation 47.34 DOWN 1.50% | Local Index closed 677.62 UP 0.12% | Overall Index closed 1534.6 DOWN 0.05% | Osino Resources Corp 19.47 DOWN 2.41% | Commodities: Gold US$ 2 880.61/OZ DOWN -0.0173 | Copper US$ 4.63/lb DOWN -0.0255 | Zinc US$ 2 857.30/T DOWN -0.07% | Brent Crude Oil US$ 74.98/BBP DOWN -0.009 | Platinum US$ 1 003.32/OZ DOWN -0.0343